Belichick or Saban

[CowboyChris]

let me first say I’m rooting hard for MM to get us where we want to go. the media has been trying hard to paint a narrative if we lose to GB, or even the divisional round, JJ should fire MM.

if that were to happen would you want BB or Saban?

 

[The Quest for Six]

I think Belichick and Saban will retire from coaching...although I think Belichick less so

 

[diamonddelts]

This thread = hot garbage

 

[RodeoJake]

Neither. Belichicks time has passed. Saban tried the NFL and quickly returned to the NCAA. Both should be looking forward to moving to the broadcast booth or fishing with Jimmy Johnson.

 

[PA Cowboy Fan]

BB. Saban failed as coach in the NFL.

 

[big dog cowboy]

 

[jazzcat22]

Both will take a year off, and most likely Saban will just stay retired. He will show up on a college game day show. Even if just part time.

Bill, if he takes a HC position, he will not want to rebuild a team. He will take a team that is close to being ready to win. Such as Seattle, who rely needs a young franchise QB. He would not go to the mess in Washington.

 

[baltcowboy]

Bellichick and it’s not close. You recruit in college football so that makes the field uneven. I don’t even thiink Saban is the best coach in the history of college football.

 

[Tim93gt]

Both will take a year off, and most likely Saban will just stay retired. He will show up on a college game day show. Even if just part time.

Bill, if he takes a HC position, he will not want to rebuild a team. He will take a team that is close to being ready to win. Such as Seattle, who rely needs a young franchise QB. He would not go to the mess in Washington.

I agree with this, but I believe BB will go where he has control to build out a program for a multi year gig, if he coaches.

 

[John813]

One was a college coach that blipped in and out of the NFL and one has been in the NFL since the Dinosaurs roamed the earth.

Give me Bill B in this hypothetical.
But I don't see the purpose. MM is the HC/OC. I don't want any OC Bill has worked with recently.

 

[acr731]

Why even bother posing the question? Neither one will ever work for Jerry, so there's no point bringing this up.

 

[CTcowboy203]

Neither…these guys are 70+ years old and if I’m going high profile I’d take harbaugh. That said MM will be back

 

[movaughn88]

Billys record without Brady:

85 - 102

 

[Jayinem]

BB. Saban failed as coach in the NFL.

BB failed without the GOAT at QB, before and after.

I would take BB as DC, but he's the most overrated head coach of all time.

 

[jazzcat22]

Why even bother posing the question? Neither one will ever work for Jerry, so there's no point bringing this up.

Same thing was said about Parcells.

 

[Jayinem]

Billys record without Brady:

85 - 102

Yep, fired twice without Brady who went on to win another SB without him.

 

[acr731]

Same thing was said about Parcells.

I would bet Jerry made promises to him and reneged on them. You have to remember - Jerry never wanted to hire Bill in the first place, but he had to suck it up in order to get support for Jerry world.

 

[jazzcat22]

I would bet Jerry made promises to him and reneged on them. You have to remember - Jerry never wanted to hire Bill in the first place, but he had to suck it up in order to get support for Jerry world.

ok then

 

[acr731]

ok then

I guess you've never seen the drunken video of Jerry admitting why he hired Bill.

 

[jazzcat22]

I guess you've never seen the drunken video of Jerry admitting why he hired Bill.

We all know that was part of the reason, but it was not the only reason.