Speed of thought has always been immeasurably more important then speed of arm for QB (or any position really). Of course it helps if you have both. There’s a reason QB evaluation is such a dumpster fire and it’s because the fossils that still run the league in many ways continue to focus on physical measurables rather then evaluate a players ability to quickly process information and turn that into action. In soccer we always refer to speed of thought as a critical skill and it is important to be able to receive the ball in a small space with defenders near you and decide quickly what to do with it. QB’s specifically require this same skill and it should be the first thing that is evaluated yet still they are judged on what types of throws they can make, even though that skill is far more common then the ability to quickly process information. Find a QB who can make quick decisions first and foremost, then look at what he can do physically and how that might limit him in the NFL.
First and foremost...I am an extremely casual fan with no base knowledge in anything QB related...
But...
What is your take on USC's QB's ability to take on pressure with his eyes focused downfield for a play?
I, personally find it as a remarkable skill for a QB. This does not mean he will pan out in NFL.
I am basing this on some network/youtube evaluations of his talent. I have watched two games of his...and the evaluation of him being able to take on pressure, scramble, while keeping his eyes down the field for a play seem very legit.
The argument can be made that he has failed this year to produce against good teams(USC defense is suspect supposedly)...but I listened to a Ticket broadcast that turned me on to the kid and then watched two games back to back of him....his ability to keep his eyes down field and look for a play while pressured seem to be ideal in todays NFL. Granted...he might be considered gunslinger that turns the ball over based on college film....and the NFL is harder....but after hearing about his skills and then watching two games of his....his ability to keep his eyes down field seem so important in todays game for a QB.
Any thoughts on Caleb Williams?
My main point is...he seems to have a rare skill that is in huge demand in NFL...keeping your eyes downfield for a play instead of getting locked on a WR. Sure...it can lead to mistakes and turnovers...but he seems to be able to keep his eyes downfield during pressure and wanting to make a play. Or...you can throw the ball into the ground like Brady. Which guy do you want? A play maker or a statistician?
Again..my main point is that the kid seems to have a rare trait that NFL would love.
