Dak or Romo Mega Thread (Week #3) **merged**

CowboyChris

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,511
Reaction score
4,961
Watch a defense like Minnesota's and then watch ours...............light years difference............no, we are not going to the SuperBowl with this defense.
Don't forget by the time the playoffs roll around, teams with good defenses may not be all that great due to injury factors, in my opinion we will have a shot because of this offense, i'm not expecting a SB run, but i wouldnt rule it out all together either.

right now teams are looking dominant cause its early in the season, Chicago had how many injuries going into tonight....look how bad they looked. and its only week 3
 

Redball Express

All Aboard!!!
Messages
16,253
Reaction score
12,758
I know he is a great person, so he's happy for team success. But Im sure part of him knows that this is the beginning of the end. Dak is the future, and it may be as early as next year. Not saying I'd choose Dak over Romo this year, but Dak pressures a defense in ways that Romo can't: with his arm and legs. And it's a mobile QB/young man's game. If I were Romo, part of me would be depressed that I may lose my job and not see the end of my contract for the Cowboys. I feel for the guy because he deserves better.
Romo knows how this works.

He moved Bledsoe aside and never apologized.

Same here..but I think DAK is doing everything he can.

It's not his decision.

I would think Romo has to be happy.

By the time he returns..DAK will have kept playoff hopes alive.

For Romo.

What's not to like about that..?
 

Super_Kazuya

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,074
Reaction score
9,113
If it were that easy why didn't the QBs last year do it?
That was always the million dollar question... a well-constructed team should not fall apart like they did last year. That is why the coaching took such criticism.

Saying it's easy is not being entirely fair to Dak either, as he still has to do his job... but after just reviewing the game again a few minutes ago, it's hard to say that very many of his throws are throws you couldn't expect Romo to easily make, or really any halfway decent QB... especially against and injury-riddled, horrible defense like the Bears. And to be fair, Tony himself has had plenty of easy nights where he benefited when the offensive line, running backs and receivers are clicking. It's not a knock on Dak to say it was easy.
 

GimmeTheBall!

Junior College Transfer
Messages
37,682
Reaction score
18,035
Dak is on the bench when he comes back. And probably the back up for as long as Romo is on the team. Best case scenario: We win the super bowl this year and Romo calls it quits.
Methinks someone is living in the terrible past.
 

GimmeTheBall!

Junior College Transfer
Messages
37,682
Reaction score
18,035
I know he is a great person, so he's happy for team success. But Im sure part of him knows that this is the beginning of the end. Dak is the future, and it may be as early as next year. Not saying I'd choose Dak over Romo this year, but Dak pressures a defense in ways that Romo can't: with his arm and legs. And it's a mobile QB/young man's game. If I were Romo, part of me would be depressed that I may lose my job and not see the end of my contract for the Cowboys. I feel for the guy because he deserves better.
Aikman, Staubach, Meredith and others outlived their usefulness to the team.
And don't give me the personal stats thing.
It is a passage of time.
At some point Romo has to believe that it is time to put pass the baton.
He is not special, just one of our greats.
 

Redball Express

All Aboard!!!
Messages
16,253
Reaction score
12,758
That was always the million dollar question... a well-constructed team should not fall apart like they did last year. That is why the coaching took such criticism.

Saying it's easy is not being entirely fair to Dak either, as he still has to do his job... but after just reviewing the game again a few minutes ago, it's hard to say that very many of his throws are throws you couldn't expect Romo to easily make, or really any halfway decent QB... especially against and injury-riddled, horrible defense like the Bears. And to be fair, Tony himself has had plenty of easy nights where he benefited when the offensive line, running backs and receivers are clicking. It's not a knock on Dak to say it was easy.
When you see us last year and watch the Pats now winning with 3rd and 4th QBs..

I am struck with how bad we are at the coaching level verses our opposition.

Same thing when I watch the Iggles.

They traded their starting QB and have overtures a bunch of their roster since the HC change and they now look transformed.

That's coaching.

We don't have nothing like that despite 5 years of Garrett.

Just think that though.

Ouch.
 

toto1939

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,057
Reaction score
1,080
Dak is on the bench when he comes back. And probably the back up for as long as Romo is on the team. Best case scenario: We win the super bowl this year and Romo calls it quits.

Best case scenario: Romo lasts about 5 plays before being injured again (and before he can put up multiple losses due to rust being away from the game or trying to prove something) and we win the Super Bowl this year with Zak.
 

rpntex

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,470
Reaction score
1,042
After we beat San Fran and go 3-1 just to drop two games in a row against solid teams, this place is going to be screaming from Romo.

I'm not putting this on Dak, Dak is someone with a bright future, but he is not a QB who is going to win you shootouts. This D isn't getting better this year, it is what it is even when Lawrence gets back. Romo can win you shootouts.

Dallas is 3-0 with Romo. He wins the Giants game. Dak's clock awareness cost him in that final drive. Too many passes in the middle of the field with no TOs remaining.
 

