There were red flags with Amari when he came here. However he’s been very productive and a player that we have to re-sign. We used a first round pick on him in 2018 and he’s a key cog to what we’re doing on offense. Sure, there’s some concerns with him but we can’t pay Dak and move on from his best target.
Yes. There were red flags before he came here. He played well early. Then the same red flags popped back up. That indicates a high probability of a pattern which is more substantial than just a red flag.
Yes. We gave up a first round pick for him. That ship has sailed. We used a first round pick on Taco too. Those are “sunk costs”.
It is irrelevant what we gave for either one of those guys. The only thing that matters is what we do with them after those costs have already been paid.
We “cut bait” with Taco, right, wrong, or indifferently. Now what about Cooper?
IDK what they are going to do. The red flags are still waving. It reminds me of the Dez situation without Dez’ mental midgetry.
We don’t “have” to pay Cooper anything. We can choose to pay Cooper, tag and trade him or let him walk and probably get a 3rd round comp pick for him. No one really knows what would be best.
But the salary cap IS FINITE. We know we can’t pay everyone. I would be making the hard decisions now. I would move on from Amari, and maybe Byron too in exchange for picks.
You could over pay Dak slightly and save enough by tagging and trading Byron and Cooper for picks to offset it some. All of those are just options.
You might get a Thielen type of receiver out of this draft and not miss a beat from Amari and save close to $20m per year. Or maybe you get lucky and draft Lamb or Jeudy at #17 and save a boatload of money.
We don’t HAVE to do anything. We have options. The team needs to not be afraid of making the wrong decision.
The odds of Amari being worth $20M per year for 5 full years is not a good bet.