Paniolo22 said:I'm not comfortable with a kicker that can barely kick in warm ups. It's rare that you kick differently than you practice.
How man reports have you heard about how great he Bill kicked in practice? Yeah, me too. Anyway, You are more likely to make kicks when you are making them all week. It builds up your confidence and most times you do better. When you are missing your warm up kicks, that can't be good for your confidence.Faerluna said:Yea, Billy is a perfect example of showing how you kick in practice is how you kick in game.
Next.
Paniolo22 said:How man reports have you heard about how great he Bill kicked in practice? Yeah, me too. Anyway, You are more likely to make kicks when you are making them all week. It builds up your confidence and most times you do better. When you are missing your warm up kicks, that can't be good for your confidence.
If you are going to pick and choose your statistics, I could just as well compare Cundiffs average of 67.8 against Carolina to Suishams 61.4 average against Detroit.Kilyin said:Suisham's kickoffs weren't that bad. I don't know who started that rumor, but it's not true. I posted this awhile back but I'll post it again, since it's relevant. A Small sampling of kickoffs between Cundiff and Suisham:
Cundiff kickoffs vs. Denver:
3-B.Cundiff kicks 63 yards from DAL 30 to DEN 7. 45-R.Alexander to DEN 28 for 21 yards (31-R.Williams). Return left side of the field.
3-B.Cundiff kicks 63 yards from DAL 30 to DEN 7. 45-R.Alexander to DEN 16 for 9 yards (29-K.Davis). Return middle.
3-B.Cundiff kicks 60 yards from DAL 30 to DEN 10. 45-R.Alexander to DEN 30 for 20 yards (20-W.Pile). Return middle.
3-B.Cundiff kicks 69 yards from DAL 30 to DEN 1. 45-R.Alexander to DEN 24 for 23 yards (18-T.Copper; 29-K.Davis). Return middle.
Cundiff Average: 63.75
Suisham's kickoffs vs. Philly:
4-S.Suisham kicks 57 yards from DAL 30 to PHI 13. 29-R.Hood to PHI 28 for 15 yards (29-K.Davis, 55-R.Fowler).
4-S.Suisham kicks 68 yards from DAL 30 to PHI 2. 29-R.Hood to PHI 23 for 21 yards (29-K.Davis).
4-S.Suisham kicks 60 yards from DAL 30 to PHI 10. 29-R.Hood to PHI 35 for 25 yards (55-R.Fowler).
4-S.Suisham kicks 68 yards from DAL 30 to PHI 2. 29-R.Hood to PHI 30 for 28 yards (33-N.Jones).
Suisham Average: 63.25
Cundiff averaged a half yard more, there really isn't that much difference.
Nobody mentioned practice per say, they talked about pre game warm ups. Also, you think Cundiffs misses were creeping in his head while he MISSED AGAIN and AGAIN? Bottom line, we are leaving our season possibly up to a rookie kicker who had the shakes during his time here. Yeah he IS 2/2, but they are both within 25 yards. I'd feel much more comfortable with a veteren kicker at this point or even France or Novak who have moregame experienceFaerluna said:If Billy was missing them in practice, I'm sure the tooting horns would have let us all know in a similar fashion as Suisham's were noted.
1. RW should playFaerluna said:If Billy was missing them in practice, I'm sure the tooting horns would have let us all know in a similar fashion as Suisham's were noted.
Paniolo22 said:Nobody mentioned practice per say, they talked about pre game warm ups. Also, you think Cundiffs misses were creeping in his head while he MISSED AGAIN and AGAIN? Bottom line, we are leaving our season possibly up to a rookie kicker who had the shakes during his time here. Yeah he IS 2/2, but they are both within 25 yards. I'd feel much more comfortable with a veteren kicker at this point or even France or Novak who have moregame experience
Kilyin said:Cunyips.
Anguillidae said:If you are going to pick and choose your statistics, Icould just as well compare Cundiffs average of 67.8 against Carolina to Suishams 61.4 average against Detroit.
jcollins28 said:Why I would have cut him right there on the sideline.
Typo, I ment to write against Arizona.Kilyin said:The only problem with that is Cundiff was the kicker when we played Detroit. The only games Suisham kicked off for us in were Arizona and @Philadelphia.
Suisham's average was 61.4 against Arizona so I'll assume that's what you meant. Cundiff's average kicking off against Detroit was 60.4. So like I said to begin with... not a big difference.