Brittle talent makes for murky decisions

erod

Well-Known Member
Messages
38,705
Reaction score
60,327
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Football equals injury. Injuries drive the plot of each season. They determine far more than draft expertism, choice of scheme, or coaching acumen.

We all know that. But our chosen team seems especially hung in purgatory, as if sitting blindfolded in the dark waiting for a 2x4 to the nether regions at any moment. It's palpable in the air.

Our quarterback's potential back-clavicle catastrophes loom over every snap of every game. Our star receiver plays like a bull still pinned up in the chute, always a danger to injuring himself, as he often does. Our running back has a long history of leg injuries, and his capable third-down replacement is lightning in an easily shattered bottle. Our tight end never misses, but is always hurt. Our defensive stars are a litany of oft-injuredness, and it bleeds throughout the front, middle, and back of that group. Lee, both McClains, Claiborne, Scandrick, Church, Crawford, Lawrence.....each has missed significant time.

This doesn't even include the handful of unpredictable key players that suffer from rectal-cranial inversion. Gregory will miss the early part of the season, and Hardy played and postured himself out of grace, at least until panic sets in.

I can't help but think this has Valley Ranch at a bit of loss. What to do? Whom to draft? What contingencies are most pressing? What are the worst and best case scenarios for a season almost certain to be riddled with necessary finagling and difficult decisions.

It makes me wonder if the upstairs aristocrats are full steam ahead for 2016, or if they're quietly preparing more for seasons to come than the months ahead. I hope both, but I certainly only Jerry is eyeing this season as make or break - like Romo - because their football worlds are facing an asteroid pretty soon.

Perhaps draft weekend will tell much, especially if Dallas goes QB at #4, or even more so if they trade up to ensure they grab their next franchise prize. If you think about it, it would be much easier to hold our attention if the coming season is lost again to injuries. They could still point to a clear plan.

The past two seasons are diametrically opposed to each other, and it must have the front office in constant debate. The coaches likely don't want a QB high. You know Romo and the long-timers don't. The front office probably does, as do many of us. Jerry is most certainly torn.

Most teams picking this high are awful. This one isn't. But most teams aren't seemingly this brittle and unpredictable either. So the right path isn't so clear.
 

Arkyvarminter

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,501
Reaction score
1,904
I know I'm in the minority but I want a QB at #4. Draft the best Defensive players you can get after that. As for a free agent QB being better than a rookie, that is an arguable point. You never know. I'd rather a rookie learn under Romo for a couple years than draft one when he's gone. I think Romo would be invaluable in that role. I know we need a Safety and we can get one in the later rounds. I still say our Defense isn't as bad as advertised. They stayed on the field last year due to a backup QB..........
 

RS12

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,529
Reaction score
29,874
Brittle talent makes for murky decisions

You forgot: while he hasnt been brittle, the starting TE is a geezer in football years.
 

HomeBiscuit

Well-Known Member
Messages
309
Reaction score
985
We actually haven't been hurt by injury nearly as much as some may wish. 2014 was an exceptional injury season and this past season is in fact a blessing compared to some other teams like the patriots. Hmm, the patriots, the same team that carried Matt cassell to 11-5. Let's stick to fixing the defense and leave the qb thing alone. Plus Kellen Moore is my boy.

http://boston.cbslocal.com/2015/12/23/patriots-are-nfls-most-injured-team-in-2015-according-to-data/

http://espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/page/32for32x151021/ranking-most-banged-nfl-teams-1-32
 
Last edited:

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
47,030
Reaction score
22,617
The main characters in Kismet would truly be in a morale delima right now...:)
 

texbumthelife

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,738
Reaction score
23,273
I know I'm in the minority but I want a QB at #4. Draft the best Defensive players you can get after that. As for a free agent QB being better than a rookie, that is an arguable point. You never know. I'd rather a rookie learn under Romo for a couple years than draft one when he's gone. I think Romo would be invaluable in that role. I know we need a Safety and we can get one in the later rounds. I still say our Defense isn't as bad as advertised. They stayed on the field last year due to a backup QB..........

You're definitely not in the minority, bro. Spend some time in the draft zone. It's probably a 70/30 split for taking a QB.
 

Redball Express

All Aboard!!!
Messages
16,253
Reaction score
12,758
Football equals injury. Injuries drive the plot of each season. They determine far more than draft expertism, choice of scheme, or coaching acumen.

We all know that. But our chosen team seems especially hung in purgatory, as if sitting blindfolded in the dark waiting for a 2x4 to the nether regions at any moment. It's palpable in the air.

Our quarterback's potential back-clavicle catastrophes loom over every snap of every game. Our star receiver plays like a bull still pinned up in the chute, always a danger to injuring himself, as he often does. Our running back has a long history of leg injuries, and his capable third-down replacement is lightning in an easily shattered bottle. Our tight end never misses, but is always hurt. Our defensive stars are a litany of oft-injuredness, and it bleeds throughout the front, middle, and back of that group. Lee, both McClains, Claiborne, Scandrick, Church, Crawford, Lawrence.....each has missed significant time.

