Dak or McCarthy. pick one!

[noshame]

That's a silly question
Both should be out of the NFL.
Dak's skills since the ankle injury are no longer adequate.
Strong defensive coaches have allowed McCarthy to survive, coaches not of his choosing, his only choice was Nolan.

 

[America's Cowboy]

Don't lump me in with the rest of the Dak haters. I realize that the Cowboys could do a lot worse at QB. But no way I would have resigned a declining player for $60 million a year.

Declining? How so?

 

[Big_D]

McCarthy all day. They had the golden opportunity to move on from Prescott and should’ve taken it. Now they screwed themselves no matter who the coach is.

 

[WillieBeamen]

Looking at these responses, it feels good knowinf a majority of this site has finally seen the light.

Dak and Garrett have been two of the worst things to happen to this franchise

 

[Cmac]

Looking at these responses, it feels good knowinf a majority of this site has finally seen the light.

Dak and Garrett have been two of the worst things to happen to this franchise

I'd say Romo......he gained a fan club, didn't win anything, lost win & get in games repeatedly, tossed interceptions at the wrong time, went to Cabo for a leadership conference, been lobbied for ROH & HOF, and is beloved by many on this board with his 2 playoff wins, more than Troy Aikman, part of the SB drought Dak gets criticized for, been a BFF to Garrett that YOU mention, and any reality about his career that reflects the mentioned, will warrant a flash flood on this board........C'mon WillieBeamen.....c'mon!

 

[Big_D]

I'd say Romo......he gained a fan club, didn't win anything, lost win & get in games repeatedly, tossed interceptions at the wrong time, went to Cabo for a leadership conference, been lobbied for ROH & HOF, and is beloved by many on this board with his 2 playoff wins, more than Troy Aikman, part of the SB drought Dak gets criticized for, been a BFF to Garrett that YOU mention, and any reality about his career that reflects the mentioned, will warrant a flash flood on this board........C'mon WillieBeamen.....c'mon!

Your take on Romo is comical. They’re highly considered one of the best drafting teams through the Dak era. That wasn’t the case as Jerry fumbled his way through the most of Romo’s career. The GM was at the height of his stupidity after Parcells left.

 

[Cmac]

Your take on Romo is comical. They’re highly considered one of the best drafting teams through the Dak era. That wasn’t the case as Jerry fumbled his way through the most of Romo’s career. The GM was at the height of his stupidity after Parcells left.

You're making my point.....now that's comical. Here comes the excuses as expected, as if Romo played with trash.

 

[acr731]

Just look around the board there’s fans that want Cooper Rush as the starter instead of Dak, all because we won two straight games. However, they were trashing him the previous two games and wanted to bench him for Lance. Keep living in the moment. Lol

No, it's because they're getting similar results with a QB who is making 58 mil less a season.

 

[acr731]

Declining? How so?

Were you not paying attention to the first 8 games this season? Let me guess, he stunk because he was playing injured, is that going to be the excuse?

 

[acr731]

I'd say Romo......he gained a fan club, didn't win anything, lost win & get in games repeatedly, tossed interceptions at the wrong time, went to Cabo for a leadership conference, been lobbied for ROH & HOF, and is beloved by many on this board with his 2 playoff wins, more than Troy Aikman, part of the SB drought Dak gets criticized for, been a BFF to Garrett that YOU mention, and any reality about his career that reflects the mentioned, will warrant a flash flood on this board........C'mon WillieBeamen.....c'mon!

Nah, Romo sucked. Same as Dak. They're 2 peas in a pod.

 

[Cmac]

Nah, Romo sucked. Same as Dak. They're 2 peas in a pod.

....very similar.....but there is a distinct difference in critique on this board despite yielding the same results.

 

[Gonzomandela01]

McCarthy is the 4th best coach we ever had, Dak is no. 1 fraud Qb we ever had, so its an easy one.

 

[Risen Star]

That's a silly question
Both should be out of the NFL.
Dak's skills since the ankle injury are no longer adequate.
Strong defensive coaches have allowed McCarthy to survive, coaches not of his choosing, his only choice was Nolan.

McCarthy only picks the bad coaches.

 

[Big_D]

You're making my point.....now that's comical. Here comes the excuses as expected, as if Romo played with trash.

It wasn’t well built team. You can’t go draft after draft missing constantly. He was already older than Dak when Jerry started building the Oline and then you want to talk about how good he had it. lol

 

[BoysForLife]

I'd take MM over Dak.

Our record this year with Dak and with Rush under center is basically identical

All of the stans are constantly telling us how awful Rush is, so my question is what does that tell us about Dak?

Tells me McCarthy is a near .500 coach working with scraps at the most important position

I'm keeping Mike and letting him draft the guy who he wants to build around.

Odds of success are much higher there than trying to build around a proven loser whose body is decaying at warp speed

 

[HanD]

Mm if I HAD to choose.

 

[TheCritic]

Declining? How so?

For me the first sign was Dak walking around in a boot over the summer. This season was the first time I seen him try to be an almost exclusively in the pocket passer. Without the threat of him running the ball, he's not nearly as effective IMO

 

[kskboys]

McCarthy all day. They had the golden opportunity to move on from Prescott and should’ve taken it. Now they screwed themselves no matter who the coach is.

Yeah, MM, and it's not close. MM is a middle of the pack legit HC. No, he's far from great, but he's the best we've had since Tuna.

 

[kskboys]

Our record this year with Dak and with Rush under center is basically identical

All of the stans are constantly telling us how awful Rush is, so my question is what does that tell us about Dak?

Tells me McCarthy is a near .500 coach working with scraps at the most important position

I'm keeping Mike and letting him draft the guy who he wants to build around.

Odds of success are much higher there than trying to build around a proven loser whose body is decaying at warp speed

And there's the problem. As long as we keep drafting the Kelvins and Trystens and Tacos and Mazis and average TE's in the 2nd, we are quite simply not going anywhere. Need an NFL head at the top of the heap, not Jerry drinking and groping and falling for stupid crapp.

The league is still laughing at us for falling for the Escobar hype.

 

[jazzcat22]

Leave both take the cannolis.