I feel you bro but I am not going into this game with this view I am gonna be an Optimistic Blind Homer . . . I have to I am excitedI totally agree! I watched these QBs like Lawrence and Jones hitting WRs in full stride crossing the field. I can't remember the last time Dak was picking apart a defense using short crossing routes and slants and skinny posts where the WR is on the move and he doesn't have to slow down to adjust to Daks pass. People say well Dak is much better than Lawrence and Jones but I disagree. His ability to make all the throws is limited. We saw Hebert lose but he put up one heck of a game without Mike Williams. That's like taking away Lamb. Lawrence made mistakes and the ball didn't bounce his way but he continued to over come his defense giving up 30 points and won the game for his team. That's true leadership. Jones is developing under that coaching staff and I really think the Giants are a threat to the Eagles. Dak is at the peak of his development and it's all about trying to overcome his nerves but his accuracy is all over the place and that is causing a lot of inconsistency. Jones stood in the pocket and took some nasty hits while delivering the ball. When has Dak stood tall and taken some hits to deliver the football. I'm really concerned Dak is going to lay an egg tonight and I'm already angry at him.
Then that should shift some of the blame more to the QB and OC. Lamb's strength coming out of college was his YAC ability. Almost all the scouting reports raved about his ability once the ball was in his hands.Lamb had a big season, but his YAC ability was charged as about average for a player with the volume of touches he had:
https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/nfl-receiver-rankings/
it was his ability to get open that put him apart
Dak has to get over the DBs to gain some respect to open it up underneath for the short game to be successful and vice versa..QB . . . He is terrible at timing based throws like crossing routes and slants and prefers routes that have the WR come back to him. The WRs are getting blasted because He stares down his WRs which is why Safeties are intercepting all His Passes
Wrs each run a certain route and many times WRs are open but either Dak does not see them or refuse to even attempt this throws
This is the weakness in Daks game but sadly it is huge because this limitation allows the defense to contain him and His Wrs
That's amazing (bad) considering we have Lamb
actually we were 31st in the league before Dak returned. so a lot of it is due to Rush. he had a 100 yard game against rams...that's ain't going to push you up the rankings.Dak is innacurate with the ball and rarely ever hits guys in stride or throws to the correct shoulder. So, even if the ball is catchable, a lot of times the receiver can't do much after the catching the ball.
its 23 maybe he still canBecause our wr's other than Lamb are bad lol. Noah Brown and Schultz I notice always go to the ground a lot when they don't really need to. Its like they feel they are in the middle of the field so they go down. Gallup this year can catch but his guy is stuck to him like glue. His best attribute is catching the ball in traffic right now. Maybe next year he will regain some speed and cutting ability.
Our receiving core is worst than it was last year.
We traded Coop (who was our number 1), lost Cedric Wilson who was a decent number 3/4 wr.
What did we do to replace them? Drafted Tolbert who struggled big time. Got Washington in the offseason who was a bust and is already cut.
Maybe Ty Hilton can show something but he had some terrible drops last week. Lets hope he brings his hands this game. And now we have Noah Brown playing in very key moments. Sometimes he is the second WR out there.
I was hoping Tolbert showed something this year but that didn't happen sadly.
WR, QB, and scheme related.Pretty much the title, after watching some wildcard games this weekend i noticed how many small-intermediate catches went for big chunks. So i went and checked and our top rated offense is near the bottom in that.
https://scores.nbcsports.com/fb/tmleaders.asp?type=Receiving&range=NFL&rank=231
Is this the Receivers fault, routes, scheme, qb? Ive been noticing almost every game Dak has to make tight window throws or has to checkdown (and then the guy gets immediately blasted) while i constantly see the opposing team have a wide open receiver. Whats interesting is that Pollard seems to be our YAC guy and yet i barely see him get played as a receiver.
Thoughts?
Cowboys had a lot of YAC against Minny also. There’s a common denomination there. I see it. I know you do tooWho do the Giants have . . . come on already . . It is Dak's fault
Shocking take ..lol I guess just typing "You know where i stand" would've been to easy.I totally agree! I watched these QBs like Lawrence and Jones hitting WRs in full stride crossing the field. I can't remember the last time Dak was picking apart a defense using short crossing routes and slants and skinny posts where the WR is on the move and he doesn't have to slow down to adjust to Daks pass. People say well Dak is much better than Lawrence and Jones but I disagree. His ability to make all the throws is limited. We saw Hebert lose but he put up one heck of a game without Mike Williams. That's like taking away Lamb. Lawrence made mistakes and the ball didn't bounce his way but he continued to over come his defense giving up 30 points and won the game for his team. That's true leadership. Jones is developing under that coaching staff and I really think the Giants are a threat to the Eagles. Dak is at the peak of his development and it's all about trying to overcome his nerves but his accuracy is all over the place and that is causing a lot of inconsistency. Jones stood in the pocket and took some nasty hits while delivering the ball. When has Dak stood tall and taken some hits to deliver the football. I'm really concerned Dak is going to lay an egg tonight and I'm already angry at him.
Very silly. The Cowboys with Dak have been near the top of the league in prior years.QB . . . He is terrible at timing based throws like crossing routes and slants and prefers routes that have the WR come back to him. The WRs are getting blasted because He stares down his WRs which is why Safeties are intercepting all His Passes
Wrs each run a certain route and many times WRs are open but either Dak does not see them or refuse to even attempt this throws
This is the weakness in Daks game but sadly it is huge because this limitation allows the defense to contain him and His Wrs
Andy Reid is really good at making the best of what he has, i hated us facing him when he was with Philly.WR, QB, and scheme related.
"Tight windows"
"Separation"
"YAC"
It Is for sure related to WRs, of course, but also related to ball placement and timing.
The exact same player if thrown to in stride and at the right time will have a larger window, more separation, and more YAC.
Notice that Mahomes lost Tyreek Hill and still leads the league in YAC with a very average (at best) group of WRs
That's both Mahomes and scheme.
Notice the Bills throw the long ball lot and their YAC is not all that high
But I also notice that those bottom 5 teams all have pretty poor WR groups
Lol, it’s the qb for crying out loud. He doesn’t hit in stride, doesn’t anticipate where routes will be and if he dues he throws interceptions. Ceedee had one of highest yac in college with three QBs in nfl. Only thing that changed, DakI think it’s pretty common knowledge our WR corp is awful.
Near the bottom of the league in deep ration per target and YAC.