TRADED Cowboys Trade For Panthers WR Jonathan Mingo

Majic

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,813
Reaction score
2,238
Dreadful trade. No other team would pay that much
 

Aerolithe_Lion

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,661
Reaction score
12,746
I’m not saying it’s a good trade. What I’m saying is their intent was the same as yours your can argue how good of a trade Dotson was but at the end of the day they wanted to improve their unit and traded for him. They were high on Mingo and traded for him. No one is trading a 23 year old DE or DT or a S on a rookie deal to the Cowboys. The move makes sense the compensation is a reach just like trading a 3rd for Dotson.
We got Dotson and a 5 for a 3. They effectively cost the same amount, especially when you factor in where your 4th will land. We got the 16th overall pick who had 11 tds in 2 years. You got the worst receiver on the worst team. Jahan is an every down player; Mingo may be regularly inactive in December once you see how bad his route running is. These trades are not comparable. You’re only trying to because it’s an eagle and a cowboy.
 

Majic

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,813
Reaction score
2,238
Belichick ain't coming here. You would be stock piling picks if he were
 

Chasing6

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,463
Reaction score
6,416
lol i hope cowboys never win another game as long as jerry is gm

if it was a 7th i would not care but a 4th so stupid
Trance and now Mingo. Jerry does not like the 4th round for some reason.
 

TequilaCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,932
Reaction score
8,428
Wow, wonder why a dumpster fire like Carolina already gives up on a guy with two more years under his rookie contract remaining. Getting rid of crap for a possible high 4th and 7th round pick in return is pretty good. Jerry got fleeced again. Should have been selling actually.
 

phildadon86

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,477
Reaction score
32,237
Here’s a random question……

Would you rather used 2nd rounder in 2023 for Mingo or our 4th in 2025?
Would have rather used the 2nd in 2023 on a player that wasnt 24 and at a position of need.

Instead we got Luke Schoonmaker.

Stop making excuses. This team doesnt know what it is doing.
 

Cowboys93

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,004
Reaction score
4,134
Awful trade. We gave up amari cooper for a 5th. And we trade a 4th for a 2nd rd bust with no qb to throw him the ball???? Am I high right now?
Lol I’m glad I have yall to laugh through the pain or the reality would set in that we’re doomed forever
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
83,487
Reaction score
76,336
We got Dotson and a 5 for a 3. They effectively cost the same amount, especially when you factor in where your 4th will land. We got the 16th overall pick who had 11 tds in 2 years. You got the worst receiver on the worst team. Jahan is an every down player; Mingo may be regularly inactive in December once you see how bad his route running is. These trades are not comparable. You’re only trying to because it’s an eagle and a cowboy.
You just aren’t getting it for some strange reason. I wouldn’t have done the deal and I wouldn’t have done the deal for Dotson. You are comparing the deals. I’m not comparing them. They both were bad deals. You asked why they did it. I’m telling you why and you are arguing with me how bad it is. I’m telling you they did it to upgrade their receiving group. Jahan was a bust who the Commanders were gonna cut. Mingo is a best who Panthers were probably gonna cut at some point. Cowboys were on Mingo a year ago. They are high on him now. Which part is hard to understand? If you want to take the time to laugh at the Cowboys for a dumb trade go ahead. I never said it was smart I was just answering your question.
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
83,487
Reaction score
76,336
Would have rather used the 2nd in 2023 on a player that wasnt 24 and at a position of need.

Instead we got Luke Schoonmaker.

Stop making excuses. This team doesnt know what it is doing.
What excuse did I make lol? My question had nothing to do with Schoon if you aren’t capable of answering it then don’t.
 

Aerolithe_Lion

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,661
Reaction score
12,746
You just aren’t getting it for some strange reason. I wouldn’t have done the deal and I wouldn’t have done the deal for Dotson. You are comparing the deals. I’m not comparing them. They both were bad deals. You asked why they did it. I’m telling you why and you are arguing with me how bad it is. I’m telling you they did it to upgrade their receiving group. Jahan was a bust who the Commanders were gonna cut. Mingo is a best who Panthers were probably gonna cut at some point. Cowboys were on Mingo a year ago. They are high on him now. Which part is hard to understand? If you want to take the time to laugh at the Cowboys for a dumb trade go ahead. I never said it was smart I was just answering your question.
Nobody is cutting Jahan Dotson. We paid a 3 because we outbid other teams. Do you believe Jerry was in a bidding war for Jonathan Mingo?
 
Top