Dak versus Mahomes

Mahomes is better than Dak.

What this should tell people though. Is that Dak is clearly a top 10 QB and overall a very good QB. Wanting to cut him or get rid of him is silly due to how hard it is to find QB’s who are very good.
 
The problem with this comparison is Mahomes brought his team to a championship game, and was one poor penalty by a dlineman from going to the SB.

He single handidly kind of carried that KC team. Granted they may be more of an explosive team than us all around. Also the eye test tells me he's better.......but he also has Andy Reid.

Dak isn't capable yet of willing his team to victory when nothing is going well, missing both tackles and top wr (last week vs the Jets was an example), but thats ok to me. Very few quarterbacks can.

The thing with dak is he's developing still. He's getting better, his throws, his ability to command the offense, the one audible he had was great. And that pick into double coverage? Every qb does that, and i'm glad dak did cause he can continue to learn from it.
 
Playmaker3128 said:
The problem with this comparison is Mahomes brought his team to a championship game, and was one poor penalty by a dlineman from going to the SB.

He single handidly kind of carried that KC team. Granted they may be more of an explosive team than us all around. Also the eye test tells me he's better.......but he also has Andy Reid.

Dak isn't capable yet of willing his team to victory when nothing is going well, missing both tackles and top wr (last week vs the Jets was an example), but thats ok to me. Very few quarterbacks can.

The thing with dak is he's developing still. He's getting better, his throws, his ability to command the offense, the one audible he had was great. And that pick into double coverage? Every qb does that, and i'm glad dak did cause he can continue to learn from it.
Click to expand...

Mahomes did not carry the KC team.

Mahomes is amazing. He is awesome. But the KC team was a contending level team before him. The KC offense is loaded with talent and a great coach. Mahomes isn’t carrying them.

QB’s don’t carry bad teams to championship games.
 
Durability. Let’s see how Mahomes bounces back from injury.
 
Proof said:
lol because he suffered a freak injury last game? Stop
Click to expand...
Not so, Patty has been playing with an injury, at least 2 or 3 games. This last one was icing on his proverbial cake as they say. In the end, he is who he is, and Dak is who he is. I like our QB for this team at this time.
 
silvrNblue said:
Not so, Patty has been playing with an injury, at least 2 or 3 games. This last one was icing on his proverbial cake as they say. In the end, he is who he is, and Dak is who he is. I like our QB for this team at this time.
Click to expand...

Mahomes will be fine.

If the Chiefs offered you Mahomes for Dak straight up and you said "nah, we good", you should probably see a neurosurgeon.

That's not a knock on Dak. Its just a realization that Mahomes is arguably the most talented and best QB in football right now.
 
silvrNblue said:
Not so, Patty has been playing with an injury, at least 2 or 3 games. This last one was icing on his proverbial cake as they say. In the end, he is who he is, and Dak is who he is. I like our QB for this team at this time.
Click to expand...

uhh. “Playing with”. He’s not proven to be injury prone whatsoever. And yes they both are who they are and Mahomes is the best QB In the league hands down
 
Proof said:
uhh. “Playing with”. He’s not proven to be injury prone whatsoever. And yes they both are who they are and Mahomes is the best QB In the league hands down
Click to expand...
Uhh WAIT a damn minute proof, according to ALL the media gabber heads, Carson WENTZ is the best QB in the league... get it right ole boy.
 
DakPresgoat said:
Mahomes did not carry the KC team.

Mahomes is amazing. He is awesome. But the KC team was a contending level team before him. The KC offense is loaded with talent and a great coach. Mahomes isn’t carrying them.

QB’s don’t carry bad teams to championship games.
Click to expand...

Mahomes played out of his mind. Without his level of play last year KC doesn't make it to where they were. They had the 25th ranked defense as well. They also lost Hunt middle of the year.

I ask myself could dak or any other qb outside of Rodgers and Brady (maybe wilson as well) done that with that team and i'm not sure they could have.

Now again i'll admit they had weapons galore, and Andy Reid is a huge x factor as well.
 
Playmaker3128 said:
Mahomes played out of his mind. Without his level of play last year KC doesn't make it to where they were. They had the 25th ranked defense as well. They also lost Hunt middle of the year.

I ask myself could dak or any other qb outside of Rodgers and Brady (maybe wilson as well) done that with that team and i'm not sure they could have.

Now again i'll admit they had weapons galore, and Andy Reid is a huge x factor as well.
Click to expand...

Oh their defense sucks. It’s going to cost them
Again this year most likely.

But I’m just speaking to the larger point. Even the best QB’s (and Mahomes is one of the best). Need some help.
 
DakPresgoat said:
Oh their defense sucks. It’s going to cost them
Again this year most likely.

