This wasn't a bad game for Dak

ItzKelz

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,838
Reaction score
9,164
Yeah, he wasn't nearly as awful as some try to portray.
Especially compared to everyone else. 4th and 1 and our back up center and left guard miscommunicate on an assignment after Dak drove us into scoring range. A dropped TD pass by a player that is known for having great hands for his position. Multiple drops through out the game. A blocked kick because the kicker kicked it too low after being drove into scoring position. A defense that looked like the worse defense in the NFL after looking like the best defense the previous 5 games.
 

America's Cowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
33,527
Reaction score
46,947
And as a "True" Cowboy fan this makes you happy?
Having such a inept QB leading our offense.....
No comment ....you have my sympathies........:(
Absolutely! Cowboys are on the verge of winning the NFC East Division and hosting a playoff game!

What's wrong with you, Scrooge McDuck?
 

TwentyOne

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,776
Reaction score
4,405
This is just Dak. This is what he is. Now deep into his 3rd year, it is likely what he will be, with some variation +/-.

Dak is not a QB who is going to throw for 400+ every week. That was a statistical anomaly. A total outlier when you look at the body of his work.

So no, this was not a bad game from Dak. It was just a regression to his mean coming off a big week last week.

Nah, we need a premium TE to evaluate him in all fairness.
 

LACowboysFan1

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,142
Reaction score
7,230
So if Dak played better the Cowboys would have won?

If Olawale catches the pass, that's one td. If Dak hits Gallup on one of the missed passes, that's likely a td.

So now it's 23-14. Still lose.

This was a team loss - penalties at crucial times, missed tackles, poor play calling (4th and 1 or 2 and they run Zeke from 3 yards behind the line, instead of running a 235 lb quarterback, or throwing a 30 yard pass on 3rd and 4, e.g.)

Road game, and you know, it's just possible Indy is a much better team now than at the start of the season, with Luck just back from a YEAR off.

And don't forget, Indy had a coach who spent the last 7 years on the Dallas staff. Think he doesn't know at least something about how the Dallas offense works?

Let's go back to 1992. Dallas at Philadelphia. 31-7 Eagles. 4 turnovers by the Cowboys, 4 sacks given up. Cowboys 80 yards rushing, Eagles 160 yards rushing. Look familiar?

Those games happen, to every team, even good teams. To slap all the blame on Dak is not only inaccurate, it's finding fault for fault's sake, to further somebody's anti-Dak agenda...
 

Brax

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,536
Reaction score
7,302
Especially compared to everyone else. 4th and 1 and our back up center and left guard miscommunicate on an assignment after Dak drove us into scoring range. A dropped TD pass by a player that is known for having great hands for his position. Multiple drops through out the game. A blocked kick because the kicker kicked it too low after being drove into scoring position. A defense that looked like the worse defense in the NFL after looking like the best defense the previous 5 games.
here it is again, everyone else's fault but Dak, if only Dak had more great players around him, don't you people get it Dak is great, Dak is elite all hail Dak Mr. clutch.
 

nate dizzle

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,159
Reaction score
13,744
CowboysZone DIEHARD Fan
Nah, we need a premium TE to evaluate him in all fairness.
And another premium WR, the best offensive line, premium coaches and a top rushing attack, when the sun rises in the west and sets in the east, only then will we be able to accurately evaluate Dak.
 

cowboyeric8

Chicks dig crutches
Messages
5,563
Reaction score
496
We need a legitimate challenger on the roster at QB, that is the only way Jerry would see Dak shortcomings.

Doubtful. We had one in 2016.

As much as I don't want it. I've come to the realization that Dak will be here for many years to come. So I just hope he can get better.
 

LACowboysFan1

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,142
Reaction score
7,230
here it is again, everyone else's fault but Dak, if only Dak had more great players around him, don't you people get it Dak is great, Dak is elite all hail Dak Mr. clutch.

Few, if any are saying Dak is elite, come on, some like him more than others, some like him not at all, but if someone has said Dak is elite I'd like to see the post....
 

Kevinicus

Well-Known Member
Messages
19,447
Reaction score
12,216
Especially compared to everyone else. 4th and 1 and our back up center and left guard miscommunicate on an assignment after Dak drove us into scoring range. A dropped TD pass by a player that is known for having great hands for his position. Multiple drops through out the game. A blocked kick because the kicker kicked it too low after being drove into scoring position. A defense that looked like the worse defense in the NFL after looking like the best defense the previous 5 games.

After Dak drove us? So any little positive was Dak's doing. All negatives belong to someone else?

Got it. Agree to disagree.
 

LACowboysFan1

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,142
Reaction score
7,230
After Dak drove us? So any little positive was Dak's doing. All negatives belong to someone else?

Got it. Agree to disagree.

I am in agreement with you on that.

Though there are too many here (not saying you do) that insist that the only thing keeping this team from a SB win, or going 13-3 or 12-4, is Dak, and that's just as wrong..
 

Kevinicus

Well-Known Member
Messages
19,447
Reaction score
12,216
I am in agreement with you on that.

Though there are too many here (not saying you do) that insist that the only thing keeping this team from a SB win, or going 13-3 or 12-4, is Dak, and that's just as wrong..

