1st and 10 talks Cowboys on Hard Knocks - 5/7/08

[superpunk]

well i can't help you either. you are just 1 of many on this board who underrate Eli and overrate Romo. ive seen posts recently that said "i don't think their's even 2 qbs i'd take over Romo" Romo is a good regular season qb but we don't know what he is as a postseason qb yet. so far it ain't to good though.

Maybe we can pick up Trent Dilfer or Rex Grossman. Fantastic postseason QBs. I wonder how many games we would manage to win with your brilliant strategy?

I have Eli Manning rated exactly where he belongs. Somewhere along the line you deluded yourself into thinking Eli Manning wears #91 and plays on the defensive line.

 

[theogt]

I cant believe this is even a debate.

I don't think it really qualifies.

 

[Rampage]

Maybe we can pick up Trent Dilfer or Rex Grossman. Fantastic postseason QBs. I wonder how many games we would manage to win with your brilliant strategy?

what's my brillant strategy?

 

[superpunk]

what's my brillant strategy?

Have Justin Tuck play QB.

 

[Rampage]

Have Justin Tuck play QB.

you discredit eli's success cause of his defense playing very well yet i doubt you would do that if it was Romo and our defense played well in the playoffs.

 

[superpunk]

you discredit eli's success cause of his defense playing very well yet i doubt you would do that if it was Romo and our defense played well in the playoffs.

;kjanspjg[wejrSKGK

I can't talk to you anymore.

 

[kristie]

Have Justin Tuck play QB.

 

[9xxx11]

rampage must go...:laugh2:

 

[ZB9]

i see Skip is still an idiot. He fits in well at ESPN

 

[DaBoys4Life]

he's come from a football family, won a superbowl with huge expectations because of who his brother is, and is 4 years younger than Romo. hard to argue with that.

dan marino never one a superbowl so does anyone that wins a superbowl auto is better than dan marino.

 

[kristie]

i see Skip is still an idiot. He fits in well at ESPN

yup. :laugh2:

 

[BehindEnemyLinez]

rampage must go...:laugh2:

He's still suffering from a DMac-to-Oakland hangover! He'll come to his senses and realize Romo is the better QB soon enough!

 

[Sandyf]

Guess some people would prefer Trent Dilfer to Romo. Let's see he won a Super Bowl and if I remember correctly was pretty young. Guess also they would take Eli over John Elway, you know because Elway didn't win a Super Bowl until he was in his 30's, WHEN HE FINALLY GOT A TEAM AROUND HIM.

Did Eli win the Super Bowl? Not hardly. The Giants defense won that game plain and simple. Eli had one lucky pass to a lucky WR on a catch we will probably never see happen again. Please gimme a break.

Is Eli ever mentioned as an elite QB like Romo is. It is Romo who is mentioned in the same breath as Brady, Peyton and others. And Eli, it has been even after the Super Bowl that we should wait and see.

How about handling tough personalities? Eli couldn't stand up to Shockey. You really think Romo would have that problem, if you do, you haven't watching.

Question: If Eli and Giants go 7-9 this year would you still take him over Romo? If Eli goes 14-2, then I will admit he is pretty good. But right now it isn't close.