Well sure, hire a guy whose philosophy is to never try to trick the opponent, when they always do the same against you and expect results is a brilliant move.
You cant will your way to success.
Garrett really shouldn't ever coach again in the league really, yet he is supposed to win here now.
No team would ever consider hiring S Jones or J Jones as GM of their team, yet thats supposed to work too.
Only reason this team is half as good as it is is McClay.
All goes back to the pure ignorance of the owner.