ESPN Bill Simmons Power Rankings...

CowboyWay

If Coach would have put me in, we'd a won State
Messages
4,445
Reaction score
554
http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/page2/story?page=simmons/080926

NFC East ranks.......
17. Washington Commanders
They just beat the Saints and Cardinals, so, um ... yeah. You know what scares me about the Commanders other than the fact Dan Snyder is a stubbier, less successful Mark Cuban? Poor Jim Zorn looks like he's wound tighter than a substitute teacher at Watts High. And it's not like a Mike Shanahan thing in which it looks like he's trying to melt a referee's brain; it's more of a "Don Draper running into an old friend from the Korean war back when everyone called him Dicky" type of nervous intensity, like he's battling a complex about never having been a head coach before. If Dallas beats the Skins by 25 this Sunday, I could see Zorn screaming, "I'm in charge here! OK? All right? I am the one in charge!!!!!!" and losing the locker room for good. He should start drinking red wine during games. I don't see this ending well.
(The good news: When Bill Cowher takes the job, CBS will have a four-man studio show again. That's right, more air time for Shannon Sharpe! Every one of his sentences should be preceded by a dentist saying, "You should start feeling the Novocain right about now.")


4. New York Giants
You might remember my writing last week, "Did you notice the Brady-Manning-Brees-Palmer-McNabb Era suddenly has the Romo-Rivers-Cutler-Roethlisberger-Rodgers Era breathing down its neck?" Of all the agitated e-mails from Giants fans over the next few days, this one from Rich in Stamford, Conn., was my favorite: "You and I both know you purposely left Eli Manning out of the second part of that sentence, you bitter [expletive]."

Guilty as charged! I still think the G-Men have a chance to become the first-ever "Nobody Still Believed In Us!" Team ... although it's hard to watch their defense (really good, not great) and not think, "Man, what if Strahan and Osi were playing?" And how will this Plax thing affect them? Will it blow over or keep festering? You know it's worse than we're being led to believe because Steve Smith uttered the dreaded "Plax is Plax, he does what he wants. ... We never know when it comes to Plax" quote this week.

Plax is Plax?

This has always been one of Adam Carolla's greatest theories -- any time someone describes a co-worker by saying their name twice (like "Plax is Plax"), that's code for either "This guy is one of the biggest a-holes in the history of mankind" or "This guy is one of the stupidest, most confusing and most inexplicable human beings I've ever met." Manny Ramirez, Barry Bonds, Steve Smith, Alex Rodriguez, Kobe Bryant, Stephon Marbury, Dennis Rodman, Chad Johnson ... they've all been slapped with the "[Name] is [Name]" quote over the years. It's never a good sign. For that reason alone (as well as the four upcoming games against Philly and Dallas), I can't put them ahead of ...

2. Philadelphia Eagles
We have to take the Eagles seriously after their defense put up a Wilt-like triple-double against "Ben" last week: 57 hits, 39 hurries and 17 sacks (all numbers approximate). Throw in their big-play guys, McNabb's revival, Brian "The Reuben" Westbrook, the impending return of two more receivers (Reggie Brown and Kevin Curtis) and these guys look dangerous. Of course, they can't beat these guys ...


1. Dallas Cowboys
The Cowboys do one thing (score points) better than anyone does anything else. Now that they have Miles Austin going as a much-needed third receiver, really, the only guy who can stop this offense is Tony Romo. What do we make of this guy? Will he ever stop self-destructing in big moments? Why does he keep forcing those "Brett Favre circa 2001-2006" throws when the Cowboys are in the red zone? And if you want to flip it around, what happens when he stops making dumb mistakes and just starts cranking out 228 mph laps with this Ferrari he's driving right now? I think we can safely say that, after three weeks, barring injuries, the 2008 NFL season rests in the hands of Jessica Simpson's boyfriend. Now that's weird.
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,666
Reaction score
86,211
Why would being like Brett Favre, one of the best QB's to ever friggin play, be a bad thing?

If Romo was playing like this in a Packer uniform people would dismiss it I GUARANTEE it.