Boyzmamacita

CowBabe Up!!!
Messages
29,047
Reaction score
64,100
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Dallas is 3-0 with Romo. He wins the Giants game. Dak's clock awareness cost him in that final drive. Too many passes in the middle of the field with no TOs remaining.
So true. I mentioned it right after the game. Dak hasn't mastered the sideline throw that only the receiver can catch, although he did it in the preseason.
 

Hoofbite

Well-Known Member
Messages
40,865
Reaction score
11,566
To be honest, if Dak keeps playing as well as he has I think Dallas needs to turn the keys over to him for good. He is the future and it would be foolish to put Dak on the bench just so we can see if Romo can take a hit. If this was the first time Romo had missed time due to injury then there's no question he steps back in as the starter. Fact of the matter is, he's playing on borrowed time.

For all the ill advised comparison to successful coaches that have been thrown out regarding Jason, this decision may be one where such a comparison would be entirely appropriate. When Tom Brady stepped in for an injured Bledsoe and established himself as the future QB of the Patriots, Belichik made the call to stick with Brady. Does Garrett have it in him to make the same decision?
 

Redball Express

All Aboard!!!
Messages
16,253
Reaction score
12,758
That was always the million dollar question... a well-constructed team should not fall apart like they did last year. That is why the coaching took such criticism.

Saying it's easy is not being entirely fair to Dak either, as he still has to do his job... but after just reviewing the game again a few minutes ago, it's hard to say that very many of his throws are throws you couldn't expect Romo to easily make, or really any halfway decent QB... especially against and injury-riddled, horrible defense like the Bears. And to be fair, Tony himself has had plenty of easy nights where he benefited when the offensive line, running backs and receivers are clicking. It's not a knock on Dak to say it was easy.
None of our backups last year were anywhere ready to play like DAK is coming out of college.

All those guys..Weeden, Cassell, etc. we're practically career backups who were not playing for teams.

DAK has played 4 years in the college level carrying a major college program on his back.

He's just sharper..in better condition and mentally fresher than these other guys.

I have a feeling he's going to dwarf Romo when he comes back.

The team is going to struggle because the identity DAK is establishing is so different and diverse compared to Romo..we are all going to scream for DAK to return.

What I''m hoping is that Romo doesn't quickly lose whatever DAK gains in the W-L record before we switch back to DAK.

This staff is very stubborn.

They were stubborn about keeping Weeden and failed.

They were stubborn about Cassel and he failed.

Being stubborn with Romo could divide this team against the coaches and ownership.

I think they must stay with DAK until its clear he is failing and then make a change.

Not before.
 

Redball Express

All Aboard!!!
Messages
16,253
Reaction score
12,758
Saw the game tonight..

Very pleased to say the least..

This occurred to me..

What if DAK keeps winning and Romo is ready to come back.

I think instead of inserting Romo..it would better to keep DaK until he starts to struggle.

That way..you avoid the possibility of the team being split over who should be QB.

There is a real possibility players could be resentful if Romo comes back and he's not sharp and we drop 2-3 games DAK had won for us and then you have to rush DAK back in to try to save a season.

This team is changing right now.


If the ownership and coaches suddenly throw things in reverse with Romo it fails..

..it could be a disaster.

These coaches have been constantly wrong about QBs with this team.

Now what?

Opinions
 

Donhyphen

Active Member
Messages
396
Reaction score
148
Saw the game tonight..

Very pleased to say the least..

This occurred to me..

What if DAK keeps winning and Romo is ready to come back.

I think instead of inserting Romo..it would better to keep DaK until he starts to struggle.

That way..you avoid the possibility of the team being split over who should be QB.

There is a real possibility players could be resentful if Romo comes back and he's not sharp and we drop 2-3 games DAK had won for us and then you have to rush DAK back in to try to save a season.

This team is changing right now.


If the ownership and coaches suddenly throw things in reverse with Romo it fails..

..it could be a disaster.

These coaches have been constantly wrong about QBs with this team.

Now what?

Opinions
 

Jstopper

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,488
Reaction score
8,007
Saw the game tonight..

Very pleased to say the least..

This occurred to me..

What if DAK keeps winning and Romo is ready to come back.

I think instead of inserting Romo..it would better to keep DaK until he starts to struggle.

That way..you avoid the possibility of the team being split over who should be QB.

There is a real possibility players could be resentful if Romo comes back and he's not sharp and we drop 2-3 games DAK had won for us and then you have to rush DAK back in to try to save a season.

This team is changing right now.


If the ownership and coaches suddenly throw things in reverse with Romo it fails..

..it could be a disaster.

These coaches have been constantly wrong about QBs with this team.

Now what?

Opinions

Romo isn't dropping any games Dak wouldn't that's my thought. Jesus you people have forgotten how damn good Romo is.
 

Donhyphen

Active Member
Messages
396
Reaction score
148
Romo should take over when ready. Dak has proven to be the future. We're good.
 
Top