Edwards vs. Roy comparison

[Clarkson]

Please stop posting.

The hands are the only argument that's even close, and Roy doesn't have great hands. Braylon doesn't have bad hands. But Braylon is a much better playmaker. Faster, stronger, better route runner. He will have a better season than Roy, and Roy will never have a season like Braylon did in '07.

If you think Roy is somehow better than Braylon, then you're just a delusional homer. That's all.

 

[jwitten82]

The hands are the only argument that's even close, and Roy doesn't have great hands. Braylon doesn't have bad hands. But Braylon is a much better playmaker. Faster, stronger, better route runner. He will have a better season than Roy, and Roy will never have a season like Braylon did in '07.

If you think Roy is somehow better than Braylon, then you're just a delusional homer. That's all.

The hands argument isnt' even close.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

He had two GREAT catches and dropped a TOUCHDOWN. I hardly saw Bralyon dominate the competition. Roy has had similar games with less targets. YOu must be watching the ESPN highlights. LEt's see what he does in further weeks. I knew after those two great catches we were going to have a thread about Roy Williams. Not to mention Roy was a #2 last year. Don't forget that.

 

[rkell87]

4th year Sanchez > 4th year Romo

QFT

oh and at your sig the same could be said about any QB

 

[rkell87]

The hands are the only argument that's even close, and Roy doesn't have great hands. Braylon doesn't have bad hands. But Braylon is a much better playmaker. Faster, stronger, better route runner. He will have a better season than Roy, and Roy will never have a season like Braylon did in '07.

If you think Roy is somehow better than Braylon, then you're just a delusional homer. That's all.

roy williams '06 821,31016.0


edwards '07 801,28916.1


looks like the exact same season to me...and that was with joey harrington throwing to him.

dont come back with the TD argument that your going to make cause his team was good that year when his team was bad his TDs are 3,6,3 and the lions have been worse every year

 

[SharutoX]

I'd take Edwards over Roy any day.

 

[gbrittain]

Let me make sure I understand this. Braylon goes out and catches 5 passes for 64 yards and a TD.

I am fairly certain that if he has a game in which he catches 2 passes for 21 yards this thread never gets created.

So essentially 5 catches, 64 yards and a TD and all of a sudden the rueing has already begun?

If there should be any rueing based off of one stinking game shouldn't the Jets be rueing Miles Austin 10 catches, 250 yards, and 2 TDs in a single game?

Now that is some rueing.

 

[Q_the_man]

1st and 3rd for Roy or.....
3rd and 5th for Braylon.....Just by that trade I would take Braylon all day....

 

[dfense]

Actually, imagine how pissed Brown fan is. Edwards is making big money and can't catch a cold. Then he goes to another team and has fly paper on his fingers.

Was he dogging it just to get out of town? And I'm sure he's going to talk about wanting to prove something to the Browns. Prove what? That you got overpaid for shoddy work these last few years?

 

[Mr.davon24]

I thought it takes weeks, if not months for a qb to get in sync with his wr? Braylon Edwards joined his new teammates Tuesday and caught five balls for over seventy yards and a td with limited snaps.

Our #1 WR has caught thirty balls and exactly two td's in fourteen games with the Cowboys.

I guess while watching the game you'd would have caught the fact that Cleveland and NYJ runs basically the same O.... It wasn't hard for him to step in.

 

[ThreeSportStar80]

they played miami... dont crown him just yet...

Miami is a solid team, they aren't the KC's of the world...

 

[DatNguyen59]

Edwards is better than Roy. It's not even close. He's faster, has better hands, runs better routes, and goes up and gets the ball better.

Errrrrrrr! Stop right there with that nonsense.

 

[SLATEmosphere]

Braylon for a 3rd and 5th>>>>Roy Williams for a first and 3rd

/thread

 

[casmith07]

Yeah.

Epic 50% completion percentage against a god-awful secondary.

He also gets the rock to Saints DBs.

:laugh1:

 

[casmith07]

Let me make sure I understand this. Braylon goes out and catches 5 passes for 64 yards and a TD.

I am fairly certain that if he has a game in which he catches 2 passes for 21 yards this thread never gets created.

So essentially 5 catches, 64 yards and a TD and all of a sudden the rueing has already begun?

If there should be any rueing based off of one stinking game shouldn't the Jets be rueing Miles Austin 10 catches, 250 yards, and 2 TDs in a single game?

Now that is some rueing.

Especially because the Jets went after him this off-season, and we've never been interested in Braylon "stone hands" Edwards.

 

[casmith07]

Braylon for a 3rd and 5th>>>>Roy Williams for a first and 3rd

/thread

The Browns traded Edwards for 3rd, 5th, WR Chansi Stuckey, and LB Jason Trusnik.

Just want to make sure you got the rest of the trade in there instead of blindly cutting off part of the deal.

 

[Sarge]

Edwards is better than Roy. It's not even close. He's faster, has better hands, runs better routes, and goes up and gets the ball better.

Edwards drops a TON of balls.

 

[SLATEmosphere]

The Browns traded Edwards for 3rd, 5th, WR Chansi Stuckey, and LB Jason Trusnik.

Just want to make sure you got the rest of the trade in there instead of blindly cutting off part of the deal.

The other two are Googlers and arn't relevent.

Braylon was traded for a 3rd and 5th

/thread

 

[gbrittain]

The other two are Googlers and arn't relevent.

Braylon was traded for a 3rd and 5th

/thread

You love you some Braylon we get it.

/ Thread

as you like to say.

 

[SLATEmosphere]

You love you some Braylon we get it.

/ Thread

as you like to say.

I love me some First Round picks.

/Thread