Romo just isn't a problem. Hes one of our bigger strengths. Without him we are screwed.
 

adbutcher

K9NME
Messages
12,287
Reaction score
2,910
CATCH17;2287506 said:
Why would being like Brett Favre, one of the best QB's to ever friggin play, be a bad thing?

If Romo was playing like this in a Packer uniform people would dismiss it I GUARANTEE it.

Romo just isn't a problem. Hes one of our bigger strengths. Without him we are screwed.

:hammer:
 

YosemiteSam

Unfriendly and Aloof!
Messages
45,858
Reaction score
22,189
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
CATCH17;2287506 said:
Why would being like Brett Favre, one of the best QB's to ever friggin play, be a bad thing?

Oh thats easy. Brett was feast or famine. He was either REALLY good or REALLY bad. He throws INTs in bunches. Hardly ever did he only throw one. Once you're in the playoffs, one bad game spells doom. For such a great QB who had some really good teams, he will walk away with only one super bowl.
 

Danny White

Winter is Coming
Messages
12,497
Reaction score
391
Another interesting comment from the same column:

here's my list of running backs who put the fear of God in you every time they get the ball if you either gambled against them, you're rooting for the other team or you're going against them in fantasy: (1) Adrian Peterson, (2) Reggie Bush, (3) LaDainian Tomlinson (if healthy), (4) Felix Jones, (5) Chris Johnson and (537) Deuce McAllister.
 

bootyhunta

Active Member
Messages
553
Reaction score
171
CATCH17;2287506 said:
Why would being like Brett Favre, one of the best QB's to ever friggin play, be a bad thing?

He only won ONE superbowl... i'm hoping Romo will be able to win a few more.
 

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
nyc;2287570 said:
Oh thats easy. Brett was feast or famine. He was either REALLY good or REALLY bad. He throws INTs in bunches. Hardly ever did he only throw one. Once you're in the playoffs, one bad game spells doom. For such a great QB who had some really good teams, he will walk away with only one super bowl.

What he said.
 

DaBoys4Life

Benched
Messages
15,626
Reaction score
0
CATCH17;2287506 said:
Why would being like Brett Favre, one of the best QB's to ever friggin play, be a bad thing?

If Romo was playing like this in a Packer uniform people would dismiss it I GUARANTEE it.

Romo just isn't a problem. Hes one of our bigger strengths. Without him we are screwed.

Brett Farve I could name about 10 QB's i'd rather have that Brett in his prime.
 

RainMan

Makin' It Rain
Messages
3,125
Reaction score
0
Did Romo really self destruct in "big moments" the last two weeks?
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,666
Reaction score
86,211
Having Brett Favre is far from a bad thing.

Hes one of the best QB's of all time. Hes incredible, face it.

His good FAAAAAaaaar out-weighs his bad.

All that being said Romo isn't Favre but in a lot of ways his game resembles it.

He can be like Tom Brady in the pocket and Brett Favre out of it.

Please be the idiot that says, "you think Romo is as good as Brady and Favre combined."
 

DallasEast

Cowboys 24/7/365
Staff member
Messages
62,335
Reaction score
64,033
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
RainMan;2287598 said:
Did Romo really self destruct in "big moments" the last two weeks?
In my opinion? No. In my book, a "big moment" is a decisive point of any game. Romo has stumbled some against the Eagles and Packers, but not during any of the critical portions of those games.
 

R8erFan4Ever

New Member
Messages
156
Reaction score
0
nyc;2287570 said:
Oh thats easy. Brett was feast or famine. He was either REALLY good or REALLY bad. He throws INTs in bunches. Hardly ever did he only throw one. Once you're in the playoffs, one bad game spells doom. For such a great QB who had some really good teams, he will walk away with only one super bowl.


well said.
 

DaBoys4Life

Benched
Messages
15,626
Reaction score
0
CATCH17;2287612 said:
Having Brett Favre is far from a bad thing.

Hes one of the best QB's of all time. Hes incredible, face it.

His good FAAAAAaaaar out-weighs his bad.

All that being said Romo isn't Favre but in a lot of ways his game resembles it.

He can be like Tom Brady in the pocket and Brett Favre out of it.

Please be the idiot that says, "you think Romo is as good as Brady and Favre combined."

