Dak is the 30th best starting QB in the NFL

[Hawkeye0202]

Per ESPN Stats....

DAK
Passing yards - 23rd
Pct - 28th
TDs tied at 24th
Rating - 27th
Total QBR - 26th

Thanks.......kinda odd starting a thread with numbers we have no idea where they came from

 

[Reid1boys]

Yes he was. If ******* Trent Dilfer was a championship caliber QB, then Romo was. This argument people use against Romo is absolutely laughably blind.

Using the logic of those saying Romo wasn’t championship caliber, I guess Marino, fouts, Jim Kelly are also not championship Caliber.

 

[bsbellomy]

1. Brady
2. Rodgers
3. Brees
4. Ben
5. Wilson
6. Mahomes
7. Goff
8. Wentz
9. Cousins
10. Luck
11. Rivers
12. Cam
13. Stafford
14. Ryan
15. Dalton
16. Mayfield
17. Carr
18. Trubisky
19. Watson
20. Carr
21. Bortles
22. Marriotta
23. Darnold
24. Rosen
25. Eli
26. Flacco
27. tannehill
28. Allen
29. The broncos guy
30. Dak
31. Beatherd
32. Winston

This is truly embarrassing

I would move Bortles down to the bottom, Tannehill right above him, Allen right above him, and Winston right above Dak. Darnold is better right now but I'm not sure Rosen is yet. I think 27-28 is about right. Don't think he's a guy you can win with no matter what you surround him with.

 

[Reid1boys]

I would move Bortles down to the bottom, Tannehill right above him, Allen right above him, and Winston right above Dak. Darnold is better right now but I'm not sure Rosen is yet. I think 27-28 is about right. Don't think he's a guy you can win with no matter what you surround him with.

.
Last year, in 13 games, Winston threw for 3500 yards and 19td passes, and you think dak I start better than he is? I don’t love Jameis, but if we were down 14 pts in the 4th quarter, I did take him over dak all day long.

 

[bsbellomy]

.
Last year, in 13 games, Winston threw for 3500 yards and 19td passes, and you think dak I start better than he is? I don’t love Jameis, but if we were down 14 pts in the 4th quarter, I did take him over dak all day long.

Well I didn't say Dak was better than Jameis, so there is that.

 

[Clove]

Championship caliber wasn’t a good description leaving it open for criticism such as this but I certainly don’t recall Romo leading a bottom tier offense nor near the bottom of the league Qb rankings at anytime including less than great surrounding support.

Romo most seasons was a top 10-15 QB not 25th -30th.

Which matters to you? To suck or kinda suck?

 

[Clove]

Yes he was. If ******* Trent Dilfer was a championship caliber QB, then Romo was. This argument people use against Romo is absolutely laughably blind.

Win multiple playoffs, then I might say he's championship caliber. Especially when you have one of the best receivers to ever play in (TO) and a HOF tight end...

Dak sucks, but he's never had those type of weapons in their prime.

 

[Diehardblues]

Which matters to you? To suck or kinda suck?

I wouldn’t describe a mostly top 10 offense and QB as kinda sucking.

 

[glimmerman]

30th is a little harsh. I truly believe that if he focuses and has a little luck that he could be a 20th ranked qb.

Or if WR held on to the ball. Some of this is on Dak for sure. But some is on WR and coaching. Why did Linehan keep going between tackle when they were run blitzing all night. How about a toss or sweep.

 

[Clove]

I wouldn’t describe a mostly top 10 offense and QB as kinda sucking.

If you've been in the league 14 years, played for near 10 years and only have one play off victory, with one of the top 5 best receivers to ever play, a HOF TE, then you suck. He was a star in the regular season, and a JAG in the play offs. You can't be considered great when you falter in the play offs.

And this is where pedigree comes in. Big time, big school QBs. There's a reason they play there, and if they have success, that's even better. You need a BIG SCHOOL QB, with a nice size and a big arm, with the smarts of a natural QB. And most of all, you need a coach he will not dumb him down.

 

[Diehardblues]

If you've been in the league 14 years, played for near 10 years and only have one play off victory, with one of the top 5 best receivers to ever play, a HOF TE, then you suck. He was a star in the regular season, and a JAG in the play offs. You can't be considered great when you falter in the play offs.

And this is where pedigree comes in. Big time, big school QBs. There's a reason they play there, and if they have success, that's even better. You need a BIG SCHOOL QB, with a nice size and a big arm, with the smarts of a natural QB. And most of all, you need a coach he will not dumb him down.

That’s totally ridiculous using your measurement as the bar for all. Lol

 

[Gangsta Spanksta]

Pessimist Cowboy says he is 30th and only can get worse.

 

[Hennessy_King]

As of right now dak is a middle of the road QB (15-20) that takes care of the football. And on a run first team that is what you need.

 

[Jake]

23rd, 27th, 30th, does it really matter? You aren't going anywhere with that.

 

[Diehardblues]

Using the logic of those saying Romo wasn’t championship caliber, I guess Marino, fouts, Jim Kelly are also not championship Caliber.

I certainly wouldn’t place Romo at those HOF comparisons.

Those kind of comparisons do open up these unrealistic bashing.

Not only did Romo not put up those kind of numbers but he didn’t have their consistent playoff success despite not winning a championship.

Championship caliber isn’t a definte description but HOF talent is. Romo wasn’t HOF talent nor put up those type of career numbers.

 

[Established1971]

This board is bizarre to me. Romo has the 4th best passer rating all time -- all time -- and so many people hated him and thought he sucked. Now we have a QB who struggles to pass over 200 yards a games for over a season and droves of people are defending him like it's other guys fault.

Dak even has issues handing the ball off, last night another play where his exchange with Zeke looked so awkward. Sure it is only on an occassional play here and there but I cant recall any qb Ive ever seen where so often Ive thought "does he know how to hand the ball off"

 

[Diehardblues]

As of right now dak is a middle of the road QB (15-20) that takes care of the football. And on a run first team that is what you need.

But he’s not even that at this time.

I wasn’t attached to Romo and I’m certainly not to Dak. But I do recognize the difference in their production and the offenses effectiveness with each other under center respectively.

 

[HonoluluCowboy]

As of right now dak is a middle of the road QB (15-20) that takes care of the football. And on a run first team that is what you need.

Name the QB's below him

 

[rags747]

Winston is better than him and Beathard is a backup.



We have the worst starting QB in the league

Im not sure if I should give u a LIKE or just Cry!

 

[Clove]

That’s totally ridiculous using your measurement as the bar for all. Lol

For most. You can win with the ladder, but you need a competent front office that knows how to evaluate those types of QBs, and even better, have that type of coach to pull it out of him. We don't.