quickccc
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 16,787
- Reaction score
- 14,606
Logan is not a western but has similar traits of a Western.
Have you ever seen Shane? Both movies are different but share similar themes. The Outlaw Josey Wales is not as strong yet another fair comparison between a Western and Neo-Western like Logan.
I am assuming Watchmen was boring and made it tedious to watch. That is my guess since its length (162 minutes) and The Dark Knight's (152 minutes) are almost the same.
Watchmen has its flaws but is also a true mystery film at its core. I think a few scenes could have been edited out and would have made it more receptive to general audiences.
That said, I probably considered it a better movie overall than most. Personally, I think reaction to the movie itself overshadows a pretty good performance by Jackie Earle Haley.
His Rorschach portrayal was hardcore, almost The Punisher like in some ways--especially during his prison scenes.
The big difference is the Christopher Nolan’s ' Dark Knight " had such extraordinary twists and plots that constantly keep you going, constantly kept you thinking, clueing, trying to anticipate
and predict what is gonna happen next, only to keep sustaining the surprise element,
it chess-gamed and play Jeopardy with you, occupied and captivated you with such intrigue that the long length time wasn’t even thought of.
it's so much going on, and so much to offer, it easily masks the long length.
plus on top of all that - then add in on Heath Ledger's magnificent Oscar winning acting performance
The ' Watchmen " actually had interesting characters, action parts and suspense in parts, but its also built and ran off long talk, philosophical dialog and long pace.
As you said, it could have (should have) been edited down to make it more receptive... and sufficient.