Twitter: Broaddus: Josh Ball only had two bad plays

viman96

Thread Killer
Messages
21,561
Reaction score
22,665
Jimmy Johnson would talk about evaluating a player on how many bad plays they had versus how many good ones.

Jimmy may have cut Ball to send a message to the rest of the team. He (Ball) is the type of player Jimmy would use as example too.
 

DCreppinBoysfan

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,169
Reaction score
4,127
I’m starting to see why broadus fell out favor with the organization from a scouting standpoint. He said it before that the Jones stopped valuing his input a long time ago and now I understand why
 

Proof

Well-Known Member
Messages
13,309
Reaction score
14,791
That was the perception.

That was hardly the reality.

https://cowboyszone.com/threads/the-official-sober-assessment-of-josh-ball.498825/

Here's what Todd Archer said about Tyron Smith after his rookie preseason... sounds a lot like what could be accurately said for Ball...

LWR_Recording.png


Have become increasingly persuaded, based partially on what I've read Cowboys fans on Twitter say, that the attitude is rooted in his indiscretion at 18 yrs old.

He's 24. He's not had any new history in that way. But it still appears to color how some if not many fans look at the guy.

that doesn't sound similar at all. I mean that sounds like an accurate depiction of his game on sunday. Also Tyron was a 20 yr old rookie... in training camp. As you said this guy is already 24
 

_sturt_

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,645
Reaction score
4,567
that doesn't sound similar at all. I mean that sounds like an accurate depiction of his game on sunday.

Of the two of us, I'm inclined to believe I'm the one who actually did a play by play review of every Ball snap in the preseason... DEN, where he legitimately did not play well... and then over the course of the two games vs LAC and SEA, a holding penalty, one tackle for loss and one sack. He may have had a false start, but I'm cloudy on that.

For the other dozens of plays from scrimmage, he was somewhere in the spectrum from adequate to very good.

And yes, I'll agree, it also sounds like an accurate description of his game on Sunday.

Also Tyron was a 20 yr old rookie... in training camp. As you said this guy is already 24

Okay. So?

I'm only suggesting that rookies, no matter their age, tend to need some time to acclimate... surely that's not some out-there concept. I'm not bashing Tyron. I'm suggesting that if a 1st round pick needs time to acclimate, then most certainly a 4th round pick does.

Ball is a rookie Cowboy. I've been a fan since the 1970 season. I can't recall ever seeing a plurality of Cowboy fans so predisposed to beat on a player in his first season playing the game at a professional level.

I also can't ever recall seeing the media so allergic to a player. They didn't talk to him in preseason to my knowledge, and certainly haven't talked to him since. The only time I believe anyone has even heard Ball's voice was the interviews on draft day. Now, to be fair to media, that could be by his own discretion--part of the court decree in 2016 was that he could never speak to the media about any of the abuse history, and he just prefers to limit any possibility of that. (Btw, that also applied to his ex-gf... which would suggest that the violence was not one-sided, fwiw, since there wouldn't seem to be any reason for a court to demand that of a person who was only a victim.)

Josh Ball is ours.

He has six years of evidence as far as we can know of putting that kind of behavior behind him. Football-wise he deserves the same patience that has ever been extended to any Cowboys rookie ever. He's a 4th rounder. He was never expected to come into the league as a plug-and-play product. He needs development like most. But he's shown promise also like most. It's not too much to ask that he be treated like any other 4th rounder since or before him in their first season.


Here's one guy's closer look at the film from yesterday....

 
Last edited:

Silverz1972

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,605
Reaction score
2,245
I saw at least 6 bad plays.

he is not bad at run blocking. Might be good to bring in on a goal line package. He’s a strong **

he needs a lot of work in pass blocking. His feet are crap.
 

Bagman

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,212
Reaction score
3,326
He's correct. 2 bad plays. That's how many I counted as well. I also counted 9 awful plays.
 
Top