Twitter: McCarthy on Dak

mattjames2010

Well-Known Member
Messages
21,483
Reaction score
20,162
Hit his ceiling with the 2nd most yards in the league and 4th highest QBR. Of the top 5 passers in yards this year the next closest was 14th in QBR. How are we going to be able to live with that!?

I really don't care about passing yards, with a good chunk coming in garbage time.

And LOL at people STILL trying to use QBR. Ryan Fitzpatrick was 8th this season. Mitchell Trubisky was freakin' third last year. Nice try.
 

Ranched

"We Are Penn State"
Messages
34,885
Reaction score
84,323
If Dak can't be a pocket passer, he won't last in this league.
Any quarterback can be a pocket passer if they're protected & not flushed out.

Aikman was a pocket passer, but eventually it got the best of him being he was flushed out of the pocket one too many times causing his retirement from so many concussions.
 

rags747

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,596
Reaction score
8,105
I don't think it would be good for a new coach to come in and say to the QB that will most likely get a long term contract that he sucks.

But as I said, if Dak doesn't take the next step under McCarthy, that means he hit his ceiling. I would HOPE that Dak only gets a franchise tag to see how he does with McCarthy. If he doesn't improve, then we move on. It's the most sensible thing here.
Although Rivera today put Haskins on notice!
 

coult44

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,334
Reaction score
7,138
Build it around the running game and defense and let Dak manage the game. That's when he's been the most successful, not when he's throwing it 40 times a game.

Can Jerry fire fans also?You guys are so used to old school crap you don’t want to change... Dak or the Cowboys have not been successful in 25 years...Now he will have the chance to learn just like other success QBs have
 

Tabascocat

Dexternjack
Messages
26,568
Reaction score
36,238
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
The best thing that could have happened for Dak did happen. He is out from under a mundane offensive philosophy and a new head coach who happens to work out the kinks in QB’s.

I am not a huge Prescott guy but if anyone can get him to play better, McCarthy can :thumbup:
 

mattjames2010

Well-Known Member
Messages
21,483
Reaction score
20,162
Although Rivera today put Haskins on notice!

Rivera is garbage. I already made a thread on it.

He'll be run out of town in a couple years. 6 losing seasons out of 9 years as HC. Gets praise for a fluke season in which he got outmatched and punched in the mouth on the biggest stage and couldn't keep his QB from crying like a baby and taking a tantrum.
 

Irvin88_4life

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,454
Reaction score
26,305
(sigh) Another "stat wh**e". I have watched this team for many years. I have seen the great, the good and the trash. Dak is a stud, a real athlete, HOWEVER, his passing skills are, well let's say, poor. He is consistently late and behind open receivers, especially on the favored slant pattern. Many of his deep passes are short of the preferred spot and receivers who have open field in front of them have to slow down and I have seen them have to STOP in order to catch the pass.
Now, going back to your statement that when this team passes early they win and when they run early they loose, I would tell you that what I have seen is when this team played a competent NFL defense that understood that Dak is the limitation of the team and took Zeke away (regardless of Qtr) and forced the Cowboys to use Daks arm as the primary weapon (more than 30 throws) they (the Cowboys) lost. Dak still got his yards due to the difference in defenses being played when the score is out of reach or when the opponent is just laying back keeping everything in front of them.

Can this team win with Dak at QB? No doubt, but they have to play a new kind of offense. It has to be centered on the run with mostly short, quick passes and the occasional mid range pass and near zero deep passes.

As for "understanding the game and situational football", my question is, when did you learn that phrase?
I completely disagree with you about zero deep passes. You realize that Dak has been top 5 in deep passes the past two seasons and even led the league this past season. Some of you over exaggerate Daks bad throws.
 

blueblood70

Well-Known Member
Messages
38,486
Reaction score
26,921
Minnesota dared us to run, they played nickle and stopped us cold with 6 guys in the box. Dak shredded them and with the game on the line we ran and lost.
I know I watched it but Dak ran the RPOs and threw it to zeke, he had the power and control and he blew it dont blame that on coaches..RPO mean run either Dak or zeke OR PASS, he made a poor decsions to run the play called and didnt execute it..

he did this in other games and didnt get it done..
 

mattjames2010

Well-Known Member
Messages
21,483
Reaction score
20,162
Any quarterback can be a pocket passer if they're protected & not flushed out.

Aikman was a pocket passer, but eventually it got the best of him being he was flushed out of the pocket one too many times causing his retirement from so many concussions.

That's not what is being implied here.

If you can't excel as a pocket passer, you will not be a franchise QB. And it's not as though Dak has Newton/Lamar physical traits. That's just not who he is. He's a heavy footed QB with SOME running abilities. He needs to work on his mechanics and footwork with McCarthy.
 

The Fonz

Correctamundo
Messages
8,201
Reaction score
11,955
Wake me up when i see action and good result.

cross-my-fingers-picture-id116959807
 

irishline

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,523
Reaction score
3,802
Clearly you did not watch the games this year.

The games where we passed early, on early downs, we scored points and built leads, and ran effectively in the second half. Pass first does not mean passing 40 times a game. Our offense was the most successful when we ran it 40% or less in the first half.

When we did what you suggest, we fell behind, and HAD TO PASS MORE. Passing early will actually lead to passing LESS.

