Dak in perspective

ChldsPlay said:
Better - Rodgers, Brady, Brees, Stafford, Ryan, Big Ben, Carr, Luck, Rivers, Romo, Wilson, Cousins.

Similar - Dalton, Flacco, Palmer (maybe, I haven't really watched him much this year to see what his issue is), Newton, Mariota, Smith, Manning (50/50 - not sure he can help himself).
Click to expand...

Dak is 5-0 versus those "better" QB's and has played well enough to keep another one on our bench.
 
MichaelWinicki said:
Flacco would do as well in the Dallas system as Prescott?

Your entire post lost credibility just on that note.
Click to expand...

With the talent on the team this year? I think so. Pretty close to it anyway. Maybe we shoyld ask PFF since they are the epitome of credibility.
 
ThreeandOut said:
Dak is 5-0 versus those "better" QB's and has played well enough to keep another one on our bench.
Click to expand...

I guess the ENTIRE point of everything I said was over your head. You just used the weakest argument possible.
 
The title of this thread is ironic considering it seems the only perspective that is allowed is that Dak is amazeballs and this is the best rookie performance there is, was, and ever will be.

Nobody wants to consider other perspectives.
 
Clove said:
Name me one team that doesn't have help?
New England 4 Pro Bowlers
Dallas 5 Pro Bowlers
Green Bay 3 Pro Bowlers, but there should have been another with Jordy Nelson
Raiders 7 Pro Bowlers
Steelers 4 Pro Bowlers
You win with talent unless you're a cheating franchise like New England.
So Dak having talent on his team does not diminish his superior accomplishments this year.
Click to expand...
Yep those 90's teams had talent galore. It doesn't diminish how great Aikman, Emmitt and Michael were though. They were winners.
 
MichaelWinicki said:
Hey...

Hope you enjoy the rest of Dak Prescott's tenure in Dallas.

Hopefully it's at least 10 years.

Then maybe you'll be "AdultsPlay".
Click to expand...

I hope he ends up as the best QB in history.

Hopefully by that point some people will be willing to be objective and mature in their analysis.
 
Sepia said:
I wonder why so many vets appear so impressed with what he's done as a rookie if he hasn't contributed all that much to the best record in the NFL. What do they know?
Click to expand...

What he has done is very impressive for a rookie.
 
Sarge said:
How anyone can be anything but completely thrilled with what Dak has done thus far is mind boggling. .02
Click to expand...

I challenge you to find a quote from someone saying they aren't happy with how well he has done.
 
ChldsPlay said:
I challenge you to find a quote from someone saying they aren't happy with how well he has done.
Click to expand...

You won't find that but there's plenty of Romo FANS out there that wish he was the one having the success. They feel he's paid his dues and deserves a championship. They'll tell you that Dak has his entire career ahead of him and that time is running out for Romo and he deserves this more than Dak. It's become a Dak vs Romo for many on this board. Some don't like Dak's game of safe, high percentage throws despite how successful it's been, they want more big plays down the field. They feel he's a dink and dunk game manager and that we would be even better with Romo at QB. If the Cowboys win the SB, they'll believe they could have won it with Romo.

There's some that believe Romo never had as good a team as this and believe Dak is just going along for the ride. It's not that some don't like Dak but they feel sorry for Romo and would rather see the Cowboys win the SB with him even if it means losing, than to win a championship with Dak. A SB win with Dak is going to be bittersweet for many. It sounds crazy but there's some on this board that are bigger FANS of Romo than they are of the team. There's a few Romo FANS that I haven't seen post since Romo went down in preseason.
 
KJJ said:
You won't find that but there's plenty of Romo FANS out there that wish he was the one having the success. They feel he's paid his dues and deserves a championship. They'll tell you that Dak has his entire career ahead of him and that time is running out for Romo and he deserves this more than Dak. It's become a Dak vs Romo for many on this board. Some don't like Dak's game of safe, high percentage throws despite how successful it's been, they want more big plays down the field. They feel he's a dink and dunk game manager and that we would be even better with Romo at QB. If the Cowboys win the SB, they'll believe they could have won it with Romo.

