Ezekiel Elliott Appreciation Thread **merged**

SDCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,763
Reaction score
22,734
Zeke is beasting. I can't even imagine how good he'll likely be by the end of the season.
 

KB1122

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,328
Reaction score
1,629
I know. 150 last week. 140 this week. He's obviously good. But I'm not convinced he's top-5-draft-pick-good. He lacks the Dorsett burst. He had 140 yards. But the holes were gigantic and with better breakaway speed he should have had 180-200, maybe more, with a couple of touchdowns. There were at least three big runs where a top-5 talent should have turned on the jets and scored. There was one on the drive where Dorsett would have scored easily. Smith would have been tackled inside the five. I think McFadden would have scored.

I can't complain too much, because he's obviously productive. But he strikes me as a quality third-round mudder that we used an elite draft pick on. I think I might rather have Buckner and the right third-round back. I'm just not convinced that he's worth the draft capital we spent on him.

Just MO. Figure it's an interesting conversation.
 

Blackspider214

Well-Known Member
Messages
13,130
Reaction score
15,994
I know. 150 last week. 140 this week. He's obviously good. But I'm not convinced he's top-5-draft-pick-good. He lacks the Dorsett burst. He had 140 yards. But the holes were gigantic and with better breakaway speed he should have had 180-200, maybe more, with a couple of touchdowns. There were at least three big runs where a top-5 talent should have turned on the jets and scored. There was one on the drive where Dorsett would have scored easily. Smith would have been tackled inside the five. I think McFadden would have scored.

I can't complain too much, because he's obviously productive. But he strikes me as a quality third-round mudder that we used an elite draft pick on. I think I might rather have Buckner and the right third-round back. I'm just not convinced that he's worth the draft capital we spent on him.

Just MO. Figure it's an interesting conversation.

f1a6b8e0_MichaelScottClosingDoor.gif
 
Last edited:

SHAMSzy

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,323
Reaction score
3,216
He has looked flat out dominant past two games. You can see he is getting more comfortable. By the end of the season he will be putting up ridiculous numbers!!
 

KB1122

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,328
Reaction score
1,629

You can laugh, but he left four points on the board on the last drive.

It's like the Kirk Cousins completion against us, where it was a big gain, but it should have been a touchdown, then we got the interception in the end zone.
 

LittleBoyBlue

Redvolution
Messages
35,766
Reaction score
8,411
He showed heart and fire... burst and exolosivenesss.

I'm good.


Give these guys more than 2 minutes before we express major disappointment.
 

Toruk_Makto

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,242
Reaction score
17,336
I know. 150 last week. 140 this week. He's obviously good. But I'm not convinced he's top-5-draft-pick-good. He lacks the Dorsett burst. He had 140 yards. But the holes were gigantic and with better breakaway speed he should have had 180-200, maybe more, with a couple of touchdowns. There were at least three big runs where a top-5 talent should have turned on the jets and scored. There was one on the drive where Dorsett would have scored easily. Smith would have been tackled inside the five. I think McFadden would have scored.

I can't complain too much, because he's obviously productive. But he strikes me as a quality third-round mudder that we used an elite draft pick on. I think I might rather have Buckner and the right third-round back. I'm just not convinced that he's worth the draft capital we spent on him.

Just MO. Figure it's an interesting conversation.
I mean he isn't worth a top 5 pick. Becuase he's likely to get injured and or not be worth his 2nd contract.

But he looks great now. So all we can do is hope he continues this type of production for a decade.
 

NickZepp

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,851
Reaction score
2,082
I know. 150 last week. 140 this week. He's obviously good. But I'm not convinced he's top-5-draft-pick-good. He lacks the Dorsett burst. He had 140 yards. But the holes were gigantic and with better breakaway speed he should have had 180-200, maybe more, with a couple of touchdowns. There were at least three big runs where a top-5 talent should have turned on the jets and scored. There was one on the drive where Dorsett would have scored easily. Smith would have been tackled inside the five. I think McFadden would have scored.

I can't complain too much, because he's obviously productive. But he strikes me as a quality third-round mudder that we used an elite draft pick on. I think I might rather have Buckner and the right third-round back. I'm just not convinced that he's worth the draft capital we spent on him.

Just MO. Figure it's an interesting conversation.

Dorsett as a rookie had 2 100 yard games(one of which was actually 200+) Elliott did fumble it twice against Washington but if didn't we are looking at 3 100 yard games in 4 rookie games. Dorsett wasn't quite Dorsett as a rookie.
 
Top