Cowboys defensive rankings during Super Bowl years

unionjack8

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,555
Reaction score
27,296
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
1971 they were 7th
1977 they were 8th
1992 they were 5th
1993 they were 2nd
1995 they were 3rd

Hopefully this will shut the Dak haters up but it won't. Can't wait to see the excuses coming. :popcorn:
As an aside I'd be interested to see how many top 10 Ds we have had in non superbowl years and see our records in those years...
 

charron

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,824
Reaction score
15,255
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
1971 they were 7th
1977 they were 8th
1992 they were 5th
1993 they were 2nd
1995 they were 3rd

Hopefully this will shut the Dak haters up but it won't. Can't wait to see the excuses coming. :popcorn:


So with multiple HOF's on offense the times they won SB were when they also had top 10 defenses. As good as our offense is now, those guys were better and still needed defensive help. You are correct you do not have to have a #1 defense just really really good, top 10 minimum to make a SB run.
 

TwoDeep3

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,509
Reaction score
17,341
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Nope, I blamed it on Romo for being a choker. But somehow Dak gets the excuses Romor rarely got.

I suppose you were not here when Romo threw the pick at the end of the Denver game in Texas Stadium against Manning. The final score was something like dal 48 - den - 51. The pick in question was in the shadow of the Dallas goal line. Manning could not get in and score a TD. So the field goal won the game.

It was a defenseless game on both sides. Or it was two superb QB's cutting up the opponents defense. But coming here after the game, almost to a man Romo was being defended for throwing into double coverage in huis usual Favre-like mindset of ignoring risk reward.

And no matter what opponent. Commanders, that late pass where he couldn't see the linebacker that sealed the season. Pittsburgh, where he threw to Witten who was triple teamed instead of an open receiver. Jets, he elected to throw to Witten in that game with the best cornerback ibn the game in front of Witten and a safety behind. Romo threw it directly to the cornerback.

Game after game when the money was on the line, Romo has a propensity to risk, and in some cases lose big.

Yet this site consistently blamed the defense. No gaff by Romo was ever his fault.

I see games where Dak makes mistakes. Two games last year in the waning moments he threw picks. But comparing Romo, the pick machine for most of his career to Dak is folly. And frankly, those two picks were essentially Hail Mary's of a fashion since the game was about to end. Hold the ball and he is indecisive. Throw it and the possibility of a pick outweighs any positive outcome.

One last point. it is a team, game and QB's do not win it all by themselves. I liked Romo. But I got used to him trying to make the hero play. The Dez Greenbay was not a catch. The odds were in the favor of Dallas to slowly drive it down and win the game. Romo made the decision to throw deep. In that case, with four minutes left, that game was list by the QB.
 

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
60,238
Reaction score
49,018
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Definitely helps to have a top 10 or higher D

Dallas did have the 7th ranked defense as recently as 2018, and 6th in scoring
 

acr731

Jerry learned to GM from Pee Wee Herman
Messages
10,665
Reaction score
29,500
Dallas defensive rankings by year:

https://www.pro-football-reference.com/

2016 - #5
2017 - #13
2018 - #6
2019 - #11
2020 - #28

So Dak had a top 5 and a top 10 defense in two seasons, and a top 15 defense twice. The only year he had a god-awful defense was in 2020.

SOMEONE PLEASE TELL ME WHY DAK KEEPS GETTING THE POOR DEFENSE EXCUSE WHEN HIS DEFENSE WAS BAD ONLY 1 SEASON..........
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
1971 they were 7th
1977 they were 8th
1992 they were 5th
1993 they were 2nd
1995 they were 3rd

Hopefully this will shut the Dak haters up but it won't. Can't wait to see the excuses coming. :popcorn:

I recall one year in the 90's when they were the #1 defense in the NFL. Maybe it was 1993 and they fell to second later in the year.
 

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
60,238
Reaction score
49,018
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
I suppose you were not here when Romo threw the pick at the end of the Denver game in Texas Stadium against Manning. The final score was something like dal 48 - den - 51. The pick in question was in the shadow of the Dallas goal line. Manning could not get in and score a TD. So the field goal won the game.

