KJJ
You Have an Axe to Grind
- Messages
- 62,266
- Reaction score
- 39,494
Right, you were comparing McFadden to a long list of HOF running backs.
Yep, an average back put up 1,000+ yards/4.6 YPC in 11 games behind the best OL in football. Had he started the other five, he would have went for 1,500+. Had he had Romo or even an average NFL starter he would have surpassed that.
You're making McFadden out to be a great back. You claimed he could have had 1600 yards rushing last season with Romo which would have had him leading the entire league in rushing. lol You proved my point by saying Sammie Smith sucked and not even the great Dan Marino could make him a solid back. I brought up several great backs that had very productive HOF careers with average to bad QB situations and also brought up Jamal Lewis and Chris Johnson who'll never be elected to the HOF that had 2000 yard seasons despite bad QB situations. The Cowboys were looking for a great back which is why they drafted Zeke. We're not going any further until you answer these questions. If you keep dancing, I'll keep asking.
If a QB makes that big a difference to an RBs success then explain how Eric Dickerson, Barry Sanders, Walter Payton, Jim Brown, Earl Campbell and Adrian Peterson had so much production and HOF careers playing with average to bad QBs? If the QB makes the RB, how did Jamal Lewis rush for 2066 yards in 2003 with Kyle Boller and Anthony Wright? Go look at the numbers those QBs put up. If the QB makes that big a difference for a RB how did Chris Johnson rush for 2006 yards with Vince Young and Kerry Collins? Both were terrible!