But I’m just speaking to the larger point. Even the best QB’s (and Mahomes is one of the best). Need some help.
Click to expand...

Definitely agreed, even the great Tom Brady needs alot of help. If they didn't build the oline they do around him every year he'd get killed back there. He's also had Gronk, Moss ect, and he has bellicheck.

Thats why i laugh when people wanted dak to "will his team" to victory last week. Without both starting tackles and without his top offensive weapon. Find me alot of qb's that can overcome it. Idc if that was the jets, that wasn't the same jets team last week.
 
PAPPYDOG said:
LOL.....Dak in perfect circumstances performs well and yesterdays game was a dream boat scenario for us . The problems start with Dak when the circumstances are well not 100% as seen in the last 3 losses. Comparing him to Mahomes is a Joke to say the least.
Dak needs to show us the money when Zeke and the offline is not at 100% and can carry the offense and team to victory.
Hence the reason he is still without a contract and hence the continuous debates with this QB.
The next 2 months will tell the tale if the word Franchise can be attached to Dak.
Click to expand...

You keep trying to push this BS narrative that Dak doesn't have a contract because he hasn't proved himself yet. Dak has been offered contracts, but has declined signing any of them because he is betting he can get more next year. The guy is making a staggering 2 million dollars this year. That's less than some backup QBs are making. I would say that he is pretty damn good for a 2 million dollar QB. Heck, I think the Cowboys signed him to an initial contract of 2.7 million with something like 375,000 signing bonus. He is still on that contract. So, for 3 million, the Cowboys have a QB who has gone to 2 Pro Bowls, won Offensive Rookie of the year, and led his team to 2 NFC East Titles. I think that's a pretty good return on their money.
 
Sydla said:
Mahomes will be fine.

If the Chiefs offered you Mahomes for Dak straight up and you said "nah, we good", you should probably see a neurosurgeon.

That's not a knock on Dak. Its just a realization that Mahomes is arguably the most talented and best QB in football right now.
Click to expand...
Riiight, and you just know from your crystal bally thingy that Patty could waltz right on in here and play lights out, with these players, and these coaches? ok.... you take him then, for me I'm all good with Dak Prescott, Mr 4th rounder. But hey, that's just me. And seriously, you should stop sleeping while posting, your grandeur dreams are getting in the way of common sense... Chiefs offer up Mahomes for Dak... ROFL, yeah in any body's dreams.
 
DakPresgoat said:
Mahomes is better than Dak.

What this should tell people though. Is that Dak is clearly a top 10 QB and overall a very good QB. Wanting to cut him or get rid of him is silly due to how hard it is to find QB’s who are very good.
Click to expand...

:hammer:
 
silvrNblue said:
Riiight, and you just know from your crystal bally thingy that Patty could waltz right on in here and play lights out, with these players, and these coaches? ok.... you take him then, for me I'm all good with Dak Prescott, Mr 4th rounder. But hey, that's just me. And seriously, you should stop sleeping while posting, your grandeur dreams are getting in the way of common sense... Chiefs offer up Mahomes for Dak... ROFL, yeah in any body's dreams.
Click to expand...

Dude, you are being ridiculous at this point.

This is exactly the type of posts that give Dak supporters bad names. Because it's so ridiculously Dak homeristic.

Mahomes is a better QB than Dak. Yes, he could step in here in Dallas and play better than Dak has. There's no shame in saying that. I don't get why some of you Dak guys can't admit Dak is a really good QB but there are probably some that are better than him.
 
Sydla said:
Dude, you are being ridiculous at this point.

This is exactly the type of posts that give Dak supporters bad names. Because it's so ridiculously Dak homeristic.

Mahomes is a better QB than Dak. Yes, he could step in here in Dallas and play better than Dak has. There's no shame in saying that. I don't get why some of you Dak guys can't admit Dak is a really good QB but there are probably some that are better than him.
Click to expand...
Naw, your right it wasn't Patty's fault they dropped their last 2 games, I mean with ALL that talent and all... good grief. Shove your homerism where it doesn't shine. If you can't see it by now, your a romojizzer and should move into jerry world.
 
DakPresgoat said:
Mahomes did not carry the KC team.

Mahomes is amazing. He is awesome. But the KC team was a contending level team before him. The KC offense is loaded with talent and a great coach. Mahomes isn’t carrying them.

QB’s don’t carry bad teams to championship games.
Click to expand...

After watching some of KCs games though, they are lucky they have Mahomes, because their defense sucks.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Staff online

Members online

... and 70 more.
Total: 9,994 (members: 170, guests: 9,824)
Robots: 947

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,015
Messages
14,506,769
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top