Comparing this team to 2017

waldoputty

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,375
Reaction score
21,163
as far as i am concerned, rico replaces the best remaining part of dez - ability to fight for the ball, and he can do it better with large catch radius
he is also a heavier larger target to get the tough yards that witten does.
 

charleshaleyfan94

Well-Known Member
Messages
424
Reaction score
336
dont agree.

what sank this team last year?
1. tsmith injury
2. zeke suspension
3. bad lb play

what has happened - ALL 3 have been solved - and should get us at least 2 games.
1. tsmith seems as healthy as last year. fleming is proven swing tackle. furthermore, williams can play tackle as needed. that is 2 backups for tsmith.
2. zeke suspension - lets hope zeke behaves all season and there is currently no pending investigation.
3. jaylon is better. thomas is good backup for lee. lve is depth piece that could force his way into starting lineup during the season.

what else improved
1. passrush - dlaw and gregory bookends - both can get more than 10 sacks. if irving returns, that is 3 major passrush threats. with each passrusher, the pressure gets much more intense.
2. corner play should be as good if not better with chido more experienced
3. austin provides a threat that takes some of the attention away from zeke - making zeke more effective.
4. richards is now running the defense and may not do the marinelli prevent defense when we are winning.

other question marks
1. dez gone - i believe rico replaces dez on fade/jump ball routes. dez was no longer top 10 wr last year.
2. witten gone - sure he was safety valve but rico can be a huge massive target that can catch with contact going on.
3. wr's are better match for dak skills in that they should have better separation. hurns had better average separation than dez did - almost double.
4. tfred - big question though it seems they caught it early. question is who is backup c.
5. kicker

I have a concern with the OL. If we had 3 Flemings, I would feel a lot better about them.
Worst concern is that Cooper Rush is our #2 QB. We need a very productive vet backup who knows how to win football games that Dak can exchange football knowledge with. Kellen Moore never won an NFL game and is oblivious and should be coaching 1st graders.
I have a big concern with the TE position. Other than Rico at times, they are invisible.
I have a big concern with only 2 starting RBs.
I have a big concern that they kept Noah Brown, who was as unproductive as Ryan Switzer. (TWO wasted draft picks). I think Noah Brown caught one pass last year for around 5 yards.
I have a concern with the kicking game. I would have given Bailey another year to see if he regained his "mojo".
The WRs are a question mark. Would have cut Noah Brown (and.. he's hurt. How is he going to help this team win football games??) Would have kept Lenoir and whoever else contributed.
And last of all: SAFETY!! We are in trouble here!!

The front office are bringing in "bodies" instead of playmakers and this is the kiss of death while the other front offices who are serious about winning NFL football games, have great personnel who know to scoop up to help them WIN... and they are not messing around about it.
 

LocimusPrime

Well-Known Member
Messages
34,091
Reaction score
92,903
Agree with some but still see problems that will prevent this team from having much success. See 8-8

Swing tackle is upgraded. Overall oline is worse.
Young qb with no safety valve and center that's not very expierenced and cant help dak near as much as tfred.
Tes are worse.
Wrs could be worse or better.
Dline should be better but I think it's being overhyped.
Jaylon will be better plus better depth.
Same hc
Same oc
Rougher schedule
:hammer:
 

waldoputty

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,375
Reaction score
21,163
I have a concern with the OL. If we had 3 Flemings, I would feel a lot better about them.
Worst concern is that Cooper Rush is our #2 QB. We need a very productive vet backup who knows how to win football games that Dak can exchange football knowledge with. Kellen Moore never won an NFL game and is oblivious and should be coaching 1st graders.
I have a big concern with the TE position. Other than Rico at times, they are invisible.
I have a big concern with only 2 starting RBs.
I have a big concern that they kept Noah Brown, who was as unproductive as Ryan Switzer. (TWO wasted draft picks). I think Noah Brown caught one pass last year for around 5 yards.
I have a concern with the kicking game. I would have given Bailey another year to see if he regained his "mojo".
The WRs are a question mark. Would have cut Noah Brown (and.. he's hurt. How is he going to help this team win football games??) Would have kept Lenoir and whoever else contributed.
And last of all: SAFETY!! We are in trouble here!!

The front office are bringing in "bodies" instead of playmakers and this is the kiss of death while the other front offices who are serious about winning NFL football games, have great personnel who know to scoop up to help them WIN... and they are not messing around about it.

3 flemings? not needed. bottom line is that they got a decent g/t backup in ehinger. they got fleming. that is 2 vet backup who have multiple starts. if tfred comes back, that is 3 experienced quality backups and much better than what we had.
2 rb - actually 3 as austin can play there. furthermore, they guess right and darius and bo are available to go to practice squad. i expect additional rb to be on 53 after 2-3 players moved to ir. hopefully only 2 because tfred is expected back before 8 games.
noah is on 53 but can go to ir. cutting lenoir has proven to be the right move as he was not claimed and can go on 53 if they want him or the ps.
finally if dak is injured for a significant amount of games, season is over and rush is good for tanking
 

charleshaleyfan94

Well-Known Member
Messages
424
Reaction score
336
3 flemings? not needed. bottom line is that they got a decent g/t backup in ehinger. they got fleming. that is 2 vet backup who have multiple starts. if tfred comes back, that is 3 experienced quality backups and much better than what we had.
2 rb - actually 3 as austin can play there. furthermore, they guess right and darius and bo are available to go to practice squad. i expect additional rb to be on 53 after 2-3 players moved to ir. hopefully only 2 because tfred is expected back before 8 games.
noah is on 53 but can go to ir. cutting lenoir has proven to be the right move as he was not claimed and can go on 53 if they want him or the ps.
finally if dak is injured for a significant amount of games, season is over and rush is good for tanking
there is no reason on earth, after Cooper Rush's preseason performance, to be on this roster.
 

waldoputty

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,375
Reaction score
21,163
there is no reason on earth, after Cooper Rush's preseason performance, to be on this roster.
he knows the system and it takes too long for another qb to come up to speed to backup
white is the development guy who will likely need at least 1 year.
besides if dak is injured, season is over so tank to get the better picks.
 

charleshaleyfan94

Well-Known Member
Messages
424
Reaction score
336
as far as i am concerned, rico replaces the best remaining part of dez - ability to fight for the ball, and he can do it better with large catch radius
he is also a heavier larger target to get the tough yards that witten does.
and Rico might go out on suspension which means we don't have a TE.. Period
 

charleshaleyfan94

Well-Known Member
Messages
424
Reaction score
336
he knows the system and it takes too long for another qb to come up to speed to backup
white is the development guy who will likely need at least 1 year.
besides if dak is injured, season is over so tank to get the better picks.
but this is what happens every year...key player goes down.. tank and season is over.
 
Top