Heard this on the radio about Dan Quinn and penalties

TequilaCowboy

TequilaCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,285
Reaction score
7,334
AsthmaField said:
To answer the question… yes, aggressive. I always like aggressive defense, even if it causes a few more penalties.

I promise you that the opposing offense would rather see a passive defense with no penalties, than an aggressive, in your face defense that gets some penalties.
Click to expand...

An aggressive defense can also result in turnovers which will negate some of those penalties. Aggressive all the way.
 
CWR

CWR

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,586
Reaction score
34,309
Dre11 said:
Kinda long but needed to setup the question. Now I'm not blaming Dan, because I feel it's on the players mental focus .
But a radi0 hist on 105.3 fan pointed out after researching was that each year Dan was the main DC on a team
Seattle 2 years (legion of boom) 1 year Here the team was number 1 in penalties. What I find interesting is they won a superbowl in Seattle ranking #1 in penalties. Went to the superbowl and was 12-5 here. Which leads to this, his defenses are very aggressive which Could lead to more flags, ( haven't did the research on if the defense lead the way in penalties or offense)
Here's the question if the aggressive style is the major culprit, what would you choose. Have a less aggressive defense or continue being the aggressive defense and live with the flags?
Click to expand...

I'll take penalties and a #1 defense who forces turn overs any day.

It's the offensive penalties that hurt the most, because it's so difficult to overcome 2nd and 20 when we can't run against a cover 2.
 

Irse

Member
Messages
43
Reaction score
41
League ave.
Offensive Holding 34 21.13
False Start 20 18.75
Unnecessary Roughness 10 5.38
Defensive Pass Interference 10 9.63
Neutral Zone Infraction 10 3.63
Defensive Offside 8 4.97
Delay of Game 6 5.38
Defensive Holding 6 5.16
Illegal Use of Hands 5 2.34
Illegal Block Above the Waist 4 2.22
Roughing the Passer 3 4.81
Illegal Formation 3 2.13
Face Mask (15 Yards) 2 2.31
Illegal Contact 2 0.88
Horse Collar Tackle 2 0.47
Encroachment 2 1.16
Ineligible Downfield Pass 2 1.44
Defensive Too Many Men on Field 2 1.13
Offensive Pass Interference 1 2.5
Illegal Shift 1 0.81
Roughing the Kicker 1 0.31
Unsportsmanlike Conduct 1 1.31
Offside on Free Kick 1 0.13
Chop Block 1 0.19
Disqualification 1 0.16
Offensive Too Many Men on Field 1 0.31
Player Out of Bounds on Kick 1 0.19
Illegal Double-Team Block 1 0.31

https://www.nflpenalties.com/team/dallas-cowboys?year=2021&view=penalties
 
817Gill

817Gill

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,141
Reaction score
19,113
Dre11 said:
Kinda long but needed to setup the question. Now I'm not blaming Dan, because I feel it's on the players mental focus .
But a radi0 hist on 105.3 fan pointed out after researching was that each year Dan was the main DC on a team
Seattle 2 years (legion of boom) 1 year Here the team was number 1 in penalties. What I find interesting is they won a superbowl in Seattle ranking #1 in penalties. Went to the superbowl and was 12-5 here. Which leads to this, his defenses are very aggressive which Could lead to more flags, ( haven't did the research on if the defense lead the way in penalties or offense)
Here's the question if the aggressive style is the major culprit, what would you choose. Have a less aggressive defense or continue being the aggressive defense and live with the flags?
Click to expand...
Why did you leave out the Falcons years, just because he was HC? I watched the 105.3 segment as well, once they realized his Falcons days he was middle to the pack or better in penalties they said they were thrown off as well.

I think the Seattle penalties are easy as heck to explain. They began a style of defense that used huge and physical DB’s to play an aggressive style of defense. Those Brandon Browner was a penalty machine and ended up continuing after leaving Seattle. Those guys were just so big and physical that they were obviously going to generate a lot of penalties.

I don’t think this info is as damning as the stat would suggest.
 
OGCowboy

OGCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
927
Reaction score
1,556
This team has been soft...we all know that
At this point I want mean, blood spitting aggressive play. I’ll even take an ejection here and there.
 

Hardline

Well-Known Member
Messages
20,795
Reaction score
36,313
I played football from 5th grade to high school varsity and was a starter for the most of it. Played offense and defense and all that time I only committed one penalty and that was taking off downfield on the kickoff team before the ball was kicked.
Playing good sound fundamental football will take care of the penalty issues.
The problem the Cowboys have is getting called for penalties that didn't actually happen.
 
Rockport

Rockport

AmberBeer
Messages
41,344
Reaction score
41,297
Dre11 said:
Kinda long but needed to setup the question. Now I'm not blaming Dan, because I feel it's on the players mental focus .
But a radi0 hist on 105.3 fan pointed out after researching was that each year Dan was the main DC on a team
Seattle 2 years (legion of boom) 1 year Here the team was number 1 in penalties. What I find interesting is they won a superbowl in Seattle ranking #1 in penalties. Went to the superbowl and was 12-5 here. Which leads to this, his defenses are very aggressive which Could lead to more flags, ( haven't did the research on if the defense lead the way in penalties or offense)
Here's the question if the aggressive style is the major culprit, what would you choose. Have a less aggressive defense or continue being the aggressive defense and live with the flags?
Click to expand...
I wouldn’t pay too much attention to anything you hear on the radio.
 
nalam

nalam

The realist
Messages
11,032
Reaction score
6,503
Dre11 said:
Kinda long but needed to setup the question. Now I'm not blaming Dan, because I feel it's on the players mental focus …..
Here's the question if the aggressive style is the major culprit, what would you choose. Have a less aggressive defense or continue being the aggressive defense and live with the flags?
Click to expand...

Aggressiveness is welcome, we want players to play with some aggression, Football demands it.

But knuckleheadness shouldnt be , Like the one Joseph did, on a long field goal ( 55+ yards ) you don’t commit an offside togive the other team chance.
 
Dre11

Dre11

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,686
Reaction score
11,450
817Gill said:
Why did you leave out the Falcons years, just because he was HC? I watched the 105.3 segment as well, once they realized his Falcons days he was middle to the pack or better in penalties they said they were thrown off as well.

I think the Seattle penalties are easy as heck to explain. They began a style of defense that used huge and physical DB’s to play an aggressive style of defense. Those Brandon Browner was a penalty machine and ended up continuing after leaving Seattle. Those guys were just so big and physical that they were obviously going to generate a lot of penalties.

I don’t think this info is as damning as the stat would suggest.
Click to expand...

I left out Falcons because he wasn't the DC
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top