I don't think so he has the numbers however I really wouldn't say he's the best ever. There are QB's I'd rather have than him as it stand now he not even in my top ten.
 

skinsscalper

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,146
Reaction score
5,693
CATCH17;2287612 said:
Having Brett Favre is far from a bad thing.

Hes one of the best QB's of all time. Hes incredible, face it.

His good FAAAAAaaaar out-weighs his bad.

All that being said Romo isn't Favre but in a lot of ways his game resembles it.

He can be like Tom Brady in the pocket and Brett Favre out of it.

Please be the idiot that says, "you think Romo is as good as Brady and Favre combined."

Brett Favre has skills. Even the dumbest of people know that, but let's face a little truth here: The only person who chokes more in big games than Favre is McNabb (and McNabb us catching up).
 

BrAinPaiNt

Mike Smith aka Backwoods Sexy
Staff member
Messages
78,654
Reaction score
43,000
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
from article said:
(The good news: When Bill Cowher takes the job, CBS will have a four-man studio show again. That's right, more air time for Shannon Sharpe! Every one of his sentences should be preceded by a dentist saying, "You should start feeling the Novocain right about now.")

:laugh2: :laugh2:

About the Romo/Favre thing.

I think it is plain to anyone who watches the cowboys that Romo has his Gunslinger/Favre moments.

There are times when he makes these plays and they work and you are just in awe of them...in a good way.

There are times when he makes these plays and they backfire and you are just in awe of them...in an angry way.

And there are times when he makes them plays and you are in awe in a good way but at the same time you think to yourself...that was a really dumb thing to do but thank my lucky stars that it actually worked.

Romo is a good QB but he does have his gunslinger/favre moments.
 

Idgit

Fattening up
Staff member
Messages
58,971
Reaction score
60,826
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
As someone who consistently defended Troy Aikman v. Brett Favre and Emmitt Smiff v. Barry Sanders, I have a hard time supporting feast-or-famine decision making now just because I love Romo and love the Cowboys. I will say that I think Romo is smart enough to fix the few problems he's got, and that we're really lucky to have him regardless.

Gotta love Cowboy fans disputing the reasoning in a thread about our #1 power ranking.
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,666
Reaction score
86,211
DaBoys4Life;2287634 said:
I don't think so he has the numbers however I really wouldn't say he's the best ever. There are QB's I'd rather have than him as it stand now he not even in my top ten.

I didn't say he was the best ever.

And as far being feast or famine hes had so many feasts that when he goes famine you'd still be obese.
 

Temo

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,946
Reaction score
362
CATCH17;2287612 said:
Having Brett Favre is far from a bad thing.

Hes one of the best QB's of all time. Hes incredible, face it.

His good FAAAAAaaaar out-weighs his bad.

All that being said Romo isn't Favre but in a lot of ways his game resembles it.

He can be like Tom Brady in the pocket and Brett Favre out of it.

Please be the idiot that says, "you think Romo is as good as Brady and Favre combined."

Here's the thing though: Romo is nothing like Brady in the pocket. Brady does not throw balls into triple coverage. Ever.

He's like Favre inside and outside the pocket.
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,666
Reaction score
86,211
Idgit;2287643 said:
As someone who consistently defended Troy Aikman v. Brett Favre and Emmitt Smiff v. Barry Sanders, I have a hard time supporting feast-or-famine decision making now just because I love Romo and love the Cowboys. I will say that I think Romo is smart enough to fix the few problems he's got, and that we're really lucky to have him regardless.

Gotta love Cowboy fans disputing the reasoning in a thread about our #1 power ranking.

Exactly.

Also Romo knows if he is making mistakes he can step back and let the guys around him take over.

Favre never really had that on Offense.

They put together some great defenses in Green Bay but their old GM said one of his biggest mistakes was not getting enough weapons for Brett.

----

All that aside Romo is Romo and Favre is Favre.
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,666
Reaction score
86,211
Temo;2287647 said:
Here's the thing though: Romo is nothing like Brady in the pocket. Brady does not throw balls into triple coverage. Ever.

He's like Favre inside and outside the pocket.

Actually he kinda is.

And just because he throws it into thick coverage once or twice a game doesn't mean his style in the pocket isn't similar.
 
Top