Columbo... rest of the NFL not interested?

lspain1

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,372
Reaction score
33
JJT described him as a "marginal athlete" whatever that means. Colombo remains an enigma. Has he peaked or will he continue to improve? I really liked his jacking up of Hall last season and he seemed our only OL who had a mean streak on the field. I really can't blame the guy letting FA run for while and see if the offers improve. We'll see.
 

InmanRoshi

Zone Scribe
Messages
18,334
Reaction score
90
Colombo would probably have a lot of interest if he would come down off his price, but Colombo is playing his cards exactly as he should. He has an offer from the Cowboys (and maybe a few other teams), in his back pocket, now he should go out and see if he can't do better. Now that Pettigout is off the market, there's not any other starting caliber OT's that could take Colombo's offers and there's still almost 6 weeks until the draft. You never know when there is going to be an injury or off the field incident that is going to put a team in a desperate situation.

And Jerry and the Cowboys are playing it exactly as they should, as well.
 

burmafrd

Well-Known Member
Messages
43,820
Reaction score
3,379
I would not take JJTs word that day is day and night is night as regards player capabilities. Its hard to tell how much more physically he can improve. He can almost certainly get stronger- considering he has only really been able to work out seriously for a little over a year. He can also get better technicially- his total starts are only around 22 or so- maybe a total of a year and a half. So there is every reason to believe that he can improve.
 

Redball Express

All Aboard!!!
Messages
16,253
Reaction score
12,758
..interest from other teams.

It's just that he's not a bargain at this point given the salary demands being mentioned and the fact that the number of years he wants maybe scaring teams off.

Columbo is definitely in the second or third tier of FA out there.

:rolleyes:

He's not an absolute gem of a player and we have a tendency as fans to see even average play from a player at RT as being a godsend.

And even one year of stability as necessitating a knee-jerk reaction of wanting to sign him for more than he's worth.

Dallas doesn't want to do that.

At this point, I think he's what Dallas would want, because they don't have a high draft pick involved with his coming here and so far, Dallas has gotten their way with what they offered to do and paid minimally.

On the other hand, making a big contract mistake if this suddenly flat-lines and Columbo's knee doesn't hold up, that's another crisis waiting to happen.

:mad:

Dallas will avoid that.

So I think the way to do this is to give him his 3 year deal but the 3rd year should be voidable by the player should he meet certain incentives in the contract.

Also, if he makes the incentives, part of those are the bonuses that would equal what he's presently asking for the first two years.

Then Dallas can decide if he's made them, he'll get his new contract offer and it will be a wopper at that time.

Or if not, Columbo can re-enter the FA market two years from now with higher demands than now and will get it and more.

It's a win-win deal.

:)

I think that the team and the player should both be rewarded and protected based on appropriate results.

Nothing wrong with that.

We'd all like to see Columbo be a sweet deal for a team in need of the position being filled by somebody with something to prove.

I think what the word is that Dallas already has a reasonable offer in place given the risk-reward and that any team who will exceed it has shifted the deal to the risk side and not the reward side of the equation.

Just take one look at the history with Rodgers, Al Johnson, Peterman and others like Rivera who either had injury histories or now have them once here.

Where are they today...?

Gone or quickly fading out of the future plans of the team like with Rivera.

:(

And leaving a debris field behind with blown draft choices and cap busts galore.

The percentages are not in Dallas' favor with Columbo.

Clearly. As much as Columbo and his agent would like to think otherwise.

As hard as it is being a fan and wanting progress at RT..the team is just as committed to not making another mistake.

If Columbo doesn't quickly step in and make the needed adjustments to his offer, I think Dallas has no choice but to pull the trigger on whatever other option it must do..

..either pursue another FA that will fit at G and move Davis to ROT or make a trade for one with some team that has somebody it will let go for similar or even higher monies than Columbo, but has a track record and a health history better than Marc's.

I think Columbo will and should get this done quickly.