This doesn't even include the handful of unpredictable key players that suffer from rectal-cranial inversion. Gregory will miss the early part of the season, and Hardy played and postured himself out of grace, at least until panic sets in.

I can't help but think this has Valley Ranch at a bit of loss. What to do? Whom to draft? What contingencies are most pressing? What are the worst and best case scenarios for a season almost certain to be riddled with necessary finagling and difficult decisions.

It makes me wonder if the upstairs aristocrats are full steam ahead for 2016, or if they're quietly preparing more for seasons to come than the months ahead. I hope both, but I certainly only Jerry is eyeing this season as make or break - like Romo - because their football worlds are facing an asteroid pretty soon.

Perhaps draft weekend will tell much, especially if Dallas goes QB at #4, or even more so if they trade up to ensure they grab their next franchise prize. If you think about it, it would be much easier to hold our attention if the coming season is lost again to injuries. They could still point to a clear plan.

The past two seasons are diametrically opposed to each other, and it must have the front office in constant debate. The coaches likely don't want a QB high. You know Romo and the long-timers don't. The front office probably does, as do many of us. Jerry is most certainly torn.

Most teams picking this high are awful. This one isn't. But most teams aren't seemingly this brittle and unpredictable either. So the right path isn't so clear.

I appreciate those that want to place all the chips on Romo and call..

I also wonder if not preparing for the future is wise.

Frankly..

I have come to the conclusion that Tony Romo is now not the answer for the present and definitely is a progress - stopper if we don't take a QB with our #4.

I understand his play is the only thing we have to point to if we are considered competitive.

And that's the probem.

We are too dependent as a team and as coaches on Romo.

It's been a run of bad luck with Tony from his fumbled FG against Seattle in '06 to his ill-fated Cabo vacation to his complete deflation against the Vikings in the playoffs to triple 8-8 seasons that sent this Franchise into the Sea of Apathy.

And in 2014..he had his best and last chance at a SB with Murray toting the rock.

It's time to turn the page on the Tony Romo Era.

He can play another year or two...

but we must capitalize on our 4-12 season with realistic vision.

If this is just a blip on the radar and we are going to rebound for a strong run at a World Title..fine.

If not, then we are still rebuilding for a run and QB has to be a top need since we have proven we can't win without Romo with the kind of QB quality we have afforded the team so far.

Do we need more defensive help?

Sure.

But defense is not going to win games for us right now.

Offense will.

I remember when Parcells wanted to install the 3-4 defense and it was supposed to immediately fix our problems.

We devoted 2 #1 's to rebuilding that defense with Spears and Ware as the foundation and the defense never did blossom and finally had to go back to the 4-3.

In the meantime..the offense and Romo were our signature.

The time has come to let Romo take his final shot at a championship but also become time to get a young QB ready to play. We do not have 4 years to develop a QB like it took Romo.

We have to procure a top level guy with the skill sets to move quickly if needed should Romo not be able to continue...if just for a few games or a whole season.

We are at a cross roads right now.

The team hangs in the balance.
 

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
47,030
Reaction score
22,617
Living on the edge and being part of CIS, is really tough...for sure, all those terrorists and dangers.

C'mon, not even through with free agency and the draft is now under a month, and wet diapers?
 

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
47,030
Reaction score
22,617
You forgot: while he hasnt been brittle, the starting TE is a geezer in football years.

Do tell us, in this youth based time arrangement, just when it is that Jason Falls below 500 yards receiving in a season? Yea, he is needing a wheel chair now...
 

dantheman41

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,064
Reaction score
545
You're definitely not in the minority, bro. Spend some time in the draft zone. It's probably a 70/30 split for taking a QB.

I'm pretty split... I kinda hoping we trade down a few spots and then pick the best of Zeke, Hargraves, Spence, Goff or Wentz
 

DandyDon1722

It's been a good 'un, ain't it?
Messages
6,386
Reaction score
7,008
I know I'm in the minority but I want a QB at #4. Draft the best Defensive players you can get after that. As for a free agent QB being better than a rookie, that is an arguable point. You never know. I'd rather a rookie learn under Romo for a couple years than draft one when he's gone. I think Romo would be invaluable in that role. I know we need a Safety and we can get one in the later rounds. I still say our Defense isn't as bad as advertised. They stayed on the field last year due to a backup QB..........

Very interesting post - Have you ever heard of Occams Razor?

It's a philosophical notation that basically says when all other explanations fail - the obvious one is the answer.

We haven't addressed one of the most important aspects of the team in the off season thus far - a back up QB. We ignored it in FA and have consistently denied we are going after a QB in the first round. Could it be that everything we've been hearing about the Cowboys has been a Jerry and Stephen smokescreen and we are actually going to select wither Wentz or Goff?

