Best QB Game

[Mavs Man]

Roger Staubach 64+
Joe Montana 58
Otto Graham 41
John Elway 34
Troy Aikman 36
Johnny Unitas 33
Peyton Manning 23
Dan Marino 11-

 

[THUMPER]

Roger Staubach 64
Joe Montana 58
Otto Graham 42+
John Elway 34
Troy Aikman 36
Johnny Unitas 33
Peyton Manning 23
Dan Marino 10-

 

[Pukindog]

Roger Staubach 65 +
Joe Montana 57 -
Otto Graham 42
John Elway 34
Troy Aikman 36
Johnny Unitas 33
Peyton Manning 23
Dan Marino 10

 

[Nav22]

How the hell is Tom Brady off the list?

 

[ROMOSAPIEN9]

Aikman still had better statistics than Staubach and set most of the Cowboys passing records and that is a fact..

Roger Staubach not only was, but IS now currently a better QB than Troy Aikman...That Sir...is a/the FACT!!

There is 100% absolutely NOTHING that you can EVER say that will change that indisputable fact.

You wanna choose teams? I'll take Staubach...and my team will beat Aikman's team...EV-ER-Y TIME!!

I will NEVER back down from that stance....EVER!!

P.S. Staubach had a better career passer rating. No doubt that means nothing to you.....pffft

P.S.S. Steve Beuerlein woulda won those superbowls at QB with that team.

 

[THUMPER]

How the hell is Tom Brady off the list?

Probably because he has only played 8 seasons in the NFL and people are not yet convinced that he can maintain his statistics over the long haul. That and the fact/possibility that the Patriots cheated to win their SBs. At least that's why I voted him off the island.

 

[jackrussell]

Corrected list...wayne motley voted for,but did not add one point to Elway.

Roger Staubach 65
Joe Montana 57
Otto Graham 42
John Elway 35
Troy Aikman 36
Johnny Unitas 33
Peyton Manning 23
Dan Marino 10

 

[jackrussell]

Roger Staubach 65
Joe Montana 57
Otto Graham 43+
John Elway 35
Troy Aikman 36
Johnny Unitas 33
Peyton Manning 22-
Dan Marino 10

 

[Wolfpack]

Roger Staubach 65
Joe Montana 57
Otto Graham 44+
John Elway 35
Troy Aikman 36
Johnny Unitas 33
Peyton Manning 21-
Dan Marino 10

 

[tunahelper]

Aikman 1000 Baby YEAH!

 

[rcaldw]

Roger Staubach 65
Joe Montana 57
Otto Graham 44
John Elway 34-
Troy Aikman 37+
Johnny Unitas 33
Peyton Manning 21
Dan Marino 10

 

[rcaldw]

Roger Staubach not only was, but IS now currently a better QB than Troy Aikman...That Sir...is a/the FACT!!

There is 100% absolutely NOTHING that you can EVER say that will change that indisputable fact.

You wanna choose teams? I'll take Staubach...and my team will beat Aikman's team...EV-ER-Y TIME!!

I will NEVER back down from that stance....EVER!!

P.S. Staubach had a better career passer rating. No doubt that means nothing to you.....pffft

P.S.S. Steve Beuerlein woulda won those superbowls at QB with that team.

No response from me needed. You just did my job for me. Carry on.

 

[Rackat]

Roger Staubach 65
Joe Montana 58+
Otto Graham 44
John Elway 34
Troy Aikman 37
Johnny Unitas 33
Peyton Manning 20-
Dan Marino 10

 

[firehawk350]

Roger Staubach 65
Joe Montana 58+
Otto Graham 44
John Elway 34
Troy Aikman 37
Johnny Unitas 33
Peyton Manning 20-
Dan Marino 10

Well, there is your homer meter for you. Staubach better than Dan Marino, better than Johnny U, better than Montana... He was a good player, good QB and great leader but no way was he better than Marino, Elway and Montana.

 

[Rackat]

Well, there is your homer meter for you. Staubach better than Dan Marino, better than Johnny U, better than Montana... He was a good player, good QB and great leader but no way was he better than Marino, Elway and Montana.

Speaking of homerism, when the greatest QB's are discussed, I never hear Joe Theisman's name mentioned. Wonder why that is?

 

[firehawk350]

Speaking of homerism, when the greatest QB's are discussed, I never hear Joe Theisman's name mentioned. Wonder why that is?

He's not great maybe??? What, you expect me to defend him just because he was a Commander? I have no problem admitting Theismann wasn't great, he was just good.

Sammy Baugh was a great QB for his time, and was named ESPN's or SI's (one of the two, I forget) best all around player. The only player in history to throw 4 TD passes and intercept 4 passes in the same game.

Sonny Jerguson was probably among the top pure passers in history. He was just amazing throwing the ball. But, he isn't in the top 5 QB talk IMO.

Other than those two, I'm not overly impressed with any QB in team history. There were some good ones, but only those two qualify as great.

 

[THUMPER]

He's not great maybe??? What, you expect me to defend him just because he was a Commander? I have no problem admitting Theismann wasn't great, he was just good.

Sammy Baugh was a great QB for his time, and was named ESPN's or SI's (one of the two, I forget) best all around player. The only player in history to throw 4 TD passes and intercept 4 passes in the same game.

Sonny Jerguson was probably among the top pure passers in history. He was just amazing throwing the ball. But, he isn't in the top 5 QB talk IMO.

Other than those two, I'm not overly impressed with any QB in team history. There were some good ones, but only those two qualify as great.

I brought up Sammy Baugh earlier in this thread and I have him ranked in my top-5 all-time QBs (link) but he was not a contestant in this thread.

 

[Hostile]

Roger Staubach 65
Joe Montana 58
Otto Graham 44
John Elway 35 +
Troy Aikman 36 -
Johnny Unitas 33
Peyton Manning 20
Dan Marino 10

 

[firehawk350]

I brought up Sammy Baugh earlier in this thread and I have him ranked in my top-5 all-time QBs (link) but he was not a contestant in this thread.

I wasn't advocating their inclusion in this thread at all, he just asked about Theismann to see if I would homer it up so to head off his future questions (how about Rypien, how about Williams, how about Ramsey...) I told him the only Commander QBs that I consider among the league greats and tell him the rest run the gamut from good (Rypien) to horrible (Shuler).

 

[Rackat]

I wasn't advocating their inclusion in this thread at all, he just asked about Theismann to see if I would homer it up so to head off his future questions (how about Rypien, how about Williams, how about Ramsey...) I told him the only Commander QBs that I consider among the league greats and tell him the rest run the gamut from good (Rypien) to horrible (Shuler).

Actually, you quoted my QB rating post, in response I asked the question about Theisman. Since I had given points to Montana, I was curious why you would use my post as an example of homerism. I think we all know that the Commanders have not had an elite quarterback.