At Week 5 Who are your top 5 players? Biggest disappointments?

[ChuckA1]

Not even Aubrey as an honorable mention?

Aubrey missed an extra point... time to move on!

He's the most reliable player on the team.

 

[Pessimist_cowboy]

Just curious why you would think S Williams is a LB? He played outside LB, almost exclusively as a pass rusher in Mike Mcintyre’s 34 defense. He played end and some 3tech his 2nd senior season in a hybrid.
He played end his 2 seasons at northeast Mississippi community college where he registered 21 sacks.
Even if there was some indication (I haven’t seen it) he was smart enough to diagnose and fill the correct hole against the run he looks like they’ve got him over 270 to play strong side starting end!

I think his best position in the league would be a SAM LB. He has almost no pass rush moves, zero bend. What he excels at in the NFL is his pursuit. He is fast and I think as a SAM LB he could utilize his speed and athleticism to be an excellent run stopping and occasional blitzing LB. I don’t see a bright future as a 4-3 DE.

His college production has not translated well into the NFL. I see him as a Kyle Wilber type player in this league.

 

[Whirlwin]

*I did not list O linemen; they remain workaday but anonymous.

1. Pickens (Irvin Jr.)
2. Aubrey (Duh)
3. Williams (old school)
4. Diggs (a rebirth?)
5. Shemar James (active!)

Honorable mention: Bland and Dak

Disappointments

1. Elam
2. Blue (Not ready for Prime Time?)
3. Eze
4. Sanborn
5. Murray
Honorable mention: Osa, (Fowler)

BLUE, no idea yet what to expect from him

 

[cowboyec]

5 best:
☆dak prescott
☆javantae williams
☆george pickens
☆kenny clark
☆james houston

best group:
☆OL

disappointmet:
☆elam
☆fowler
☆LB play minus marist liufau

 

[StarW]

Aubrey missed an extra point... time to move on!

He's the most reliable player on the team.

Man, I'm convinced he missed it on purpose. We were finally running up the score, and he just wanted to clown around for a minute to give the boys a good laugh.

 

[StarW]

I think his best position in the league would be a SAM LB. He has almost no pass rush moves, zero bend. What he excels at in the NFL is his pursuit. He is fast and I think as a SAM LB he could utilize his speed and athleticism to be an excellent run stopping and occasional blitzing LB. I don’t see a bright future as a 4-3 DE.

His college production has not translated well into the NFL. I see him as a Kyle Wilber type player in this league.

Man that's an interesting point. Keep him out there in base at SAM and then use him as a situational PR? He looked good on the play he got his sack. They had him over the center like we used to occasionally do with Parsons, and his speed gave him a direct shot into the backfield before the center could even react. But having him at SAM with 2 other DEs on the field cound be an interesting 4-3 power defense. He's def got the speed to get go sideline to sideline.

 

[Vinnie2u]

1. Dak
2. Aubrey
3. Williams
4. Pickens
5. Houston/ Clark

Worst
1. Sanborn, Schoonmaker, Elam, Wilson. Kneeland

 

[conner01]

Me lord, Blue has been given minimal touches, like 5 so far.
He can't possibly improve without the reps and touches.
Having said tha, his fumbling profile precedes him, and the fact he hasn't been Inserted much tells me he is a big disappointment to his coaches.

My point exactly.