There's some that believe Romo never had as good a team as this and believe Dak is just going along for the ride. It's not that some don't like Dak but they feel sorry for Romo and would rather see the Cowboys win the SB with him even if it means losing, than to win a championship with Dak. A SB win with Dak is going to be bittersweet for many. It sounds crazy but there's some on this board that are bigger FANS of Romo than they are of the team. There's a few Romo FANS that I haven't seen post since Romo went down in preseason.
Click to expand...
OH MY GOODNESS.

PREACH
 
KJJ said:
You won't find that but there's plenty of Romo FANS out there that wish he was the one having the success. They feel he's paid his dues and deserves a championship. They'll tell you that Dak has his entire career ahead of him and that time is running out for Romo and he deserves this more than Dak. It's become a Dak vs Romo for many on this board. Some don't like Dak's game of safe, high percentage throws despite how successful it's been, they want more big plays down the field. They feel he's a dink and dunk game manager and that we would be even better with Romo at QB. If the Cowboys win the SB, they'll believe they could have won it with Romo.

There's some that believe Romo never had as good a team as this and believe Dak is just going along for the ride. It's not that some don't like Dak but they feel sorry for Romo and would rather see the Cowboys win the SB with him even if it means losing, than to win a championship with Dak. A SB win with Dak is going to be bittersweet for many. It sounds crazy but there's some on this board that are bigger FANS of Romo than they are of the team. There's a few Romo FANS that I haven't seen post since Romo went down in preseason.
Click to expand...

Wrong. That's just what you tell yourselves they believe.
 
from 4+ WR formations
Ryan 60 of 83 648 yd 6 td 1 int 113.9
Prescott 115 of 168 1363 yd 8 td 2 int 103.8
Brady 85 of 130 991 yd 5 td 0 int 101.2
Rodgers 148 of 233 1448 yd 15 td 3 int 97.0
Brees 93 of 132 990 yd 8 td 5 int 96.5

late & close
4th qtr or OT, one-score margin
Brady 30 of 40 445 yd 3 td 0 int 135.9
Brees 77 of 107 843 yd 8 td 3 int 108.1
Ryan 34 of 59 543 5 td 2 int 102.5
Prescott 59 of 92 668 yd 4 td 0 int 100.3
Rodgers 24 of 43 328 yd 3 td 1 int 93.9

Red zone
Brady 40 of 59 284 yd 18 td 1 int 111.2
Rodgers 68 of 109 418 yd 29 td 0 int 109.6
Brees 72 of 101 399 yd 26 td 2 int 109.3
Ryan 56 of 86 333 yd 19 td 1 int 107.2
Prescott 33 of 55 282 yd 16 td 1 int 105.5

15+ yards in air
Brady 37 of 73 1177 yd 9 td 1 int 130.3
Prescott 37 of 74 967 yd 9 td 1 int 129.8
Ryan 53 of 93 1587 yd 11 td 3 int 127.6
Rodgers 45 of 115 1361 yd 8 td 3 int 96.3
Brees 49 of 95 1555 yd 7 td 9 int 82.2

vs. top 10 pass defenses
Brady 87 of 132 1193 yd 7 td 1 int 109.1
Rodgers 109 of 172 1274 yd 12 td 3 int 101.7
Brees 137 of 192 1405 yd 10 td 5 int 98.5
Ryan 86 of 138 1172 yd 6 td 3 int 94.8
Prescott 72 of 124 758 yd 3 td 2 int 77.3

This is an outstanding regular season by a QB who checks all the boxes except the one labeled "experience against elite defenses."

Enjoy the ride and stay tuned.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Members online

Total: 22,006 (members: 29, guests: 21,977)
Robots: 910

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,041
Messages
14,508,697
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top