You might be in the minority but hang in there - you might be right.
 

LocimusPrime

Well-Known Member
Messages
34,091
Reaction score
92,903
Very interesting post - Have you ever heard of Occams Razor?

It's a philosophical notation that basically says when all other explanations fail - the obvious one is the answer.

We haven't addressed one of the most important aspects of the team in the off season thus far - a back up QB. We ignored it in FA and have consistently denied we are going after a QB in the first round. Could it be that everything we've been hearing about the Cowboys has been a Jerry and Stephen smokescreen and we are actually going to select wither Wentz or Goff?

You might be in the minority but hang in there - you might be right.

I've heard of that razor theory. We haven't really addressed DE either. We let hardy walk, Gregory has a suspension, don't re-sign j Crawford or mincey but get some practice squad dude from the Raiders. Doesn't make logical sense.
 

Alexander

What's it going to be then, eh?
Messages
62,482
Reaction score
67,294
Most teams picking this high are awful. This one isn't. But most teams aren't seemingly this brittle and unpredictable either. So the right path isn't so clear.

Sadly, I think the organization stops at your first two sentences and thinks last year was just a bad dream.

They have an amazing ability to ignore warning signs and overrate the talent on the roster, plus their mortality. That has been an on-going and prevalent tendency for the culture forever. I doubt they are preparing in the slightest for the "unexpected". That would be way outside their narrow scope of thought.
 

dfense

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,109
Reaction score
6,542
Football equals injury. Injuries drive the plot of each season. They determine far more than draft expertism, choice of scheme, or coaching acumen.

We all know that. But our chosen team seems especially hung in purgatory, as if sitting blindfolded in the dark waiting for a 2x4 to the nether regions at any moment. It's palpable in the air.

Our quarterback's potential back-clavicle catastrophes loom over every snap of every game. Our star receiver plays like a bull still pinned up in the chute, always a danger to injuring himself, as he often does. Our running back has a long history of leg injuries, and his capable third-down replacement is lightning in an easily shattered bottle. Our tight end never misses, but is always hurt. Our defensive stars are a litany of oft-injuredness, and it bleeds throughout the front, middle, and back of that group. Lee, both McClains, Claiborne, Scandrick, Church, Crawford, Lawrence.....each has missed significant time.

This doesn't even include the handful of unpredictable key players that suffer from rectal-cranial inversion. Gregory will miss the early part of the season, and Hardy played and postured himself out of grace, at least until panic sets in.

I can't help but think this has Valley Ranch at a bit of loss. What to do? Whom to draft? What contingencies are most pressing? What are the worst and best case scenarios for a season almost certain to be riddled with necessary finagling and difficult decisions.

It makes me wonder if the upstairs aristocrats are full steam ahead for 2016, or if they're quietly preparing more for seasons to come than the months ahead. I hope both, but I certainly only Jerry is eyeing this season as make or break - like Romo - because their football worlds are facing an asteroid pretty soon.

Perhaps draft weekend will tell much, especially if Dallas goes QB at #4, or even more so if they trade up to ensure they grab their next franchise prize. If you think about it, it would be much easier to hold our attention if the coming season is lost again to injuries. They could still point to a clear plan.

The past two seasons are diametrically opposed to each other, and it must have the front office in constant debate. The coaches likely don't want a QB high. You know Romo and the long-timers don't. The front office probably does, as do many of us. Jerry is most certainly torn.

Most teams picking this high are awful. This one isn't. But most teams aren't seemingly this brittle and unpredictable either. So the right path isn't so clear.

I couldn't find any silver lining in that whole post. Sounds like the whole team is an injury. Guys who have never missed a game are brittle? Glass is half empty, sky is falling, etc.
 

dfense

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,109
Reaction score
6,542
Draft a QB, he'll sit, learn, improve, then be ready. To leave. -Osweiler
 

Redball Express

All Aboard!!!
Messages
16,253
Reaction score
12,758
Draft a QB, he'll sit, learn, improve, then be ready. To leave. -Osweiler

There is no way to prevent a player from leaving if the team isn't willing or is unable to afford him.

You can't make a decision based on an unknown like that.

When Romo moves on, his contract will be available to be used to re-sign whomever.

That's a big chunk of change.

Osweiler deserves whatever he gets.

Living up to it is another thing altogether.
 

erod

Well-Known Member
Messages
38,705
Reaction score
60,327
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
I couldn't find any silver lining in that whole post. Sounds like the whole team is an injury. Guys who have never missed a game are brittle? Glass is half empty, sky is falling, etc.

In their defense, they have a significant amount of money tied up in Dez, Lee, Romo, Crawford, etc.

They kind of have to bet on their health and contribution, or what's the point of even keeping them. And it is plausible that they could be healthy again this year. Every team gets decimated by injuries certain years.

But I think we all feel the tipping point that exists with this team. We just hold our breath.
 
Top