Well, he's the biggest thing...only because improvement at his position would have the greatest impact. Other areas can be improved, but it would be much more difficult to get the necessary impact.
 

Doomsday

Rising Star
Messages
19,814
Reaction score
16,101
Especially compared to everyone else. 4th and 1 and our back up center and left guard miscommunicate on an assignment after Dak drove us into scoring range. A dropped TD pass by a player that is known for having great hands for his position. Multiple drops through out the game. A blocked kick because the kicker kicked it too low after being drove into scoring position. A defense that looked like the worse defense in the NFL after looking like the best defense the previous 5 games.

I guess the 2nd half didn't happen? Not to mention that the only reason they moved the ball in the first half was ZEKE running and making yards out of nothing from all of Dak's check downs.
 

Brax

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,536
Reaction score
7,302
Few, if any are saying Dak is elite, come on, some like him more than others, some like him not at all, but if someone has said Dak is elite I'd like to see the post....
Top 5 is elite and many posts on the board claim that he just that, also many posts of how he is better than many Elite QB's (from Brady to Aikman) I am sure you have seen many of them, my post was more in jest of the "Dak is great when he wins it's everyone else's fault when they lose", I am not a big Dak fan but realize you just do not snap your fingers a great QB appears and that due to Jerry's view Dak is the anointed one, I also have brain and a show me attitude just like I did with Meredith, Morton, White , unlike Dak all got deep in the playoffs yet they were not what the team needed to bring home a championship. On this board there are many at both extremes both extremes are wrong but reality is until Dak wins something he is just a place holder.
 

LACowboysFan1

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,142
Reaction score
7,230
Well, he's the biggest thing...only because improvement at his position would have the greatest impact. Other areas can be improved, but it would be much more difficult to get the necessary impact.

In the 2016 playoff game against the Packers, Dak had 302 yards, Zeke 125 yards rushing, Dez 132 yards passing. But the defense let Rodgers run up a 21-3 lead.

Dak was plenty good enough to win that game, but the defense let the team down. So the cry went out "We need a better defense!"/

So we draft 7 defensive players in 2017 and 3 more in 2018, get the defense to a current no. 5 defense, and now it's "We need a better quarterback!"

So what's the choices if you don't keep Dak as the starter? Only 2 - draft a stud (hopefully) qb early in the draft, or pick up a top free agent.

In the first case, we're already 8-6, won't have the top pick. Is the draft next year chock full of great prospects? Looking at Walter Football, none of the top 3 are another Aikman or such, all have accuracy issues (that people point to as a big problem with Dak) or other shortcomings. So it doesn't appear there's a good chance of getting that stud next year.

Veteran? Who's available? A Bledsoe or such, a qb who'd been to a SB and had other great stats? Don't think so. Rodgers, Brees, etc. aren't going to come to the Cowboys, even if they did, going to cost a chunk of money, and there goes your ability to get the top tight end, safety, guard, offensive tackle or 1-tech (as so many are screaming for).

I'm just saying that I don't really see any sure way for this team to move on from Dak and get a new qb in place before you have to pay the Zekes, etc. that you probably can't do after paying a big contract to a vet, or wait for a rookie to develop. Even a Mahomes is a second year guy, your hot shot rookie will likely take at least 1 year to develop, maybe 2.

I would love to improve the quarterback spot, but I'm afraid JJ has painted this team into a corner with Dak, and we're stuck with having to hope he's going to become much better...
 

Kevinicus

Well-Known Member
Messages
19,447
Reaction score
12,216
In the 2016 playoff game against the Packers, Dak had 302 yards, Zeke 125 yards rushing, Dez 132 yards passing. But the defense let Rodgers run up a 21-3 lead.

Dak was plenty good enough to win that game, but the defense let the team down. So the cry went out "We need a better defense!"/

So we draft 7 defensive players in 2017 and 3 more in 2018, get the defense to a current no. 5 defense, and now it's "We need a better quarterback!"

So what's the choices if you don't keep Dak as the starter? Only 2 - draft a stud (hopefully) qb early in the draft, or pick up a top free agent.

In the first case, we're already 8-6, won't have the top pick. Is the draft next year chock full of great prospects? Looking at Walter Football, none of the top 3 are another Aikman or such, all have accuracy issues (that people point to as a big problem with Dak) or other shortcomings. So it doesn't appear there's a good chance of getting that stud next year.

Veteran? Who's available? A Bledsoe or such, a qb who'd been to a SB and had other great stats? Don't think so. Rodgers, Brees, etc. aren't going to come to the Cowboys, even if they did, going to cost a chunk of money, and there goes your ability to get the top tight end, safety, guard, offensive tackle or 1-tech (as so many are screaming for).

I'm just saying that I don't really see any sure way for this team to move on from Dak and get a new qb in place before you have to pay the Zekes, etc. that you probably can't do after paying a big contract to a vet, or wait for a rookie to develop. Even a Mahomes is a second year guy, your hot shot rookie will likely take at least 1 year to develop, maybe 2.

I would love to improve the quarterback spot, but I'm afraid JJ has painted this team into a corner with Dak, and we're stuck with having to hope he's going to become much better...

Yeah, needing a better QB and having the ability to get one are two very different things. But not being able to get one doesn't change the fact that you need one.
 
Top