Cowherd’s Top 10 QBs heading into 2023

[DenCWBY]

Got #1 and #2 correct. Hurts should be #3, Hurts made some awesome 3rd down SB throws that showed he belongs. Rodgers #4. The rest can be shuffled but with Stafford #9 and Goff #10. You could make a case for Jones, Dak and/or Cousins at #11, #12 and #13 but Dak had too many errors this year despite missing 4 games as well.

 

[Jimbo123]

replace hurts with Watson and I agree

Hurts should move to #3

 

[MarionBarberThe4th]

Depends what the list is about. Is it a list of who is better right now? Or is it what QB you would pick to be your guy going forward from here?

I always do my list on who I’d pick for the year. Not based on past stats

 

[Zman5]

Just came to see if he lost credibility by having Dak top-10

He can't lose something he never had.

 

[zeke21]

Very hard to do a 'top 10' for any position.

What is clear.. is that most of the league has now woken up to the fact that Dak is not Top 10. Despite his 'numbers' again looking good.. I think more and more people are actually paying attention to what he does on the field.

How we can take a cap hit of 50M for a mid table QB is beyond me.. a lot of us thought that contract would sink us and thus it has come to pass. Going to be very hard to watch the next few seasons I think.. as we waste Parsons and Lamb careers just like we have wasted so many before them. What a sick joke.. Dak literally lays an egg yet again in the playoffs and the Jones clowns still think he is 'the guy'. They then watch a SB with two talented QBs.. and see a 27 year old win his 2nd SB and still think Dak is 'the guy'. Just clueless.

 

[shabazz]

Herbert has the most passing yards and TD passes in his first 3 seasons in NFL history.

He's not the problem with the Chargers.

Yup, he’s a baller in the making

Cant see putting Lawrence in the 3rd spot considering he only played well the 2nd half of the season

and finally, we are seeing Rayne Dakota out of a lot of peoples top 10 list…..they’ve seen enough

 

[ChronicCowboy]

Hurts should move to #3

He had a great year but he needs to do it again to be considered a top QB. His stats weren’t impressive until this season.

 

[Cowpolk]

I printed the list for bathroom usage

 

[CowboyRoy]

I always do my list on who I’d pick for the year. Not based on past stats

Go back to my post I edited it and put in my list for you.

 

[CowboyRoy]

I always do my list on who I’d pick for the year. Not based on past stats

Mahomes, Burrows, Allen, Rogers, Hebert, Stafford, Hurts, Prescott, Jackson, Lawrence, Watson?

Elite ends at Rogers for me. Hebert through Lawrence are all in the same category to me its just a matter of who you put around them. I do like Hebert, but his leadership and mental aspect needs to work on. He will be elite as he develops.

Doing this list just goes to show how few QB's are actually any good in the NFL. ONce you get passed Jackson its hit or miss. I like Watson, but he looked terrible. I think he will be better this year. Jackson I think the league has caught onto him and he is getting older. Lawrence is high here, but I have him there on potential as well. I think he will be moving up this coming season closer to the top 5.

 

[shabazz]

I printed the list for bathroom sausage

Huh?

 

[Calvin2Tony2Emmitt2Julius]

Colon Cowaste is a moron. It's a popularity contest , Not theres anything wrong with that. But to act as if HIS list means something?

Tell's me all I need to know

 

[CowboyRoy]

Hurts should move to #3

You cant honestly think Hurts should be at 3?

 

[shabazz]

Colon Cowaste is a moron. It's a popularity contest , Not theres anything wrong with that. But to act as if HIS list means something?

Tell's me all I need to know

I agree that all these lists are subjective but #4 has been losing the media lately……the turnovers are doing him in.

Lawrence at #3 is based more on his potential and draft position than on his complete season.

 

[Adreme]

Complete joke of an order and it has nothing to do with Dak not being there.

Lawrence ahead of Allen or even in the top 10 is funny. Hebert ahead of Allen for doing what exactly? Losing and choking?

Hurts at 6? Who is that at 10? LOL Goff? Yah right.

I will say this Josh Allen lead the league in turnovers and wins are not a QB stat (and Allen has not exactly been on many winning teams either). That is the reason I can agree with Herbert over Allen.

Lawrence is way too high. I have no doubt about that. Goff had 3 straight ugly years but now that he has 1 good year he is a top 10 QB? I just cannot buy it. I think the issue is with no more Brady and everyone realizing Wilson does not belong on a top 20 list everyone is now just putting in their favorite players to go with the 7 that everyone knows is in the top 10.

 

[InPhiltraitor]

Stafford at 7 seems too high, if you go off, "what have you done for me lately".

Think he'll rebound next year, but that's not guaranteed. Lawrence is definitely overhyped at #3.

Cowherd’s been riding the Stafford train since he’s been in LA. Keeps talking about how he excelled in the SB run, yet he overlooks Stafford’s punt pass that should have been caught by Jaquiski Tartt which more than likely would have sent SF to the SB.

He’s got Herbert ahead of Allen based on trajectory. Don’t know what the numbers say, but the eye test tells you Buffalo’s offense wasn’t clicking as well without Daboll.

Agree on Lawrence. Much better season but is he getting too much hype based on San Diego’s 2nd half collapse.

 

[shabazz]

You cant honestly think Hurts should be at 3?

I would take him over Lawrence…….at this point. He’s an impressive dude and was clearly an MVP candidate this season

i wouldn’t have said that last season. I had Dak over him in ranking NFC East qbs before the season started

 

[Vanilla2]

If turnovers were his reason for leaving dak off the list then josh allen is rated too high

 

[MikeT22]

Herbert over Allen lol.

I really don't get the love affair with this guy....lol

Dak not in the list...comical. Is Stafford even going to play? Rodgers gets the benefit of the doubt...even Goff....where is Jackson even playing?

Guy is a clown...

Nothing says Dak is a top 10 QB. Almost every category he is in the 12-15 range, well except for interceptions where he is #1

 

[CowboyRoy]

I will say this Josh Allen lead the league in turnovers and wins are not a QB stat (and Allen has not exactly been on many winning teams either). That is the reason I can agree with Herbert over Allen.

Lawrence is way too high. I have no doubt about that. Goff had 3 straight ugly years but now that he has 1 good year he is a top 10 QB? I just cannot buy it. I think the issue is with no more Brady and everyone realizing Wilson does not belong on a top 20 list everyone is now just putting in their favorite players to go with the 7 that everyone knows is in the top 10.

I know Hebert is everyones darling, but his teams haven done nothing. I like him, but he gets too much credit. Allen is simply incredible No way is Hebert above Allen. Allen can beat you with both his legs and his arm and his team was suspect this season.

Allen and burrows are interchangeable. I just really like Burrows. If they every get an Oline over there Mahomes is the only guy with a shot.