My view of the #27 pick and safety...
I would be intrigued if Allen were to be available. Many fans aren't very enamored with a high placement for Mays.
I'm not as high on the Combine type of measureables. Football players are harder to beat than just great athletes. Ken Hamlin plays a strong role in the Dallas secondary. Not all of that is matched up with the speedy receivers. There are cornerbacks for that specific coverage problem. The team was confident in leaving him matched up with the good tight ends and receivers that were faced. He wasn't abused in those matchups.
I question how much improvement occurs if not one of the top two safeties were used to send Hamlin packing. Ball and Watkins both might be fine in a trade off consideration just for the backup quality.
Mike Hamlin was drafted for his coverage as well as collegiate ability to go for the ball. I wonder how much less he would merit than those less than the top tier of this draft. Since time is needed to develop even a top tier addition, that causes me to start to question matchups that project to a top level and already functional element to arrive at 'upgrade.' Other than Thomas and Allen, I would have to weigh more in line with upcoming needs elsewhere on the team.
At linebacker, even Bradie James has hit that 30 point of his career. I wouldn't rest well expecting Bobby Carpenter to replace him. J Williams looks to project into where Keith Brooking plays, the weak side, but the strong side is another story. Hodge was brought in to contend in a package type position, but won't even be ready for the field during the pre-camp training this summer. He may well have already missed his train onto the roster.
The future is quickly arriving in the interior of the linebacker group...and I'm not sure I project into a J Williams and Bobbie Carpenter interior just yet. The speed of J Williams is tempting, and he eases my concerns. But there is Carpenter, and he just doesn't sooth my senses for the middle of a defense outside of package considerations.
Middle linebacker is a pretty important team function. Allow me to shed some light here:
'With Jake Delhomme gone, and young Matt Moore (8 career starts) installed at quarterback, the Panthers would seem to have a leadership void. But actually the team’s guiding light didn’t go anywhere. The leader in question is middle linebacker Jon Beason, who will be counted on to help sustain the old Panther mentality as the roster turns over. That’s important, with a crew of vets jettisoned and the front office under strict spending limits. And Carolina believes Beason is up for the job. “It’s two things,’’ coach John Fox said. “One, the nature of that position, because you’re at the heart of it, you’re the signal-caller, and some of that just happens. Not that your middle ’backer has to be the leader of your defense, but it just turns out that way quite a bit. And he has some of those natural leadership skills. It’s not always rah-rah. Sometimes those things that are needed to be said are on Monday after practice or after a game, not so much during a game. It can be how you react when there’s a crisis. Jon’s got those skills.’’ Beason just turned 25, but in three seasons, he’s been in on 419 tackles, started 48 games, and made two Pro Bowls.'
*(by Albert Breer)
See anyone on the Cowboy roster that will quickly fill the shoes of either Keith Brooking or Bradie James? Excuse me, if I don't get carried away with the plate dejure for this season, and stick with an older set of values as to what is needed first...
For the past five years, the fandom and many of the media have been on the drum beat of wide receiver for Dallas. Well, they struck rare mineral content through free agency following the draft. But they did strike talent...and then there are indicators by Jerry himself, taking the receiver missings out of the frying pan for this draft. If Bryant reached Dallas at 27, then a real decision would have to be made. He is real talent....it won't happen. Just as it won't happen that either Thomas or Allen reach that point in the draft for Dallas. If Dallas desires either of them, then have to pay for the dance and move up to acquire them. I'm not sure that Jerry is intent on weathering more media itensity that would cloud both himself and his team.
At safety, I feel what is already on the shelf merits confidence. Ken Hamlin might not be an All Pro right now, but he is a fully functional veteran. He is at least better than what Dallas had with the departed cornerback, Henry.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not opposed to going to safety, a coverage type, in the top three rounds...but at #27, I would expand considerations quite an extent. I would include linebacker, and even defensive end/nose tackle to that. This group of defensive linemen in the top three rounds are pretty strong also. I would be even more eager to add a top of draft defensive end to 'push' the combination of Hatcher, Bowen, and Spears.
There usually are just about 22-24 players each year, that actually have first round grades. That puts Dallas, less some free falling of these, right at the lower return level for their draft spot. Now if some quarterbacks push into the first round, some players might fall. If they don't and a team wants to cherry pick a quarterback, then trading into the top of round two, and taking an aggressive and strong linebacker and defensive end would be smart. That would leave the third and fourth rounds for the offensive tackle and guard/center selections. A developing and 'small school' cornerback and safety could be brought in that could be brought to speed, but in a lower round. That makes more sense to me...given the present and need to push up to a Super Bowl this season.
At safety, I would make a real push for Ram's safety, Atogwe...and move to strengths of this draft that match with 'future' needs on this team. I would build the defensive interior, middle linebackers, and offensive line first...and then add a strong developer at both safety and corner.
If like Jerry Jones has been stating, wide receiver and safety starters are eliminated due to players available in range, then priorities do shift in this draft. Position limiting, to safety and receiver, do take a ding until value alone is the cause, as in lower rounds...