Measured solely by his performance, maybe. But, taken with the off-field nonsense, no way!
And, I loved the pick and have been a supporter.
There is that to consider and he's made that bed with his actions and I am not referring to the DV as that is still a mystery.
I also loved the pick and he was as complete a RB as I've seen come out of college up to that point and I really liked his blocking skills for the QB we had at that time.
However, they picked him with that red flag of his HC asking his Dad to move to Columbus so they went in with eyes open.
While some hammer him for the ego thing, this "kid" has been a spotlight since he was a 3 year sport player at a high quality educational high school. He's not a dumb jock. The ego is a big part of the NFL or they wouldn't have these "no other _________ can make more than me" clauses and if we think the money isn't a card that gets played within teams and the league, we need to rethink that.
I do get a kick out of all the indignation likes he's doing something to us. How dare him run his own life, he owes us, he owes the team. No, he does not owe either anything. And with all of this angst aimed at Elliott, I would be surprised at any player on that team being that way either. They all understand the real game better than any of us do.