Not sure what games you were watching. Here are the last 8 games of 2019:

MIN first half - Passed 23 times, ran 13 times (36.11%): Dak ended with 46 attempts. Losing at half and we lost 24-28

DET first half - Passed 25 times, ran 13 times (34.2%): Dak ended with 46 attempts. Winning at half and won 35-27

NE first half - Passed 12 times, ran 17 times (58.6%) - During our two first half scores we ran the ball 12 times (to 4 passes). The rest of the half was 8 passes and 5 runs (38.4): Dak ended with 33 attempts. Losing at the half, lost 9-13.

BUF first half - Passed 21 times, ran 15 times (41.6%) : Dak ended with 49 attempts. Losing at the half and lost 15-26

CHI first half - Passed 15 times, ran 16 times (51.6%) - we ran the ball 10 times on our first drive (to 2 passes) leading to our only score of the first half... After that drive: 13 passes, 6 runs (36.1%): Dak ended up with 49 attempts. Losing at half and lost 24-31

LAR first half - Passed 16 times, ran 24 times (60%): Dak ended up with 23 attempts. Winning at the half and won 44-21

PHI first half - Passed 18 times, ran 6 times (25%): Dak ended up with 44 attempts. Losing at the half and lost 9-17

WAS first half - Passed 17 times, ran 17 times (50%): Dak ended up with 33 attempts. Winning at the half and won 47-16.

With the exception of the Detroit game, the exact opposite of what you said happened. Each game we were around or below 40% running in the first half we ended the half down. We scored a TD against the Bears by running the ball on the first drive 10 times, then basically abandoned the run (6 more rushing attempts the rest of the half). Our two scores against NE in the first half were on predominantly rushing oriented drives and passed more than 60% on the stalled drives.

The games we won against the Rams and the Commanders our run-to-pass ratio was at least 50% and both of those ended in blow outs.

We lost to most of those teams because we either abandoned the run or just decided to pass more than 60% of the time in the first half. This directly led to Dak having to pass more in the 2nd half. All of the games listed where Dak threw 40 or more attempts we actually rushed less than 40% in the first half. Passing early didn't lead to less passes it actually led to more compared to the games where we were more balanced.

Keep in mind I am not blaming Dak. Far from it. But we are better when we are balanced or leaning towards rushing. The results from the 2nd half of the season show that when we became pass happy and abandon the run (for whatever reason) it usually put us in a hole at the half.
 
Last edited:

DandyDon52

Well-Known Member
Messages
21,422
Reaction score
15,464
McCarthy will make Prescott better.
I think he will make all the players better,with the staff he is gathering it is going to be a different atmosphere and culture.
Totally different offense and defense.
Teams wont know what we are doing before we snap the ball!!
No more bend dont break defense!
And ST's might even have some good punt returns, blocked kicks, turnovers, who knows.
 
  • Like
Reactions: G2

blindzebra

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,557
Reaction score
4,446
I know I watched it but Dak ran the RPOs and threw it to zeke, he had the power and control and he blew it dont blame that on coaches..RPO mean run either Dak or zeke OR PASS, he made a poor decsions to run the play called and didnt execute it..

he did this in other games and didnt get it done..
You claimed they loaded up, they did not because they knew if we saw 6 in the box we'd run. The consecutive runs set up that throw to Zeke...it was 100٪ bad coaching.
 

pansophy

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,009
Reaction score
4,114
Not sure what games you were watching. Here are the last 8 games of 2019:

Minnesota first half - Passed 23 times, ran 13 times (36.11%): Dak ended with 46 attempts. Losing at half and we lost 24-28

Detroit first half - Passed 25 times, ran 13 times (34.2%): Dak ended with 46 attempts. Winning at half and won 35-27

NE first half - Passed 12 times, ran 17 times (58.6%) - During our two first half scores we ran the ball 12 times (to 4 passes). The rest of the half was 8 passes and 5 runs (38.4): Dak ended with 33 attempts. Losing at the half, lost 9-13.

Buffalo first half - Passed 21 times, ran 15 times (41.6%) : Dak ended with 49 attempts. Losing at the half and lost 15-26

Chicago first half - Passed 15 times, ran 16 times (51.6%) - we ran the ball 10 times on our first drive (to 2 passes) leading to our only score of the first half... After that drive: 13 passes, 6 runs (36.1%): Dak ended up with 49 attempts. Losing at half and lost 24-31

LA first half - Passed 16 times, ran 24 times (60%): Dak ended up with 23 attempts. Winning at the half and won 44-21

Phi first half - Passed 18 times, ran 6 times (25%): Dak ended up with 44 attempts. Losing at the half and lost 9-17

Was first half - Passed 17 times, ran 17 times (50%): Dak ended up with 33 attempts. Winning at the half and won 47-16.

With the exception of the Detroit game, the exact opposite of what you said happened. Each game we were below 40% running in the first half we ended the half down. We scored a TD against the Bears by running the ball on the first drive 10 times, then basically abandoned the run (6 more rushing attempts the rest of the half). Our two scores against NE in the first half were on predominantly rushing oriented drives and passed more than 60% on the stalled drives.

The games we won against the Rams and the Commanders our run-to-pass ratio was at least 50% and both of those ended in blow outs.

We lost to most of those teams because we either abandoned the run or just decided to pass more than 60% of the time in the first half. This directly led to Dak having to pass more in the 2nd half. All of the games listed where Dak threw 40 or more attempts we actually rushed less than 40% in the first half.
People put too much stock into pass and run count totals -- totals are completely misleading because it removes the context in which those calls were made. If we are unsuccessful on 1st down then we are going to pass more on 2nd and 3rd down, regardless of whether we ran or passed on 1st down. If we are behind and need to play a faster pass game we are going to pass more. The list goes on.
 
Top