I find all the McFadden love and Randle hate a little strange. Maybe it's people seeing what they want to see, maybe it's that McFadden looks the part, maybe it's that McFadden's first run went for 8 yards. After that, though, he rushed for 3, 3, 3, 1, and -2, finishing 6 for 16. Randle had the fumble and didn't light the world on fire, but at least he averaged 4 yards per carry and had zero negative runs. Plus the three catches for 42 yards.
Look at our first TD drive.
Two Randle rushes put us in 3rd and 1, which he converted by catching a pass for 25.
Then he caught another one for 11 yards and another first.
Then he ran for 5 on first down.
Then, after we converted that one, he ran for 5 on the NEXT first down.
I'll admit my bias against McFadden. He's never stayed healthy and has been extremely unproductive the last three years (albeit behind a poor line). But I see a lot of people here saying how good he looked running. Me, I'll be impressed when there's actually production there.