An Honesty Thread...

[juck]

its second quarter Colts up say 10-3.Ware around the side spears Mannings head,concussion,,out for remainder of game.Nothing serious,just out for game.are u happy?be honest.

 

[smarta5150]

I'd rather win without any excuses possible for the critics.

But if we win, whatever. He'll be ok.

 

[Rampage]

win by any means necessary

 

[Jimz31]

I honestly wouldn't like it if it were a "cheap shot", but if it happened in the course of a play with no maliciousness, then I'm fine with it.

 

[superpunk]

I'd cut him.

 

[FiveTime]

I don't want to see any injuries...just a Dallas victory.

 

[twa]

Part of the game,as Jimz said I'm fine with it long as it's clean.

 

[juck]

before the Steelers played them last year,Porter was talking so much smack on Manning Munster,I think he got into his head.When porter would sack him its was with visciousness.I hate the Steelers but Porter can play on my team anyday.

 

[Canadian BoyzFan]

I hate seeing any players hurt. Especially the great players.
This is an easy "no".

Anyone who says yes is not a Football fan.
Just my 0.02.

 

[Canadian BoyzFan]

Part of the game,as Jimz said I'm fine with it long as it's clean.

Spearing is not part of the game.

 

[Beast_from_East]

its second quarter Colts up say 10-3.Ware around the side spears Mannings head,concussion,,out for remainder of game.Nothing serious,just out for game.are u happy?be honest.

No way, I want to beat the Colts straight up, not with any asteriks. Our best 11 on their best 11 and lets see what happens.

We dont need to take Manning out to win, we can do it legit.

Boyz 21-17

 

[Tuna Helper]

Do you think they will put an asterisk down if one of our big time players goes down with an injury?

I'll take a win over a respectable win anyday. A "W" is still a "W".

 

[Rampage]

Do you think they will put an asterisk down if one of our big time players goes down with an injury?

I'll take a win over a respectable win anyday. A "W" is still a "W".

 

[gollum]

Hard and clean, no problem, but I'd get more joy out of beating them with Peyton being able to say "Would you sign my melon" and talk about the fruit, not his head.

 

[sonnyboy]

I'd honestly prefer a clear cut no excuses win. However, protecting your QB is part of the game. If we knock him out, that counts in my book.
Now if pulls up lame in warm ups and doesn't play at all, that's a different story. That would suck! I don't want that, even though it would probably get us a win.

 

[ravidubey]

its second quarter Colts up say 10-3.Ware around the side spears Mannings head,concussion,,out for remainder of game.Nothing serious,just out for game.are u happy?be honest.

No, I'd feel cheated. Now if he sacked him and Manning was concussed hitting the ground, I'd feel bad for Manning but proud that we'd knocked him out fair and square.

 

[BadKarma]

Spearing is not part of the game.

So the answer to the juckie's question is - no...I would not be happy.

I would like to see us beat the Colts with Manning as the QB. No excuses for the media to say why we won.

 

[Cowboy4ever]

I never feel good about a cheap shot.. its not how the game should be played. Now if we take Manning out ,, fair and square, well that is just football.

 

[ghst187]

its second quarter Colts up say 10-3.Ware around the side spears Mannings head,concussion,,out for remainder of game.Nothing serious,just out for game.are u happy?be honest.

This is the ONLY scenario I can foresee that would give us a reasonable chance to win this game....

 

[sonnyboy]

Hard and clean, no problem, but I'd get more joy out of beating them with Peyton being able to say "Would you sign my melon" and talk about the fruit, not his head.

Ya I want him there at the end so he can ask ROMO for his autograph