DMN: BLOG: What would you give up for (Det) Roy Williams?

[ABQCOWBOY]

Plain and simple question to all who are interested in this thread.

If Roy Williams were in Dallas, would he be succesful? Would he make our offense better then what it was this year? Yes, or no?

 

[FuzzyLumpkins]

Plain and simple question to all who are interested in this thread.

If Roy Williams were in Dallas, would he be succesful? Would he make our offense better then what it was this year? Yes, or no?

probably but then again hed also probably miss a significant amount of time due to injury.

 

[CF74]

Plain and simple question to all who are interested in this thread.

If Roy Williams were in Dallas, would he be succesful? Would he make our offense better then what it was this year? Yes, or no?

Does a bear do his dookey in the woods?

 

[khiladi]

But then he got hurt just like he did in 04 and 05. Im not saying that he sucks but the injuries hes had are a huge red flag.

he has to go up and catch passes that are thrown by Jon Kitna.... that is asking for trouble....

but seriously, the guy has averaged 14 game seasons ever year he has been in the league... I don't know when this guy got hrut, but I'm sure his missing games was also dictated by whetehr the Lions were in play-off contention or not. There is no reason to risk more injury if your essentially eliminated from the play-offs, like Detroit was last year, when Roy Williams was out during the 4 game stretch.

The guy hasn't had a sever injury that has hurt his performance. What has hrut his performance is being surrounded by an incredibly crappy team, that hasn't had an OL for ages...

 

[slick325]

Plain and simple question to all who are interested in this thread.

If Roy Williams were in Dallas, would he be succesful? Would he make our offense better then what it was this year? Yes, or no?

Great query ABQ. That is all that needs to be asked and answered in this thread. Then make a decision as to what value for the Dallas Cowboys of 2008 and beyond Roy Williams has based on: age, talent, stats, injury history, market value for WR's with his ability, market value in recent years for WR's (what WR's were traded recently, for what and how do they stack up to Roy Williams).

Thanks ABQ.

 

[ZeroClub]

Plain and simple question to all who are interested in this thread.

If Roy Williams were in Dallas, would he be succesful? Would he make our offense better then what it was this year? Yes, or no?

I think the Cowboys need another major threat at WR to go along with Owens. Roy Williams fits that bill. I think they'd be very good together, especially factoring in Witten.

But value is an issue too and I'm not sure what Williams is worth (draft choices, salary cap, injury risk, etc.).

 

[Bob Sacamano]

We start at #28 and go up from that.

I'm w/ you 100% except for this part, I don't think we should start the bidding at a 1st round pick

a 3rd at the least

 

[theogt]

I'm w/ you 100% except for this part, I don't think we should start the bidding at a 1st round pick

a 3rd at the least

Of course, from a negotiating standpoint. But I'm talking about what his value is in terms of what other players have received. Of course we're going to try and get him for a lesser amount.