Choice for Cromartie rumors... would you do it?

[Coakleys Dad]

no way no how....

this trade is not even close for me honestly

Tashard is real talent, just under-utilized IMO due to two other RBs ahead of him. MBIII I think will be the odd man out if you ask me.

Do we really need an underachieving CB that bad to trade away someone like Choice?

I think even the rumor is an embarrassment.

i feel the same way.

 

[Wood]

I would do Cromartie for Choice in heart beat.

 

[Bob Sacamano]

no thanks

 

[jswalker1981]

Ok, so would you trade a third round pick for Cromartie? And remember it is a low third round pick, and we could be getting a potential stud cb (he has already played at a very high level).

 

[cowboyschmps3]

well i wldnt like for it to happen unless hes released but he can prolly play safety...

 

[Eskimo]

The fact that Cromartie is even being talked about as available is all the proof I need to suggest that he is a cancer that should be avoided. I don't particularly care what kind of cancer it is.

 

[Big Country]

Hell No!!

 

[Spectre]

This has probably been discussed on the other thread...but I see more value in three good corners vs three good rbs. You play one RB at a time, while you play 2 or 3 corners at a time.[\quote]

I agree with this line of thinking.

 

[Rudy]

I think this would be a great trade for SD. The idea of Choice and Sproles feels like it could be a perfect combo. That being said, I pray that it never happens. Choice for feature back in 2k10!

 

[Rudy]

Anybody that thinks Cromartie is a cancer but good enough to outweigh Choice in value should re-watch this:

This team has become a unit - I don't think it needs any heavy tampering.

 

[reddyuta]

Choice is the future ,he can be a workhorse and still be very productive.we need all 3 RBs as we have seen for two seasons .

 

[Kaika]

I think I would do it.

I think that running backs are easier to replace than a very good corner.

 

[miamicowboy21]

I would do this right now!!!...I'm still upset we passed him over 5 years ago for Carpenter. Cromartie is a star and should be wearing one on his helmet!!

 

[Idgit]

Threads like these tell you so much about the mentality of our posters. That's not a snark, I'm just shocked how many people would trade anyone for a problem like Cromartie at this stage of his career.

 

[miamicowboy21]

Threads like these tell you so much about the mentality of our posters. That's not a snark, I'm just shocked how many people would trade anyone for a problem like Cromartie at this stage of his career.

Yeah, why would I want a 6'3 playmaking corner like cromartie. With the pass rush we have you could pencil in cromartie for at least 6 picks. Explain to me what is the PROBLEM with him other than the fact he dosent use condoms. The guy makes plays and he plays a premium position.

 

[superonyx]

Threads like these tell you so much about the mentality of our posters. That's not a snark, I'm just shocked how many people would trade anyone for a problem like Cromartie at this stage of his career.

I think the reason people are willing to part with an underutilized 3rd rb is because they dont think dallas will use him much this year either......Now if barber was cut today then it would be different. We like choice, just dont want to watch him sit the bench another year and then leave for nothing next year.

 

[Cover 2]

Only way I'd do it is if Cromartie moves to safety.

And I dont think that's going to happen.

I'll keep Choice.

I doubt he's smart enough to play safety. I would rather keep Choice as well, because I figure he will start seeing a huge increase in carries.

 

[Cover 2]

I would do this right now!!!...I'm still upset we passed him over 5 years ago for Carpenter. Cromartie is a star and should be wearing one on his helmet!!

No he's not. He sucks.

 

[RealCowboyfan]

I find this hard to believe, but I'm throwing it out there as food for thought...

I just heard for the past 3/4 hour on talk radio (I think it was ESPN) guys discussing a possible Tashard Choice for Antonio Cromartie trade.

It sounded theoretical to me but it got me to thinking...is it a good trade?

What do you think?

Don't do it unless you getting Cromartie and a 3rd or 4th round draft pick.

 

[the truth of it all]

Agreeing with post about football iq of some posters here.

Are you serious?

Unless he's going to play saftey or newman , possibly jenkins is going to play free safety you dont do that. Thats ********.