Dallas FO 3 mistakes in 2015 which hurt Super Bowl chances

blindzebra

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,560
Reaction score
4,451
How did the fluke injury occur??
prudent move or stupid move? It is a matter of opinion.
No team except dallas has ever let a MVP, and rushing champ RB go the following year,but still so many say it was the right thing to do.

How players do on other teams is largely irrelevant to how they would have done with dallas.
We resigned guys this year that if we didnt they might have the same fate , go elsewhere and not do too good.

You do realize that we ran the ball better in 2015 but just had fewer carries because we did not get the 35 TD passes that gave us leads to add carries late, right?

Romo and Dez made Murray in 2014...take Romo and Dez away and we could have had Emmitt in his prime at RB and we'd have not done any better.
 

YosemiteSam

Unfriendly and Aloof!
Messages
45,858
Reaction score
22,189
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Romo going down is what killed our chances.

https://lh4.***BROKEN***/-JpS1O_DYj70/VwmO6oPYY9I/AAAAAAAE66Q/5jHhQnRjpnoV5SL-x22DJm-KNDVktqrwg/w647-h364-no/-4157426652.gif
 

SilverStarCowboy

The Actualist
Messages
10,337
Reaction score
1,998
You do realize that we ran the ball better in 2015 but just had fewer carries because we did not get the 35 TD passes that gave us leads to add carries late, right?

Romo and Dez made Murray in 2014...take Romo and Dez away and we could have had Emmitt in his prime at RB and we'd have not done any better.


Then what does Houston, the Chiefs, Vikes and Buffy have that Dallas doesn't. Coaching? Talent? Culture? ... maybe it's the Fans.
 

KJJ

You Have an Axe to Grind
Messages
62,173
Reaction score
39,426
2015's Super Bowl Chances:

romo-injury-eagles.jpg


Move on

That's the problem with this team it all revolves around Romo. He's been the starting QB for 10 years and the Cowboys haven't even sniffed a SB because we've never had a good enough team around him. The day he went down in Philly we all knew the Cowboys were done if he missed significant time. Even Jerry has commented in the past that he wishes the rest of the team played as well as Romo. When you go 1-11 with 3 backup QBs you don't have a good "team' and Romo's already proven he can only carry the Cowboys so far.
 
Last edited:

KJJ

You Have an Axe to Grind
Messages
62,173
Reaction score
39,426
Go back and look at some of the great teams the Cowboys had under Staubach and Aikman those teams could still win and look good doing even when they had to miss games. When you go 1-11 with three backup QBs two of which were veterans that won more than 35 games between them your issues are much deeper than who's playing QB. Those who think had Romo stayed healthy all season the Cowboys would have ended up in the SB are dreaming!
 

DandyDon52

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,780
Reaction score
16,657
Go back and look at some of the great teams the Cowboys had under Staubach and Aikman those teams could still win and look good doing even when they had to miss games. When you go 1-11 with three backup QBs two of which were veterans that won more than 35 games between them your issues are much deeper than who's playing QB. Those who think had Romo stayed healthy all season the Cowboys would have ended up in the SB are dreaming!

That is true, they should be able to go .500 at least with the bkups,
 

DandyDon52

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,780
Reaction score
16,657
You do realize that we ran the ball better in 2015 but just had fewer carries because we did not get the 35 TD passes that gave us leads to add carries late, right?

Romo and Dez made Murray in 2014...take Romo and Dez away and we could have had Emmitt in his prime at RB and we'd have not done any better.

your not seeing my point lol, guess you are "blind"
 

JoeKing

Diehard
Messages
36,638
Reaction score
31,938
Then what does Houston, the Chiefs, Vikes and Buffy have that Dallas doesn't. Coaching? Talent? Culture? ... maybe it's the Fans.

You say that like those other teams all won the Super Bowl last year. Let's get this straight, the Cowboys 2015 season was a massive fail but that doesn't mean we should look up to teams that didn't quite fail as much as something to strive for. If you really must know what Houston, the Chiefs, Vikes and Buffalo have that Dallas does not, is one Super Bowl trophy to share between them all. The Cowboys have a history of winning multiple Super Bowls. There is nothing those other teams have done that should cause you to forget this fact.
 

noshame

I'm not dead yet......
Messages
14,933
Reaction score
13,417
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
One thing kept us from success last year. Linehan andhis refusal to adapt his system/play calling to the back up QBs. You had a guy with a great arm who was capable of throwing deep outs and curls, but they aren't inhis dink and dunk horizontal offense he implemented for Tony.

It wasn't till he had his boy back there in the end he adjusted to his weak arm and added some mid range lobs which he excelled at during college.
None of the back ups were all star material, but we could have had better performance out of the first two, and ultimately a better season.
 

jazzcat22

Staff member
Messages
81,285
Reaction score
102,215
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Oh I don't know, been hashed and rehashed...or is that whined and whined some more over and over....and over...
Must we relive this over and over...it's time to get ready for the 2016 season.
Guess I had the choice of not clicking on the thread, but it's slow, so click on every thread.

It's Sunday, Mavs need a win to make the playoffs so they can get knocked out by the Spurs or Warriors in the 1st round.....:laugh:....
 

Mr Cowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,612
Reaction score
32,654
While I disageree with basically all three of your "mistakes" the loss of Romo and Dez had more to do with us not making the Super Bowl than anything.

Well said, I agree completely.

Now let's go draft another DE or CB with the 4th pick...........
 

willia451

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,288
Reaction score
3,528
I don't know about any of that.

But I will say this. Not having an effective and consistent running game to begin the season certainly did put Romo more at risk to injury.

Can't let that happen again.
 

thisiscowboyscountry

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,375
Reaction score
1,136
How did the fluke injury occur??
prudent move or stupid move? It is a matter of opinion.
No team except dallas has ever let a MVP, and rushing champ RB go the following year,but still so many say it was the right thing to do.

How players do on other teams is largely irrelevant to how they would have done with dallas.
We resigned guys this year that if we didnt they might have the same fate , go elsewhere and not do too good.

I can tell you the fluke injury had nothing to do with poor conditioning. If it was a hamstring or a groin injury I may agree but were talking broken bones. The salary cap forces teams to make tough decisions and based on Murrays injury history, number of carries, and longevity of rbs we didnt think he was worth the money. As you can see our running game was still good last year as Murray fell of a cliff. It could be a matter of scheme, but losing Murray didnt have the impact you suggest.

Lastly, though I do agree certain players fit better than others losing guys like Carter and Durant wasnt the downfall of 2015. I would have liked to retain both for lb depth but neither was a game changer.

The primary issue that led to a poor season was of course injuries. Losing your QB, WR, and top corner early in the year would sink anyone. Number 2 was coaching. Cassel and Weeden should have atleast been able to win a handful of games last season yet we were inept passing the ball. The fact that Weeden could win on a team he barely knew the system for has to point to coaching. Lastly, the interior of the line did a poor job generating pressure and containing the run. This can mask deficiencies at each level and made it tougher on everyone else.
 

Bullflop

Cowboys Diehard
Messages
25,712
Reaction score
30,906
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
It's not complicated. I believe most of the problems that Dallas encountered last season were due to insufficient backup strength to compensate for the losses of players that were unavailable.
 

SilverStarCowboy

The Actualist
Messages
10,337
Reaction score
1,998
It's not complicated. I believe most of the problems that Dallas encountered last season were due to insufficient backup strength to compensate for the losses of players that were unavailable.

I believe its two things then some.

1st off Playmaking WRs, 2ndly Defensive conversion rate.


I'll leave the rest alone because it has nothing to do with on the field.
 
Top