Does this SB change the occurence of the Rodgers vs Romo threads..

[tupperware]

Romo vs Rodgers threads?

Yes, No, Maybe, Who cares?

Just curious.

 

[The30YardSlant]

Romo is a great QB

Rodgers is a great QB with a SB title

That's it. Some people with an agenda will make it out to be more than that, but it isnt.

 

[Beast_from_East]

Romo vs Rodgers threads?

Yes, No, Maybe, Who cares?

Just curious.

No, its not going to change anything.

 

[dbair1967]

Romo is a great QB

Rodgers is a great QB with a SB title

That's it. Some people with an agenda will make it out to be more than that, but it isnt.

sums it up

 

[Dale]

I love Romo, but I don't think there's a debate at this point.

Rodgers is the highest playoff rated QB of all time, no? Romo's career playoff rating is considerably worse than his regular-season showing.

I'll continue to stand by Romo through thick and thin. I think he's a wonderful talent and a guy who has a chance to scratch that "great" label. But he hasn't accomplished what Rodgers has.

 

[realtick]

Never underestimate the depths of denial a homer will go to tout their own and dump on another team's player.

 

[The30YardSlant]

I love Romo, but I don't think there's a debate at this point.

Rodgers is the highest playoff rated QB of all time, no? Romo's career playoff rating is considerably worse than his regular-season showing.

I'll continue to stand by Romo through thick and thin. I think he's a wonderful talent and a guy who has a chance to scratch that "great" label. But he hasn't accomplished what Rodgers has.

See what I mean?

 

[The30YardSlant]

Never under estimate the depths of denial a homer will go to tout their own and dump on another team's player.

Who is dumping on Rodgers? I said he's a great QB.

 

[CATCH17]

Come on.. This debate ended weeks ago. No need to pile on our guy because he is really good too.


Rodgers is just an incredibly talented player. Like a Super Romo.


I would've never thought in 2007 when Rodgers had to come in against us when Nate Jones took out Favre that we would one day be saying he was better than Tony.

Romo was amazing at that time too. Thats why you can't let opportunities slip. The Packers took advantage and kept Pittsburgh within striking distance for us when it comes to Lombardi;s

 

[DallasEast]

Romo vs Rodgers threads?

Yes, No, Maybe, Who cares?

Just curious.

No. Fantasy football is a modern day affliction.

 

[realtick]

Who is dumping on Rodgers? I said he's a great QB.

Not saying you. There is another thread "Rodgers, Brady, Romo...." that's 400+ posts long with people doing that.

 

[The30YardSlant]

I would've never thought in 2007 when Rodgers had to come in against us when Nate Jones took out Favre that we would one day be saying he was better than Tony

People are saying he's better than Tony because it's an easy thing to say, just like it's easy for some people to say Bradshaw was better than Staubach

If Staubach had played on those Steeler teams, he'd have more rings. If Romo played on this years Packers team, he'd have a ring. Romo has played the majority of his career under a coaching staff that didnt prepare their team for the postseason and a defense that was rarely as consistent as this year's Packers unit.

But, Romo is a "choker" because he bobbled a snap once

Both Romo and Rodgers are great QBs

 

[Dale]

See what I mean?

If Romo wins the Super Bowl next year, is he not instantly -- and undeniably -- better than Rivers?

Levels of greatness are always in great flux. Rodgers right now is on the top of the world. If he follows this up with two crappy seasons, who will be in his corner three years from now?

Roy Williams once was the best safety in the game. He very quickly became something else.

Romo has had a pretty darn good career, and has a real chance to accomplish something great. But any Super Bowl winning QB who wins it in the style of a Manning, Brady -- and maybe even Rodgers -- will have something up on him until he joins their group.

Not sure why the flippant response from you, quite frankly. Saying that a Super Bowl-winning, Super Bowl MVP QB might just be better than Romo isn't exactly a slap in the face of our franchise QB.

 

[CATCH17]

I love Romo, but I don't think there's a debate at this point.

Rodgers is the highest playoff rated QB of all time, no? Romo's career playoff rating is considerably worse than his regular-season showing.

I'll continue to stand by Romo through thick and thin. I think he's a wonderful talent and a guy who has a chance to scratch that "great" label. But he hasn't accomplished what Rodgers has.

Dude! Hello! Nice to see you on here again..

 

[dadymat]

i still believe Romo is just as good

 

[Cowboys&LakersFan]

Of course it does.

 

[The30YardSlant]

If Romo wins the Super Bowl next year, is he not instantly -- and undeniably -- better than Rivers?

Just because he won a Superbowl? Absolutely not. That is the mindset of an uneducated fan.

Was Brad Johnson better than Dan Marino? Just as good as Brett Favre? At ANY point in any of their respective careers?

 

[Cowboy Junkie]

Romo vs Rodgers threads?

Yes, No, Maybe, Who cares?

Just curious.

I think this Off season ESPN really digs into the Romo is not Rodgers topic

 

[Dale]

People are saying he's better than Tony because it's an easy thing to say, just like it's easy for some people to say Bradshaw was better than Staubach

If Staubach had played on those Steeler teams, he'd have more rings. If Romo played on this years Packers team, he'd have a ring. Romo has played the majority of his career under a coaching staff that didnt prepare their team for the postseason and a defense that was rarely as consistent as this year's Packers unit.

But, Romo is a "choker" because he bobbled a snap once

Both Romo and Rodgers are great QBs

Who in this thread has called Romo a choker?

Rodgers is a great QB who has achieved something Romo hasn't. Fortunately, Romo still has a chance to get there. I'm confident he can do it.

 

[Dale]

Just because he won a Superbowl? Absolutely not. That is the mindset of an uneducated fan.

Was Brad Johnson better than Dan Marino? Just as good as Brett Favre? At ANY point in any of their respective careers?

You're grasping for straws, my friend. Go back and read what I said -- a Super Bowl winning QB who won it in the style of Rodgers. Not a guy who sat back, drank a beer and just didn't screw up too much.

Trying to bring Brad Johnson, Trent Dilfer, Jeff Hostetler and the likes is a weak retort and you know it. Rodgers clearly is better than those types of Super Bowl winning QBs.

If Romo goes out and wins a Super Bowl in the style of Rodgers, he'll be rightfully lauded as one of the premier QBs. If he wins it like Trent Dilfer, his national standing won't be a discussion.