Could Belichick win a Super Bowl with the Cowboys Roster?

[xwalker]

How much success could Belichick achieve with the current 53 man roster?
-Assume that Tyron, La'el and most players are relatively healthy.

1. Would they make the playoffs this year? Regular season Win/Loss record?
2. Would they make it to the NFC Championship game?
3. Would they make it to the Super Bowl?
4. Would they win the Super Bowl?

 

[Flamma]

We know what he can do with an elite QB. I don't know what he could achieve otherwise.

 

[ShortRound]

Yes, but he would have traded most of the signed players for picks I think.

 

[ABQCOWBOY]

Honestly, that guy might win with my Grandson's YAFL team......


Just saying..

 

[TheHerd]

We know what he can do with an elite QB. I don't know what he could achieve otherwise.

Brady narrative aside, their defense has been a big reason they've won a lot of their big games. Could be get this defense to be elite? I guarantee he'd be doing more to figure it out than our current coaches.

 

[Silverstar]

Yes

 

[csirl]

Yes

 

[Carson]

Absolutely

 

[Diehardblues]

He’d have probably a better chance than anyone else ?

Unfortunately Elite coaching isn’t a priority for Jerry

 

[Flamma]

Brady narrative aside, their defense has been a big reason they've won a lot of their big games. Could be get this defense to be elite? I guarantee he'd be doing more to figure it out than our current coaches.

I agree that the Cowboys would be better year in and year out. We don't see Rodgers and Brees going to every other super bowl for the past two decades. Just don't know we'd be winning super bowls.

 

[yimyammer]

probably not the exact roster as he'd tweak as he saw fit but a hard no if jeri comes along with the team, remove jeri from the picture and it would only be a matter of time imo

 

[MikeB80]

make the playoffs yes but I can't imagine he would go into a season with this defensive roster.

Give him a full offseason to redo the defense and the special teams and then yes the expectations would be high.

 

[thunderpimp91]

Yes and I dont think it's even debatable. Too much talent on this team to be .500. Bill would take the defense from average to top 10 pretty quick.

 

[MikeB80]

Yes and I dont think it's even debatable. Too much talent on this team to be .500. Bill would take the defense from average to top 10 pretty quick.

he would improve the results for sure but this roster is not that talented. Promoted and marketed yes, talented no.

How many media members and fans couldn't shut up about the defensive line and how good it is. I didn't get it then and I don't get it now. It's just okay. Its not bad or great. Its just okay. Same with the linebackers and secondary. They are just ok.

 

[zrinkill]

yes

 

[Captain43Crash]

Yes!!!! Of course he would tweak the roster after assessing the situation. He would probably try to get rid of the big contract guys not fully pulling their weight. Good by big mouth Lawrence. He would bring in smart players willing to study that have a passion for the game( the NE way). Belicheat can win without Brady. Did you see his defense with barely average talent dominate the 2nd ranked Rams O in the Super Bowl.

If you don’t think Belicheat can win without Brady you have NO idea the importance of coaching in Football!

 

[ryanbabs]

How much success could Belichick achieve with the current 53 man roster?
-Assume that Tyron, La'el and most players are relatively healthy.

1. Would they make the playoffs this year? Regular season Win/Loss record?
2. Would they make it to the NFC Championship game?
3. Would they make it to the Super Bowl?
4. Would they win the Super Bowl?

Belichick could probably win with the Dolphins roster.

 

[thunderpimp91]

he would improve the results for sure but this roster is not that talented. Promoted and marketed yes, talented no.

How many media members and fans couldn't shut up about the defensive line and how good it is. I didn't get it then and I don't get it now. It's just okay. Its not bad or great. Its just okay. Same with the linebackers and secondary. They are just ok.

This defense needs help at S and DT, but has pro bowl caliber players at all 3 levels. If a defensive coordinator needs all pros at every position you need a new coordinator.

I have more issue with scheme/technique than I do the on field talent.

 

[JayFord]

Yes

 

[maryquality]

Yes. This question is way too easy!! Give us a more challenging one.