Tovya
New Member
- Messages
- 777
- Reaction score
- 0
I'm okay with the list (though his order of the players stinks)...
except for:
A) Carson Palmer, very good, but not the 3rd best QB in the league by any leap of the imagination
B) Dwight Freeney... he is NOT a top 50 player.. at least not in a couple of years
C) Andre Johnson... he is not better than a lot of receivers who didn't make the list... I really don't like it when players get ranked because of how good they'd be IF they were healthy the whole season. Heck, that's the case with tons of player.
D) Richard Seymour.. another ridiculous IF they were healthy.
E) Drew Brees is NOT the 5th best QB in the league... that's absurd.
F) Wes Welker is NOT a top 50 player by any stretch of the imagination... you mean to tell me that a GM would take him over Brandon Marshall, Houshmandzadeh, or Torry Holt? I don't think so... I like Welker, but his effectiveness is largely based upon the attention shown on the other side to Moss... take one of those other 3 guys and put them on the otherside of Moss and they are 1500-yd receivers.
The worst snub on the list is Witten in my opinion... and maybe even T.J. Houshmandzadeh. Heck, there were tons of bad snubs really.
except for:
A) Carson Palmer, very good, but not the 3rd best QB in the league by any leap of the imagination
B) Dwight Freeney... he is NOT a top 50 player.. at least not in a couple of years
C) Andre Johnson... he is not better than a lot of receivers who didn't make the list... I really don't like it when players get ranked because of how good they'd be IF they were healthy the whole season. Heck, that's the case with tons of player.
D) Richard Seymour.. another ridiculous IF they were healthy.
E) Drew Brees is NOT the 5th best QB in the league... that's absurd.
F) Wes Welker is NOT a top 50 player by any stretch of the imagination... you mean to tell me that a GM would take him over Brandon Marshall, Houshmandzadeh, or Torry Holt? I don't think so... I like Welker, but his effectiveness is largely based upon the attention shown on the other side to Moss... take one of those other 3 guys and put them on the otherside of Moss and they are 1500-yd receivers.
The worst snub on the list is Witten in my opinion... and maybe even T.J. Houshmandzadeh. Heck, there were tons of bad snubs really.
