I believe that Schotty picked his new coordinator and he picked the assistants that he wanted. I'd like to see what the board thinks.
Jerry hired Jimmy Johnson, and I’m starting with that because there’s a lot of confusion about how those Super Bowls were won, with all the credit going to Jimmy. If it weren’t for Jerry bringing him in, none of that would’ve happened. Honestly, I don’t think Jimmy would have had the same NFL success if he’d joined a different team in a different situation. That’s a fact. Jerry approves every hire, but he also values input from his coaching staff, letting them share their preferences on candidates to interview, and together they make collaborative decisions on who to bring aboard.
I find it a bit ironic that only the positive stuff gets acknowledged, not just by you but by the fan base as a whole, and you’re going to say it wasn’t Jerry. Jerry owns the team, and he’s involved in every decision, good, bad, or indifferent. He’s the one approving everything, going all the way back to Jimmy Johnson. He hired Jimmy, there never would have been those three Super Bowls without Jerry knowing Jimmy, convincing him to join the Dallas Cowboys. They were friends and teammates in college, and it never would have happened without Jerry. There’s just no getting around that.
I get it, people focus on the negative. You didn’t like Schottenheimer, but because he hired him, you also didn’t like who was brought onto his offensive staff. Yet, you don’t think he ultimately approved Matt Eberflus? Maybe it wasn’t his first choice, but I’m certain he told Jerry, “I can work with him, I’m okay with it.” Whether he was just trying to be a good soldier or not, he absolutely approved it. If he really didn’t want him, he could’ve made it clear, screamed from the rooftops even that he wouldn’t take the job if Matt was hired.
That’s what a coach should do if they feel that strongly.
We know Mike Nolan was hired by Mike McCarthy, but you won’t give Jerry credit because Jerry wanted Kellen Moore and Dan Quinn—better choices than the ones he let coaches pick. Mike Nolan was just as bad as Matt Eberflus. Remember, Mike got his way with Nolan, but Jerry replaced him with Dan Quinn, which was Jerry’s hire. Jerry also wanted to keep Kellen Moore, but in the end, McCarthy wanted to call plays himself, so Kellen was let go. Moore then went on to win a Super Bowl ring with the hated Eagles and now runs his own show. So, who was wrong? That would be McCarthy, he was allowed to do what he wanted, and it failed in the end. Sure, there were three good years in the middle, but that had more to do with Dan Quinn.
I’m going to stay consistent, Jerry approved it,
so in the end he’s the one who signs off on all of these decisions. If you want to give Brian Schottenheimer credit, you’ve got to give it to Jerry first, same with the blame. It doesn’t matter, Jerry hires and fires everyone, probably down to the towel boy. Steven, Jerry, and the rest of the family make all the staff decisions from top to bottom. They do listen to their coaching staff too much, even during the draft. We all know most of those bad picks, were players Jerry had never heard of, he just approved them when they were brought to him.
Good, bad, or indifferent, the coaching staffs are the ones who brought in the bad players and assistants. Jerry approved them, but he didn’t force anything. JJ may have oversold Matt to Brian, but that doesn’t mean it was 100% Jerry’s idea, if Brian didn’t want Matt and spoke up, Jerry probably would have gone along with it.