Dak or Kirk

[cowboybish]

If you had a choice, would you take Kirk Cousins right now instead of Dak ?

 

[DallasDW00ds0n]

Kirk. Give me something. I need a pass completed over 10 yards.

 

[Aftershock]

Kirk without a doubt

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Kirk has always been better than Dak.

The fact that he would get lumped in with Dak so much is just dumb.

 

[Nav22]

Everyone here will say "KIRK FOR SURE" even though the Vikings are 1-4 and Dak's been more efficient than Kirk.


Vs 30 NFL teams, give me Dak.

Vs the 49ers, give me Kirk. Just because I really don't want to see Dak vs that defense ever again.

 

[Nav22]

Kirk has always been better than Dak.

The fact that he would get lumped in with Dak so much is just dumb.

"Always" except for in the regular season and in the playoffs, when Dak has objectively been the better and more productive player.

Kirk lost to the Giants at home in the WC round. Has Dak had success vs the Giants???

 

[starfan1]

If last game is a reflection of what we’ll get from here on out give me Kirk

I think some is Dak is McCarthy play calling so if he would hamper Kirk as well then it really don’t matter

 

[DallasDW00ds0n]

Everyone here will say "KIRK FOR SURE" even though the Vikings are 1-4 and Dak's been more efficient than Kirk.


Vs 30 NFL teams, give me Dak.

Vs the 49ers, give me Kirk. Just because I really don't want to see Dak vs that defense ever again.

What about vs the Cards?

 

[MoistMayonnaise]

That's like asking if I want to be kicked in the left testicle or right testicle.

 

[Nav22]

What about vs the Cards?

Need more than a 1-game sample size to pick a lesser QB over Dak.

 

[Nav22]

Kirk. Give me something. I need a pass completed over 10 yards.

"Give me something"

Kirk will give you a home loss vs the Giants in the playoffs and a 1-4 start the next season.

 

[Swagger]

Kirk has always been better than Dak.

The fact that he would get lumped in with Dak so much is just dumb.

I think a lot of it goes back to when he was at Washington. They had to beat the Giants from memory to reach the play offs. It was a dead rubber for the latter yet Cousins completely bottled it. I think people associate that with Prescott as he has completely lost the plot in any meaningful game as well unless the team has carried him. Plus their stats are very similar.

With that said, I would roll with Cousins. He's a slightly better QB than Prescott in my view.

 

[EST_1986]

Same guy but give me Kirk

 

[CATCH17]

Same player.

Pass on both. Neither is a big game player.


Try Lance and go for upside. If it fails draft.

Mediocrity is not the goal.

 

[DallasDW00ds0n]

"Give me something"

Kirk will give you a home loss vs the Giants in the playoffs and a 1-4 start the next season.

Lol Imagine thinking Dak was lighting it up against the Giants this year?

My man Dak has been drowning in a glass of water when we get to the redzone

 

[thunderpimp91]

This is where we get into the Dak overreactions after the 49er game. This question is a pickem type of question, these guys are basically the same end results just with different paths to get there.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

"Always" except for in the regular season and in the playoffs, when Dak has objectively been the better and more productive player.

Kirk lost to the Giants at home in the WC round. Has Dak had success vs the Giants???

Because beating the Giants is the barometer....

I liked humbled Nav much better.

 

[Nav22]

Lol Imagine thinking Dak was lighting it up against the Giants this year?

My man Dak has been drowning in a glass of water when we get to the redzone

LMAAOOOOO

I've seen a lot of silly things on this board.

Questioning Dak's pure ownage of the Giants might be the silliest.

Psst, Kirk lost to the Giants LAST year, not this year.

How'd Dak do vs the Giants LAST year since the 40-0 game didn't move you???

 

[Nav22]

Because beating the Giants is the barometer....

I liked humbled Nav much better.

I'm always humble.


LOL if beating the Giants isn't impressive, why does LOSING to the Giants at home in the playoffs impress you?

 

[DallasDW00ds0n]

LMAAOOOOO

I've seen a lot of silly things on this board.

Questioning Dak's pure ownage of the Giants might be the silliest.

Psst, Kirk lost to the Giants LAST year, not this year.

How'd Dak do vs the Giants LAST year since the 40-0 game didn't move you???

True that was probably Daks best game. What did he throw barely over 50% and slightly for over 100 yards? He didn’t have any TDs but you’re right, at least he didn’t give the game away either.

Bravo!