If I was him, if Davis was going to be on my left and drawing attention from the defense, that's got to make my life much easier and the pressure on the body week in and week out a blessing.

:eek:

Over the next couple of years, if he stays healthy and hungry, he should be able to learn alot and increase his value so that the next contract will be double what he's thinking he's worth now.

But he has to pay his dues to get there.

The consensus is definitely that Marc Columbo hasn't done that yet.

Dallas should give him the chance and Columbo should seize the opportunity Dallas has ready for him.

To me, it's a no-brainer.

In Dallas, all he has to do is just play again as well as last year and hopefully improve some.

If he goes elsewhere, he runs the risk of being viewed as a player who is suspect and evaled as to whatever deal he got as being too much possibly.

I'd also consider that the trainers and coaches in Dallas, especially Tony Sparano, have had a lot to do with Columbo's success in the last 18 months.

More is going to be needed from the doctors, trainers and coaches. Dallas has it already in place and knows the player and how to help him progress.

Going elsewhere means starting over and possibly a worst situation that could cause a regression in his progress.

Now what is that worth to Columbo in the way of money vs. his possible future..?

Sign Marc.

Here's the pen.

Now go hit the weight room and your new Best Friend Leonard Davis will call you shortly to ask you what's going on with the OL and what's Sparano really like.

:starspin

RedBaLL ExPreSS
 

YosemiteSam

Unfriendly and Aloof!
Messages
45,858
Reaction score
22,189
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
InmanRoshi;1411394 said:
Colombo would probably have a lot of interest if he would come down off his price, but Colombo is playing his cards exactly as he should. He has an offer from the Cowboys (and maybe a few other teams), in his back pocket, now he should go out and see if he can't do better. Now that Pettigout is off the market, there's not any other starting caliber OT's that could take Colombo's offers and there's still almost 6 weeks until the draft. You never know when there is going to be an injury or off the field incident that is going to put a team in a desperate situation.

And Jerry and the Cowboys are playing it exactly as they should, as well.

Well, he had better not wait until the draft, or he will lose the offers that he has. I think his window is closing fast. Pro-days alone could cause his offer to shrink. Personally, I think he should try and get a one year deal at $3.5M. If he plays another 16 games like last season, his value should jump closer to $5M/yr
 

MichaelWinicki

"You want some?"
Staff member
Messages
47,997
Reaction score
27,917
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
nyc;1411525 said:
Well, he had better not wait until the draft, or he will lose the offers that he has. I think his window is closing fast. Pro-days alone could cause his offer to shrink. Personally, I think he should try and get a one year deal at $3.5M. If he plays another 16 games like last season, his value should jump closer to $5M/yr

If I'm the Cowboys I do not sign him for a single year-- that would create the possibility of having to replace BOTH starting offensive tackles next offeseason since Flozell's contract expires after the '07 season.

Just the thought of having to replace both tackles after the '07 season makes me queasy.
 

GimmeTheBall!

Junior College Transfer
Messages
37,691
Reaction score
18,040
neosapien23;1411164 said:
I will never get why Dallas just didn't franchise him. That would have insured that they kept his rights and would have bought them another year to evalulate his play.

I don't see him that way. Besides, designating him a franchise player automatically puts him in a higher salary bracket.

T.O., Romo, McBriar, the RBs, Ware, Carp -- those are the franchise-tier type players. Columbo is a bubble guy.
 

5Stars

Here comes the Sun...
Messages
37,847
Reaction score
16,869
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Redball Express;1411518 said:
Sign Marc.

Here's the pen.

Now go hit the weight room and your new Best Friend Leonard Davis will call you shortly to ask you what's going on with the OL and what's Sparano really like.

:starspin

RedBaLL ExPreSS


RedBall, I like your posts, but man, you are a long winded dude! I bet you were vaccinated with a phonograph needle! :eek:
 

zekecee

When Posting...Please Use Caution
Messages
226
Reaction score
4
Jordan Black is off the board...Its getting close to the 11th hour for ole Columbo!
 
Top