Is Dak clearly better then all of them? What are you trying prove here? Any of those guys might be able to win in Dallas but more importantly, they might not cost us the highest salary in the League.
might be? that doesn't sound confident. but I listed them not to prove anything, but to have a healthy discussion and debate on why, why not...
do you think Keenum can win? anything at this point? we would be his 7th team....he is nothing but a journey man back up at this point in his career. same goes for fitzgerald. he can't stick anywhere for a reason. including Miami!!!
I don't like Dalton, he hasn't done squat his entire career, same thing everybody is accusing Dak of not having done...do we win with Dalton? probably not. so why even try? oh, to save money, because the objective is to save money not to win
Marriotta is failure. he got benched last year. in 4 years he hasn't accomplished anything and he looks like a bust headed for the role of a journey man from team to team.
I am not sold on Brady. was he good? yes. he was average last year and he needs a lot of strong weapons at this point in his career and lets not forget the bilicheck factor. he has never played in any other system. he is going to be 43. I don't expect us to make any kind of a run this year, even if Brady was here. New players for Brady. new QB. new System for everyone and coaches are new to the players. so at earliest will probably be 2021 when if everything falls in place (big if), then we make a run. is brady at 44 good enough to make a run with us? and he won't be cheap neither. he is not going to be coming in at 20 or 25 mill....
and then there is Stafford.... it would take a trade to get him. and he is older. his record overall is very average. he is coming off a back injury, which put Romo into retirement. do we want to give up valuable draft picks, specially with as many holes as we have to sign a QB coming off critical back injury that sidelines him in the season. and his track record isn't that great and he has a 1-2 playoff record.
so the question is what is Dak's worth. would $33 Mill a year be palatable?