Are we in a better place with McCarthy?

[Diehardblues]

He won a lot of football games for us.

He never had an elite DC.

Romo got hurt.

Dez got hurt.

#DezCaughtIt

Looking back, the 2020 disaster likely doesn’t happen with Jason.

These detractors really have nothing else to say against the facts . It doesn’t mean Garrett was a great or even good HC. Just that he had as much or more success than the rest of Cowboys HC this era.

If I was looking to bash Garrett for his record here that I’d begin by bashing the rest of our HC’s for not having anymore success. How shameful on their part . And maybe the issue is deeper than our HC’s, like in the sky box

It’s always amusing they have nothing else to refute his record up against others this era besides attempting to bash fans too. Typical trolling tendencies.

 

[Diehardblues]

Only because he was here a decade. And he was only here a decade because he was Jerry's pet project, the son of a man Jerry thought was a loyal employee. Not because of merit.

Basically, Jerry runs his businesses as a family business, and Garrett was the closest thing to a family member he could get at head coach. That's why he said Garrett was practically in the family portrait.

But I guess the rest of the league is just missing out by not hiring this genius who's been available for a couple of years. If you love wasting a decade of football life on a lousy coach with a good facade, Jason's your man.

That’s all part or a product of our dysfunctional organization under Jethro .

The question Id be asking is how did these other more qualified and experienced HC’s not have more success than the “ greatest puppet”. Lol

 

[Flinger]

The players are good enough. We all could see how they were mismanaged last year.

All? or the mob?

 

[big dog cowboy]

All? or the mob?

Specifically the 3 I listed. But there were more. No one had to be in the meetings, on the practice field, or know what plays are called during a game to see what was going on. It was very clear that McCarthy and his staff had no clue what they were doing.

 

[calicowboy54]

Team quit after the Dak INTs.

yeah but we were already not doing well and then that happened so, yeah they Quit. Big Mike was seen on side lines talking to them, but most of them knew DQ was leaving and they had plans for after parties already scheduled so they gave up. Im not saying it was right i think they should have sucked it up and kept going but GenZ kids just fold when things get tough. my kids are at the End of GenZ and i see them doing it all the time, things get hard and they quit. Video Game generation you can just respawn and start over better. the season ending and beinging this year is a respawn to them.

 

[FVSTONE]

We play the same way every game.

What games are you watching???????

 

[zrinkill]

No ........ but not really his fault. Until Jerry puts his ego aside ........ no coach would have a chance.

 

[Beast_from_East]

These detractors really have nothing else to say against the facts . It doesn’t mean Garrett was a great or even good HC. Just that he had as much or more success than the rest of Cowboys HC this era.

If I was looking to bash Garrett for his record here that I’d begin by bashing the rest of our HC’s for not having anymore success. How shameful on their part . And maybe the issue is deeper than our HC’s, like in the sky box

It’s always amusing they have nothing else to refute his record up against others this era besides attempting to bash fans too. Typical trolling tendencies.

Who is trolling?

Look, I dont really give a dam how many wins Garrett had vs a head coach from 20 freaking years ago. I care about the record Garrett has TODAY and how that compares to other head coaches around the league. You want to refute his record and what people say about him, go ahead, take a look.

2010.......5-3
2011.......8-8
2012.......8-8
2013.......8-8
2014......12-4 (Wildcard win)
2015.......4-12
........................................at this point he shoud have been fired, 6 yrs on the job, only 1 season over 10 wins, a single wildcard win only thing to show for 6 yrs on job........................
2016.......13-3
2017........9-7
2018.......10-6 (Wildcard win)
2019........8-8
........................................finally fired after Jerry even said to himself, "dam, what people have been saying for a decade is actually true, this dude actually does suck"................................

This is his record, does have a dam thing to do with what Campo did or Gailey did or whoever the hell else did, this is what Jason Garrett did. In over a decade, he failed to make the playoffs 7 times (including 5 times over a 6-season span). Also, in 6 of those 7 seasons, he didn't even break the .500 mark (which gave him the nickname Mr. .500). So, to boil it all down all Garrett accomplished was 2 wildcard wins after a decade on the job, thats it. Now defend this record since you seem so fond of it without resorting to "WHATaboutism" (what about Campo, what about Parcells, what about Wade, what about McCarthy).........this is not their record, its Garrett's................. so, defend it on the merits, if you can.

 

[Diehardblues]

Who is trolling?

Look, I dont really give a dam how many wins Garrett had vs a head coach from 20 freaking years ago. I care about the record Garrett has TODAY and how that compares to other head coaches around the league. You want to refute his record and what people say about him, go ahead, take a look.

2010.......5-3
2011.......8-8
2012.......8-8
2013.......8-8
2014......12-4 (Wildcard win)
2015.......4-12
........................................at this point he shoud have been fired, 6 yrs on the job, only 1 season over 10 wins, a single wildcard win only thing to show for 6 yrs on job........................
2016.......13-3
2017........9-7
2018.......10-6 (Wildcard win)
2019........8-8
........................................finally fired after Jerry even said to himself, "dam, what people have been saying for a decade is actually true, this dude actually does suck"................................

This is his record, does have a dam thing to do with what Campo did or Gailey did or whoever the hell else did, this is what Jason Garrett did. In over a decade, he failed to make the playoffs 7 times (including 5 times over a 6-season span). Also, in 6 of those 7 seasons, he didn't even break the .500 mark (which gave him the nickname Mr. .500). So, to boil it all down all Garrett accomplished was 2 wildcard wins after a decade on the job, thats it. Now defend this record since you seem so fond of it without resorting to "WHATaboutism" (what about Campo, what about Parcells, what about Wade, what about McCarthy).........this is not their record, its Garrett's................. so, defend it on the merits, if you can.

Well , we can all frame a narrative to support our view . I’ve always felt Garrett’s record on his comparison to other Cowboys HC this era was on merit and the facts.

His record perhaps doesn’t represent his success as much as it represents the lack of success of all our HC’s this era .

Which falls back on my basic message in why is our least experienced and arguably worst HC this era who had as much or more success than other much more proven and experienced HC’s receive such vitriol.