Convince me Payton is that much better than McCarthy

[WillieBeamen]

 

[foofighters]

I think Machota just did...

 

[ScipioCowboy]

He’s fitter.

 

[HungryLion]

I mean you most definitely have a point.

I still would prefer fresh blood with Rhule or Meyer.

But it’s a sound argument. I didn’t realize their numbers were that close.

 

[bewp7]

i can’t personally, but one thing i will say maybe in defense of payton is that drew brees is overrated and a playoff choker that no one ever talks about.

 

[LucaBrasi]

You can’t. Payton’s SB is over a decade ago, he’s had a generational qb, although Brees worries more about stats than wins.

maybe the Saints can get another rule change next year to help them out

 

[morasp]

The Saints season this year is pretty similar to a lot of ours with Garrett. Make the playoffs and one and done. You are what your are.

 

[superonyx]

Who said we want either?

that’s like asking me to convince you that Roseann Barr is that such hotter than Sarah Huckabee Sanders.

or that the “clap” is better than chlamydia.

no thanks

 

[WillieBeamen]

i can’t personally, but one thing i will say maybe in defense of payton is that drew brees is overrated and a playoff choker that no one ever talks about.

So is Rodgers though. Maybe even moreso than Brees

 

[clff15701]

Saints just got bounced again like every year. McCarthy is a very good coach and we would be lucky to have him.

 

[mattjames2010]

i can’t personally, but one thing i will say maybe in defense of payton is that drew brees is overrated and a playoff choker that no one ever talks about.

....Rodgers is about as much of a choker. Brees has, at the very least, beat winning teams while trailing. Rodgers record there is terrible.

McCarthy is getting way too much crap on this board and most of it is baseless. If you want Dak to take the next step, you bring in McCarthy.

 

[kskboys]

i can’t personally, but one thing i will say maybe in defense of payton is that drew brees is overrated and a playoff choker that no one ever talks about.

Yup.

Me and a couple buds talk about this. Brees is good, yes, but also overrated.

 

[DOUBLE WING]

Payton was on the verge of being run out of town after three straight 7-9 seasons before Loomis drafted Thomas and Kamara in back-to-back years. And now that he has them, he can't get out of the wild card round?

 

[Ranching]

McCarthy? We could do much worse and probably not much better.

 

[Tabascocat]

You can’t like one and dislike the other for our next HC. You either like both or want no part of them. They both have the same results.

 

[WillieBeamen]

Payton was on the verge of being run out of town after three straight 7-9 seasons before Loomis drafted Thomas and Kamara in back-to-back years. And now that he has them, he can't get out of the wild card round?

Yep. And his clock management and play calling down the stretch of games is terrible. Granted they made the field goal, but how do you end the 4th with a timeout in your backpocket? Very Garrett-esque

 

[Ranching]

Yep. And his clock management and play calling down the stretch of games is terrible. Granted they made the field goal, but how do you end the 4th with a timeout in your backpocket? Very Garrett-esque

Soooo, Payton sucks?

 

[aria]

He’s not. Payton is careless and over rated. If he were the coach of the Cowboys and made half the reckless calls he does as the coach of the Saints he would be torched by the fans and media (rightfully so). Anyone see him get bailed out by the false start flag while calling an unnecessary fake punt on his own 35 today?

 

[Zekeats]

He's conditioning us for this. He's not a far cry from Mickey.

 

[Mobinvans]

Either one is better than Garrett the loser