It was a defenseless game on both sides. Or it was two superb QB's cutting up the opponents defense. But coming here after the game, almost to a man Romo was being defended for throwing into double coverage in huis usual Favre-like mindset of ignoring risk reward.

And no matter what opponent. Commanders, that late pass where he couldn't see the linebacker that sealed the season. Pittsburgh, where he threw to Witten who was triple teamed instead of an open receiver. Jets, he elected to throw to Witten in that game with the best cornerback ibn the game in front of Witten and a safety behind. Romo threw it directly to the cornerback.

Game after game when the money was on the line, Romo has a propensity to risk, and in some cases lose big.

Yet this site consistently blamed the defense. No gaff by Romo was ever his fault.

I see games where Dak makes mistakes. Two games last year in the waning moments he threw picks. But comparing Romo, the pick machine for most of his career to Dak is folly. And frankly, those two picks were essentially Hail Mary's of a fashion since the game was about to end. Hold the ball and he is indecisive. Throw it and the possibility of a pick outweighs any positive outcome.

One last point. it is a team, game and QB's do not win it all by themselves. I liked Romo. But I got used to him trying to make the hero play. The Dez Greenbay was not a catch. The odds were in the favor of Dallas to slowly drive it down and win the game. Romo made the decision to throw deep. In that case, with four minutes left, that game was list by the QB.
False narrative on Romo

One, if not the, best 4th quarter QB ratings in league history…and especially in tight games.

so really…..not just wrong, but the opposite, on average

the painful late game mishaps just stuck with us exponentially more
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
And yet the QB you are crapping on and comparing to Dak played in the last 2 super bowls. You did catch the part about playing in the past 2 super bowls, right? He's also played in 3 straight AFC championship games. Come on man.

Maybe you have been too drunk to know how ridiculous it is to compare a super bowl champion to someone with 1 playoff win in 5 seasons.



Dak gets built in excuses for his failures but no one else does?

LOL..............DUH, maybe because they had great defenses?

I guess you just werent smart enough to even understand the obvious point of the post about defense?
 

acr731

Jerry learned to GM from Pee Wee Herman
Messages
10,665
Reaction score
29,500
LOL..............DUH, maybe because they had great defenses?

I guess you just werent smart enough to even understand the obvious point of the post about defense?

Read post #46. Dak has had good defenses and couldn't get the job done. One year he even had a top 5 defense. Stop giving him the poor defense excuse when the only terrible year was 2020.
 

Flamma

Well-Known Member
Messages
24,541
Reaction score
21,036
One of the things that is often lost in discussion of those 90s SB teams was just how talented those defenses were. They were fast, athletic and talented as hell.

Yeah, a big jump from the '91 season. But the Cowboys offense played better in '92 as well. But just because you have a top 3 defense doesn't mean you'll be a contender, or even make the playoffs.

Something that stuck out as odd to me was the 8th ranking of the '77 Cowboys. I couldn't imagine 7 teams having a better D than that Cowboys team. It turns out they were the #1 D, and the Falcons were #2, really close in yards allowed. They went 7-7. Coaching and offense play a role too.
 

Diehardblues

Well-Known Member
Messages
58,628
Reaction score
39,165
Dallas defensive rankings by year:

https://www.pro-football-reference.com/

2016 - #5
2017 - #13
2018 - #6
2019 - #11
2020 - #28

So Dak had a top 5 and a top 10 defense in two seasons, and a top 15 defense twice. The only year he had a god-awful defense was in 2020.

SOMEONE PLEASE TELL ME WHY DAK KEEPS GETTING THE POOR DEFENSE EXCUSE WHEN HIS DEFENSE WAS BAD ONLY 1 SEASON..........
Weren’t your stats for 2016 and 2018 scoring defense?
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
Read post #46. Dak has had good defenses and couldn't get the job done. One year he even had a top 5 defense. Stop giving him the poor defense excuse when the only terrible year was 2020.

LOL........sure buddy. All these great defenses we have had and you were the ONLY one that knew it?

:lmao::lmao::lmao::lmao2::lmao2::lmao2::lmao::lmao::lmao::laugh::laugh::laugh:
 
Last edited:
Top