Current top 10 qbs in order

[Clove]

I think people really want to know where Romo ranks. That is the reason for this thread, IMO. So I'll just put him at 16.

 

[mitchell2254]

Payton Manning
Arron Rogers
Drew Breeze
Tom Brady
Phillip Streams
Andy Luck
Matt Scaffold
Eli Mannning
Tony Romo
Ben Rothlisburger

 

[Beast_from_East]

How is that funny?

Peyton is 8-1 with a 121.0 passer rating.
Brees is 7-2 with a 108.9 pr.
Rodgers is 5-3 (or is it 5-2?) with a 108.0 pr.
Brady is 7-2 with a 82.7 pr.
Rivers is 4-5 (in the best division in football) with a 105.9 pr.
Luck is 7-3 (and beat the Broncos, 49ers, Seahawks) with a 87.0 pr.
Wilson is 9-1 with a 101.8 pr.
Newton is 6-3 with a 88.3 pr.
Stafford is 6-3 with a 94.1 pr.

Romo has a QB rating of 98 for the season..........................that would put him 6th on this top 10 list....................correct?

 

[dstovall5]

I think people really want to know where Romo ranks. That is the reason for this thread, IMO. So I'll just put him at 16.

Lol, I assume you're doing that just because we're 5-5, mediocre? If you're going by that metric alone, then yes 16 sounds ... mediocre.

 

[JoeyBoy718]

Romo has a QB rating of 98 for the season..........................that would put him 6th on this top 10 list....................correct?

It wasn't based solely on QB rating. I also included team records, strength of division, and crucial wins.

If you look at it, it's not ranked in order of QB rating. Not even close.

 

[dropdeadfred5]

It wasn't based solely on QB rating. I also included team records, strength of division, and crucial wins.

If you look at it, it's not ranked in order of QB rating. Not even close.

and factoring in your Romo hate. So in reality he should be around #6

 

[The Quest for Six]

Romo isn't in the top ten among quarterback, around 12 on the list...

 

[ufcrules1]

I think people really want to know where Romo ranks. That is the reason for this thread, IMO. So I'll just put him at 16.

Yeah, I put him middle of the pack somewhere too. Maybe 15 or so. He is a .500 qb.

 

[morasp]

Which QB would you want going into the fourth quarter down by 10 points?

 

[03EBZ06]

Only idiots or trolls would rank E. Manning over Romo, smh

 

[dstovall5]

NFL QBs with most starts on their respective team -

1.) New England Patriots (Tom Brady)
2.) New York Jets (Geno Smith)
3.) Miami Dolphins (Ryan Tanehill)
4.) Buffalo Bills (EJ Manuel)
5.) Cincinnati Bengals (Andy Dalton)
6.) Cleveland Browns (Brandon Weeden)
7.) Baltimore Ravens (Joe Flacco)
8.) Pittsburgh Steelers (Ben Roethlisberger)
9.) Indianapolis Colts (Andrew Luck)
10.) Tennessee Titans (Jake Locker)
11.) Houston Texans (Matt Schaub)
12.) Jacksonville Jaguars (Chad Henne)
13.) Kansas City Chiefs (Alex Smith)
14.) Denver Broncos (Peyton Manning)
15.) San Diego Chargers (Phillip Rivers)
16.) Oakland Raiders (Terryle Pryor
17.) Dallas Cowboys (Tony Romo)
18.) Philadelphia Eagles (Nick Foles)
19.) New York Giants (Eli Manning)
20.) Washington Commanders (RG3)
21.) Detroit Lions (Mathew Stafford)
22.) Chicago Bears (Jay Cutler)
23.) Green Bay Packers (Aaron Rodgers)
24.) Minnesota Vikings (Christian Ponder)
25.) New Orleans Saints (Drew Brees)
26.) Carolina Panthers (Cam Newton)
27.) Atlanta Falcons (Matt Ryan)
28.) Tampa Bay Buccaneers (Mike Glennon)
29.) Seattle Seahawks (Russel Wilson)
30.) San Francisco 49ers (Colin Kaepernick)
31.) Arizona Cardinals (Carson Palmer)
32.) St. Louis Rams (Sam Bradford)

How anyone can put 14-16 QBs on this list ahead of Romo is laughable. They either don't watch much football outside of Dallas, or they're just trolling.

 

[Jenky]

If we're talking who I would want on this team RIGHT NOW...

1. Aaron Rodgers (healthy)
2. Peyton Manning
3. Drew Brees
4. Tom Brady
5. Andrew Luck
6. Cam Newton
7. Matt Stafford
8. Russell Wilson
9. Alex Smith
10. Eli Manning (He'll throw jump balls to Dez all day without hesitation)

Throw all the stats out the window, Romo is not playing good football right now. Way too conservative, and way too inaccurate.

A post that contradicts itself. Gee. You are describing Alex Smith verbatim, yet somehow how he's in the top 10. Oh wait, must be the 9-0.

 

[dropdeadfred5]

Yeah, I put him middle of the pack somewhere too. Maybe 15 or so. He is a .500 qb.

"...the HATE is strong in this one..."

 

[Toruk_Makto]

If you call Cam Newton a game manager you don't understand football and probably watch nothing but the Cowboys.

 

[rbr651]

I find it interesting that nobody listed Bradford who was having an amazing season prior to his exit

 

[ufcrules1]

"...the TRUTH is strong in this one..."

Fixed it for you.

 

[beevomav]

Bored on the bye week. Sorry if I offend the Romo haters.

1- Peyton Manning
2- Andrew Rodgers
3- Drew Brees
4- Tom Brady
5- Andrew Luck
6- Tony Romo
7- Russel Wilson
8- Mathew Stafford
9- Phillip Rivers
10- Big Ben

Not a bad list and I might move Cam Newton in and Big Ben out, but Romo has been and remains a top 10 QB.

 

[Pessimist_cowboy]

Tier 1:
Manning
Brees
Rodgers
Brady

Tier 2:
Rivers
Luck
Stafford
Rothlisberger

Tier 3:
Ryan
Romo
Eli
Flacco

Tier 4:
Cutler
Russel wilson
Rg3
Kaepernick

LOL @ ROTHLISBERGER . That guy has been absolutely horrid.

 

[Pessimist_cowboy]

1.P Manning
2.Drew Brees
3.Arron Rodgers
4. Phillip Rivers ( we are talking THIS year)
5. Matthew Stanford
6. Andrew Luck
7.Tom Brady
8. Tony Romo
9. Russel Wilson
10.Alex Smith

 

[JoeyBoy718]

Which QB would you want going into the fourth quarter down by 10 points?

That depends. Is the division title on the line?