ok, lets make this simple. some people are engineers because they hae the mind, now a lot of people can go into engineer BECAUSE they think they can, they dont survive and thats ok. Sometimes. But yes, Trey has tools, will he see the HoF or anything like that? No, some can see that, others cant. Is it soley on the player, no. You can see lots of players who had potential but were on bad teams. The Wild cards are plentiful, BUT you can spot certain things because they show themselves. You also have coaches who can eck out a bit more from a player than what they have. Take Eli for example. Is he as good as his brother? Clearly not, but he was on a good defensive team and his coach got him some super wins. So he goes into the HoF. Can you say hes a good QB, yea, can you see him on a decent team taking taht team over the hump on his own? no. Trey may get some wins in the playoffs due to the team, but on his own? No, he doesnt show some of the qualities it takes.