#1 WRs: So where do you rank Roy Williams?

[theebs]

Lol, ok ok I'm not going to post anymore on this board until after week 1 when Roy doesn't do a damn thing. I cant wait to hear the excuses. "He's still getting to know Romo", "Its still early".


smh.

God I hope you mean it.

Please dont let us down.

 

[YosemiteSam]

Roy Williams is a Cowboys therefore he is #1.

 

[Doomsday101]

Roy Williams is a Cowboys therefore he is #1.

He is a good WR with a lot to prove in Dallas.

 

[Doomsday]

I would put him around the 12 to 15 spot on that list.

 

[Staggerlee]

You're missing Boldin on that list. I'd probably put him about 6 or 7 (Boldin that is).

Boldin was on the #2 list, fitzgerald is the #1 in arizona not boldin

 

[AbeBeta]

Probably at the top. He's certainly as good if not better than Fitzgerald.

 

[big dog cowboy]

Around #10-12.

 

[austintodallas]

Boldin was on the #2 list, fitzgerald is the #1 in arizona not boldin

Ok that makes sense.

 

[DaBoys4Life]

Now here's a list of my best guess at who is considered the #1 WR for each NFL team. I very roughly ranked them--and I know we will all have variations of the rankings (ex. rookie crabtree). These are based on 2009, not total past career.

My question is, where would you rank Roy E Willimas on this list?

1--Fitzgerald (az)
2--A Johnson (hou)
3--Cal Johnson (det)
4--R Moss (ne)
5--R Wayne (ind)
6--S Smith (car)
7--B Marshall (den)
8--G Jennings (gb)
9--T Owens (buf)
10--R White (atl)
11--M Colston (no)
12--D Bowe (kc)
13--TJ Housh
14--Ch Johnson (cin)
15--B Edwards (cle)
16--A Bryant (tb)
17--V Jackson (sd)
18--S Holmes (pit)
19--T Holt (jax)
20--S Moss (was)
21--De Jackson
22--B Berrian (min)
23--D Avery (sl)
24--D Mason (bal)
25--J Cotchery (nyj)
26--N Washington (ten)
27--M Crabtree (sf)
28--D Hixon (nyg)
29--T Ginn (mia)
30--D Hester (chi)
31--Jav Walker (oak)


I'd slot him in the 12-18 range...which is not too bad....and might be generous. We'll see!

ur list sucks

 

[zrinkill]

Lol, ok ok I'm not going to post anymore on this board until after week 1 when Roy doesn't do a damn thing.

Already bookmarked.

 

[DFWJC]

we shall see....

You putting him ahead of TJ, Bowe (who will be a beast this year), Chad Johnson, Edwards, Holmes, VJax, etc...I would say is pretty positive already. If we get that from him (maybe 1000+ yards 7-8 TDs), we're in good shape, imo.

 

[TNCowboy]

Statistically, Colston's been a more consistent player than RW. Of course, he's had the advantage of a much better QB.

The jury's still out on both of them.

 

[TNCowboy]

Agreed. Time will tell. I'd have him tentatively at 22 on this list.

It all depends if he and Romo click. While he wont have the big play like TO, he will and should make clutch catches.

Their career YPC are almost the same. Given that he played in Detroit, I haven't watched a lot of RW, but from just looking at his #s, he's made his share of big plays.

 

[LittleBoyBlue]

While he wont have the big play like TO,

he will and should make clutch catches.

Disagree. He SHOULD be a PLAYMAKER for us. A different playmaker than Owens perhaps but a playmaker nonetheless.

Agreed. He should catch most of what goes his way once he finds his rhythm with Romo.

 

[CoCo]

Lol, ok ok I'm not going to post anymore on this board until after week 1 when Roy doesn't do a damn thing. I cant wait to hear the excuses. "He's still getting to know Romo", "Its still early".


smh.

Wow, I hope Jerry doesn't drag this out into the regular season. There is patience, and then there is blindness. End this already Jerry! What more evidence do you need?

 

[Hoofbite]

http://i716.***BLOCKED***/albums/ww164/mj-saver/3169pxv.gif

It only works if you know how to actually make the picture show up.

Like this.

http://i716.***BLOCKED***/albums/ww164/mj-saver/3169pxv.gif

 

[Doomsday101]

Their career YPC are almost the same. Given that he played in Detroit, I haven't watched a lot of RW, but from just looking at his #s, he's made his share of big plays.

I agree. RW is not Keyshawn Johnson. RW does have the speed to take it deep and has a very good set of hands.

 

[JonJon]

My question is, where would you rank Roy E Willimas on this list?

1--Fitzgerald (az)
2--A Johnson (hou)
3--Cal Johnson (det)
4--R Moss (ne)
5--R Wayne (ind)
6--S Smith (car)
7--B Marshall (den)
8--G Jennings (gb)
9--T Owens (buf)
10--R White (atl)
11--M Colston (no)
12--D Bowe (kc)
13--TJ Housh
14--Ch Johnson (cin)
15--B Edwards (cle)
16--A Bryant (tb)
17--V Jackson (sd)
18--S Holmes (pit)
19--T Holt (jax)
<<<<<<<<Roy Williams>>>>>>>
20--S Moss (was)
21--De Jackson
22--B Berrian (min)
23--D Avery (sl)
24--D Mason (bal)
25--J Cotchery (nyj)
26--N Washington (ten)
27--M Crabtree (sf)
28--D Hixon (nyg)
29--T Ginn (mia)
30--D Hester (chi)
31--Jav Walker (oak)

I put him under Holt and above Moss, though I would shuffle A. Bryant and S. Holmes beneath Roy as well.

 

[ThreeSportStar80]

Why are people acting like Roy Williams isn't an outstanding player?? The guy hasn't had the ideal QB situation over the last couple of years.

 

[Avaj]

The guy hasn't had the ideal QB situation over the last couple of years.

Right, with that being said I put him on the list in the 20's. Like someone said in the earlier post this is his year to be ranked either top 10 or bottom of the list.