JonCJG
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 2,175
- Reaction score
- 162
casmith07;3818262 said:I think Amukamara is better than Peterson if we're looking for a CB.
casmith07;3818262 said:I think Amukamara is better than Peterson if we're looking for a CB.
I think if we're wanting Peterson to play FS, he's a good pick.
There's also no way Cam Newton gets past Arizona at #5 unless he has a tank of a workout.
TheCount;3818421 said:I don't see what reason there is to think that other than Peterson's weight, care to elaborate?
I'm not saying that may not be the case, but it seems a lot of people have made up their mind Peterson can't play CB, and it's not even based on his play but his physical statistics.
CanuckCowboysFan;3818481 said:Because it is humanly impossible for him to cover smaller quick receivers at that size. No change of direction/stiff hips.
Cam Newtoncasmith07;3818262 said:I think Amukamara is better than Peterson if we're looking for a CB.
I think if we're wanting Peterson to play FS, he's a good pick.
There's also no way Cam Newton gets past Arizona at #5 unless he has a tank of a workout.
CanuckCowboysFan;3818507 said:So? There good for a guy his size. But not good enough to cover small quick receivers, as opposed to a smaller cornerback.
TheCount;3818514 said:I didn't see "good for a guy his size" listed as a pro of his either. Bad hips would probably go a long way in getting you removed from the conversation as the top rated corner in the draft.
I don't agree with that but everyone has their opinion.CanuckCowboysFan;3818533 said:HE DOESNT HAVE BAD HIPS. There just not good enough( especially at his size) to cover a Steve Smith. A guy his size is limited in what he can do as a corner.
CanuckCowboysFan;3818533 said:HE DOESNT HAVE BAD HIPS. There just not good enough( especially at his size) to cover a Steve Smith. A guy his size is limited in what he can do as a corner.
burmafrd;3818551 said:Show me a top CB that is that big.
TheCount;3818546 said:Okay, so every corner that can't shut down Desean Jackson and Steve Smith should be a safety. Gotcha.![]()
TheCount;3818614 said:Nnamdi Asomugha is 6'2" 210.
But as usual, my point isn't that Peterson is destined for greatness. My point is not to rule a guy out based PURELY on his physical statistics.
I don't know how many guys have to prove something like that silly before people get it.
Saying a guy CAN'T do something based not on his play, but because he weighs more (or less) than you'd like is just silly.
