peplaw06;2947088 said:
You didn't answer the question.
And Campo is pretty well regarded in defensive circles. It reeks of an axe to grind to say he's awful as a talent evaluator. Clearly coached some pretty decent talent.
I admit, I dislike Campo, as a coach (seems likeable enough otherwise). His tenure as HC had something to do with it. But guys like Charles Haley and Ryan McNeil were not high on his coaching ability. Deion and Woodson absolutely love him.
What I see is that Campo did not cut it as a HC in Dallas, a DC in Cleveland, or even as a secondary coach in Jacksonville. So clearly his 'star' as a coach does not shine that brightly. And I do have an axe to grind, I would have preferred to bring in a coach who was on the rise, not on the decline. So, yes, I am biased, but not blind.
Campo's talent evaluation and development is on display for any to see during his days as the Cowboys HC. How many of those players ever went on to be worth anything? Especially the position group that was his forte, the defensive backs. He hit on jack. Other than Roy Williams, a consensus top 10 pick, the players of his era were as dismal as their record. He was not just bad, he was HISTORICALLY bad.
And just to bring it back on topic, I will find that bit of Campo pushing for the Smith pick. Like I said, I am biased, not blind.
But maybe a little deaf.