An eye to 2017

darthseinfeld

Groupthink Guru
Messages
33,538
Reaction score
38,176
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
In regards to the 2016 QB thing, I keep seeing the thought that this is a bad draft for QB so nobody worth a top five.

Has anyone looked down the road?

Here are the current classes for the next three years per NFL Draft Scout.

In normal years, you are lucky if the top five even make a squad and contribute, so here goes:

2017 - Chad Kelly, C.J. Beathard, Joshua Dobbs, Seth Russell, Mitch Leidner
2018 - Deshaun Watson, Luke Falk, Brad Kaaya, J.T. Barrett, Mitch Trubisky
2019 - Josh Rosen, Jake Browning, DeShone Kiser, David Cornwell, Kyler Chryst

Looking at this, I see perhaps two players I would even think about as being potentially special down the road.

Yes, I know things can change, but typically the "sure fire franchise QB" is usually starting by their second season and ones like Luck, Manning, etc. are watched for at least a year or so before they can think about declaring early.

So if this year's three of Wentz, Goff and Lynch are undesirable, what about these?

It makes it even more insane to say, well, Romo has three more years, then start looking. Well, look at 2019. Are we going to pick at the top of the draft to snag Rosen?

Said it before, will keep saying it.

If you are waiting for an Aikman to drop out of the sky, forget it. Not going to happen in today's day and age where the term franchise QB is becoming about as stupid as the phrase "shutdown corner".

There is no "good time". There are going to be fewer and fewer strong "QB drafts".

You evaluate each year based on it's merits and looking at this, I think people are hoping something dramatic will happen.

Prior to the Winston/Mariota draft last year, there were three years with the top five chosen looking like this:

Bortles, Manziel, Bridgewater, Carr, Garoppolo
Manuel, Geno Smith, Glennon, Barkley, Nassib
Luck, Griffin, Tannehill, Weeden, Osweiler (Wilson was 6th)
Newton, Locker, Gabbert, Ponder, Dalton (Kaepernick was 6th)
Bradford, Tebow, Clausen, McCoy, Kafka

So turn your nose up at this draft, but understand what is coming while doing so.
And honestly I think 2 or the top 5 overall prospects in this draft are QB's
 

Rockport

AmberBeer
Messages
46,580
Reaction score
46,004
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
I've gone back and forth on the whole QB situation. Do we draft one in the first this year or go for broke and try to make a run at the SB?

As great as it would be to actually be in the hunt this year, I don't think we'll have the defensive chops to pull it off. And that's IF Romo can stay healthy all year...which I don't see happening.

Our defensive line is a wreck now. We have two above average players, Crawford and Lawrence. Neither have shown to be a super star, command double team type player. I have hopes that they can, but I'm not sure next year will be the breakout year. And as I've said many times, I think Crawford is playing out of position to begin with.

At LB, we have Sean Lee and some nice, young talent. But no one that really grabs your attention.

Secondary we have Scandrick and Thomas. Scandrick coming off surgery and not getting younger. Carr is slightly above average but not worth what he is getting paid. Church is a below average cover guy.

Offensively we have a very good o line. A number 1 WR with physical gifts but lacking in other areas. Our number 2 WR is not dependable. And our future HOF TE needs to be replaced, sadly to say. And we have a merely average RB, if he stays healthy.

So, I'm now back in the draft QB at 4 camp. Get the guy that can hopefully be Romo's replacement.

Cut Carr, Church and Witten this year. Draft their replacements. Find a couple good deal FAs this year to fill in the rest. I'm not writing off this year, I'm just not going all in.

Now you can work in the rookie QB this year. Preseason, spot duty. He'll have a full year to get used to the NFL.

2017 rolls around and yes - I release Romo, free up 14 mill and usher in the new age. This team needs a new identity. The Romo, Witten, Garrett trio of bromance needs to be gone. It hasn't worked, for what ever reasons. And yes, I'd look to replace Garrett and staff at the end of 2016, unless he manages to get us to the Divisional game at least.

How can you think that before free agency and the draft! Answer is you can't.
 
Top